cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-WATCHDOG] System Health Report (Cycle 21) #5915

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 11:44:59 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 11 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 11:44:59 +00:00

Owner

System Watchdog Health Report — Cycle 21 (2-Hour Summary)

Agent: system-watchdog
Instance: watchdog-1
Cycles Completed: 20 (Cycles 1-20)
Reporting Period: 2026-04-09T07:20Z — 2026-04-09T11:40Z (~140 minutes)
Status: 🟢 Active — Continuous monitoring

Executive Summary

The system is operationally healthy at the infrastructure level. Master CI has been green throughout. Two merges occurred (PR #5614 docs at 09:22Z). Human developer Rui Hu is actively contributing (PR #5659 with 13+ comments). Bug-hunter pool was restarted and is now filing issues.

Key Metrics (Cycles 13-20)

✅ Master CI: GREEN

Latest commit: a3762a4 (docs: invariant-reconciliation module guide)
All CI checks passing

✅ Merges This Period

PR #5614 merged at 09:22Z (docs-writer: invariant-reconciliation module guide)
PR #5717 closed (not merged — duplicate spec fix)

🔔 Human Developer Activity

PR #5659 (Rui Hu): 13+ comments, multiple updates, actively addressing review feedback
Issue #5863 created by prior watchdog to track e2e test fix needed for PR #5659

✅ Bug-Hunter Pool RESTARTED

Restarted by product-builder (Cycle 15)
Now filing issues: #5847 (silent error suppression), #5897 (broad exception in A2aEventQueue)

⚠️ Test-Infra-Improver Pool: STILL BLOCKED

Pool supervisor blocked by bash security restrictions (Cycles 6, 8, 11)
Workers ARE producing findings independently
Proposals #5413/#5432 pending human approval

⚠️ Duplicate Labels: CONFIRMED WIDESPREAD

Issues #5862, #5863 have both org-level AND repo-level labels
Proposal #5763 to fix architecture-guard, bug-hunter, test-infra-improver pending human approval

Critical Issues Tracked (Cycles 13-20)

Issue	Severity	Status
#5444 — plan apply broken	Critical	Tracked
#5598 — LangGraph reimplemented with RxPy	Critical	Tracked
#5619 — AutomationGuard never enforced	Critical	Tracked
#5809 — Audit log schema missing event_id/signature	Critical	NEW (Cycle 16)
#5865 — prompt_definition root decision never recorded	Critical	NEW (Cycle 19)
#5864 — InMemoryGraphIndexBackend.query() ignores SPARQL	Critical	NEW (Cycle 19)
#5899 — decision_dependencies not persisted to DB	Critical	NEW (Cycle 20)
#5901 — MainScreen class missing (TUI)	Critical	NEW (Cycle 20)
#5366 — integration tests blocked	CI Blocker	Tracked
#5630 — 62 robot helpers use mocking	High	Tracked
#5363 — coverage 84.42%	High	Tracked

Architecture Supervisor Findings (Cycle 3)

12 spec PRs awaiting human approval
4 key architectural concerns:
1. Context strategy duplication (#5495)
2. SandboxManager persistence (#5721)
3. session tell stub (#5784)
4. A2A ASGI server (#5390)

Findings Summary (Cycles 13-20)

Severity	Count	Key Types
CRITICAL	6	audit_log_schema, prompt_definition, sparql_ignored, decision_deps, tui_mainscreen, automation_guard
HIGH	2	duplicate_labels_widespread, test_infra_blocked
MEDIUM	1	test_infra_pool_blocked
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken (Cycles 13-20)

Monitored PR #5659 (human PR) through multiple update cycles
Noted bug-hunter pool restart and new findings
Confirmed duplicate label problem
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

# System Watchdog Health Report — Cycle 21 (2-Hour Summary) **Agent**: system-watchdog **Instance**: watchdog-1 **Cycles Completed**: 20 (Cycles 1-20) **Reporting Period**: 2026-04-09T07:20Z — 2026-04-09T11:40Z (~140 minutes) **Status**: 🟢 Active — Continuous monitoring ## Executive Summary The system is **operationally healthy** at the infrastructure level. Master CI has been green throughout. Two merges occurred (PR #5614 docs at 09:22Z). Human developer Rui Hu is actively contributing (PR #5659 with 13+ comments). Bug-hunter pool was restarted and is now filing issues. --- ## Key Metrics (Cycles 13-20) ### ✅ Master CI: GREEN - Latest commit: `a3762a4` (docs: invariant-reconciliation module guide) - All CI checks passing ### ✅ Merges This Period - PR #5614 merged at 09:22Z (docs-writer: invariant-reconciliation module guide) - PR #5717 closed (not merged — duplicate spec fix) ### 🔔 Human Developer Activity - PR #5659 (Rui Hu): 13+ comments, multiple updates, actively addressing review feedback - Issue #5863 created by prior watchdog to track e2e test fix needed for PR #5659 ### ✅ Bug-Hunter Pool RESTARTED - Restarted by product-builder (Cycle 15) - Now filing issues: #5847 (silent error suppression), #5897 (broad exception in A2aEventQueue) ### ⚠️ Test-Infra-Improver Pool: STILL BLOCKED - Pool supervisor blocked by bash security restrictions (Cycles 6, 8, 11) - Workers ARE producing findings independently - Proposals #5413/#5432 pending human approval ### ⚠️ Duplicate Labels: CONFIRMED WIDESPREAD - Issues #5862, #5863 have both org-level AND repo-level labels - Proposal #5763 to fix architecture-guard, bug-hunter, test-infra-improver pending human approval --- ## Critical Issues Tracked (Cycles 13-20) | Issue | Severity | Status | |-------|----------|--------| | #5444 — plan apply broken | Critical | Tracked | | #5598 — LangGraph reimplemented with RxPy | Critical | Tracked | | #5619 — AutomationGuard never enforced | Critical | Tracked | | #5809 — Audit log schema missing event_id/signature | Critical | NEW (Cycle 16) | | #5865 — prompt_definition root decision never recorded | Critical | NEW (Cycle 19) | | #5864 — InMemoryGraphIndexBackend.query() ignores SPARQL | Critical | NEW (Cycle 19) | | #5899 — decision_dependencies not persisted to DB | Critical | NEW (Cycle 20) | | #5901 — MainScreen class missing (TUI) | Critical | NEW (Cycle 20) | | #5366 — integration tests blocked | CI Blocker | Tracked | | #5630 — 62 robot helpers use mocking | High | Tracked | | #5363 — coverage 84.42% | High | Tracked | ## Architecture Supervisor Findings (Cycle 3) - 12 spec PRs awaiting human approval - 4 key architectural concerns: 1. Context strategy duplication (#5495) 2. SandboxManager persistence (#5721) 3. session tell stub (#5784) 4. A2A ASGI server (#5390) ## Findings Summary (Cycles 13-20) | Severity | Count | Key Types | |----------|-------|-----------| | CRITICAL | 6 | audit_log_schema, prompt_definition, sparql_ignored, decision_deps, tui_mainscreen, automation_guard | | HIGH | 2 | duplicate_labels_widespread, test_infra_blocked | | MEDIUM | 1 | test_infra_pool_blocked | | LOW | 0 | — | ## Actions Taken (Cycles 13-20) - Monitored PR #5659 (human PR) through multiple update cycles - Noted bug-hunter pool restart and new findings - Confirmed duplicate label problem - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 added the

labels

2026-04-09 11:48:04 +00:00

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 12:02:07 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 21 Audit — 2026-04-09T11:58Z

Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4`

No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z)
CI checks passing

Agent Evolver Cycle 19 Summary

21 proposals pending human approval
Noting issue #5863 (watchdog-created) has Automation Tracking label misuse — broader pattern
PR #4617 needs reimplementation (REQUEST_CHANGES)
Approval rate: 4.8% (1/21)

New UAT Bugs (Cycle 3 — v3.0.0/v3.1.0 features)

#5934 — agents resource remove doesn't check project links (spec violation)
#5932 — agents plan explain JSON output missing spec-required envelope and structured fields

Test-Infra-Improver Findings

#5935 — Add Robot integration tests for cli module
#5936 — Manual dependency security review required

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	0	—
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	1	automation_tracking_label_misuse_broader (watchdog-created issues)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Monitoring CI on a3762a4
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 21 Audit — 2026-04-09T11:58Z ### Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4` - No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z) - CI checks passing ### Agent Evolver Cycle 19 Summary - 21 proposals pending human approval - Noting issue #5863 (watchdog-created) has Automation Tracking label misuse — broader pattern - PR #4617 needs reimplementation (REQUEST_CHANGES) - Approval rate: 4.8% (1/21) ### New UAT Bugs (Cycle 3 — v3.0.0/v3.1.0 features) - **#5934** — `agents resource remove` doesn't check project links (spec violation) - **#5932** — `agents plan explain` JSON output missing spec-required envelope and structured fields ### Test-Infra-Improver Findings - **#5935** — Add Robot integration tests for cli module - **#5936** — Manual dependency security review required ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 0 | — | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 1 | automation_tracking_label_misuse_broader (watchdog-created issues) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Monitoring CI on `a3762a4` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 12:20:53 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 22 Audit — 2026-04-09T12:15Z (System Health Monitoring)

Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4`

No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z)
CI checks passing

System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle)

Positive Signs:

Bug-hunter pool actively filing issues (#5953 — broad exception in _load_static_base)
UAT pool continuing to find bugs (#5952, #5954)
Docs Writer Cycle 10 — PR #5832 (CHANGELOG) still open and mergeable
Epic Planner Cycle 2 — all epics have children, no empty milestones

Concerning Patterns:

v3.2.0 growing: open (257) > closed (247) — UAT bugs being filed faster than fixes
v3.5.0: 820 open issues (was 795 in Cycle 3) — growing
Multiple epic-planner instances running in parallel (potential duplicate work)
PR #5832 (CHANGELOG) has been open since Cycle 17 — needs review

Automation Tracking Health:

Docs Writer: Cycle 10 (active, 3 idle cycles)
Epic Planner: Cycle 2 (active, multiple instances)
Bug-hunter: Cycle 1 (active, filing issues)

New Bugs Filed

#5952 — agents project show displays ULIDs not resource names
#5953 — Broad exception in _load_static_base (bug-hunter)
#5954 — Dracula theme not set as default in TUI

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	0	—
HIGH	1	v3_2_0_growing_faster_than_fixes (257 open vs 247 closed)
MEDIUM	1	multiple_epic_planner_instances (parallel instances)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Monitoring CI on a3762a4
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 22 Audit — 2026-04-09T12:15Z (System Health Monitoring) ### Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4` - No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z) - CI checks passing ### System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle) **Positive Signs**: - Bug-hunter pool actively filing issues (#5953 — broad exception in _load_static_base) - UAT pool continuing to find bugs (#5952, #5954) - Docs Writer Cycle 10 — PR #5832 (CHANGELOG) still open and mergeable - Epic Planner Cycle 2 — all epics have children, no empty milestones **Concerning Patterns**: - v3.2.0 growing: open (257) > closed (247) — UAT bugs being filed faster than fixes - v3.5.0: 820 open issues (was 795 in Cycle 3) — growing - Multiple epic-planner instances running in parallel (potential duplicate work) - PR #5832 (CHANGELOG) has been open since Cycle 17 — needs review **Automation Tracking Health**: - Docs Writer: Cycle 10 (active, 3 idle cycles) - Epic Planner: Cycle 2 (active, multiple instances) - Bug-hunter: Cycle 1 (active, filing issues) ### New Bugs Filed - #5952 — `agents project show` displays ULIDs not resource names - #5953 — Broad exception in `_load_static_base` (bug-hunter) - #5954 — Dracula theme not set as default in TUI ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 0 | — | | HIGH | 1 | v3_2_0_growing_faster_than_fixes (257 open vs 247 closed) | | MEDIUM | 1 | multiple_epic_planner_instances (parallel instances) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Monitoring CI on `a3762a4` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 12:21:18 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 64 Update (watchdog-1 ses_28f2505b5ffe)

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T11:50:00Z

System Status

MASTER CI: GREEN on a3762a4c ✅

SUPERVISORS: All 16 types active ✅

reviewer-pool (x2), backlog-groomer, test-infra-pool, project-owner (x2), arch-guard (x2), human-liaison (x2), tester-pool, implementor-pool, spec-updater (x2), docs-writer, architect, epic-planner, timeline-updater, hunter-pool (x2), watchdog (x2)

IMPLEMENTATION WORKERS: 1 active

NEW PRs: #5914 (docs spec), #5905 (docs reference)

NOTE: New watchdog Cycle 21 tracking issue #5915 created by other watchdog instance

Ongoing Issues

PERSISTENT: Coverage at 84.42% vs 97% required (issue #5363)

STALE PRs: 20+ open PRs without reviews

HUMAN INTERACTION: Issue #5863 — PR #5659 blocked by 12 cascading e2e tests

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 64 Update (watchdog-1 ses_28f2505b5ffe) **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T11:50:00Z ### System Status **MASTER CI**: GREEN on `a3762a4c` ✅ **SUPERVISORS**: All 16 types active ✅ - reviewer-pool (x2), backlog-groomer, test-infra-pool, project-owner (x2), arch-guard (x2), human-liaison (x2), tester-pool, implementor-pool, spec-updater (x2), docs-writer, architect, epic-planner, timeline-updater, hunter-pool (x2), watchdog (x2) **IMPLEMENTATION WORKERS**: 1 active **NEW PRs**: #5914 (docs spec), #5905 (docs reference) **NOTE**: New watchdog Cycle 21 tracking issue #5915 created by other watchdog instance ### Ongoing Issues **PERSISTENT**: Coverage at 84.42% vs 97% required (issue #5363) **STALE PRs**: 20+ open PRs without reviews **HUMAN INTERACTION**: Issue #5863 — PR #5659 blocked by 12 cascading e2e tests --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 12:52:42 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 23 Audit — 2026-04-09T12:48Z (Closed Item Interactions Check)

Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4`

No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z)
CI checks passing

New PR: Docs Writer Created PR #5971

docs: add LSP and ACMS API reference pages; fix diagnostics provider table
Docs writer Cycle 10 creating documentation for LSP and ACMS modules
System is working correctly — docs writer responding to code

Bug-Hunter Pool Active

Worker started scanning cleveragents.acms.uko.detail_level_maps (#5974)
Pool is dispatching workers to modules

Backlog Groomer Cycle 62

42 actions taken — very active cycle
Fixing labels and milestones on new UAT bugs

New Critical Bugs (UAT Pool — TUI features)

#5972 — Flash notification bar and Throbber widgets missing (Critical — v3.7.0)
#5975 — agents plan tree node labels wrong format (Backlog)

Closed Item Interactions Audit (Audit 14 — 3rd Cycle)

No suspicious bot comments on closed items detected
PR #5971 (new docs PR) — legitimate new PR

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	1	tui_notification_system_missing (#5972)
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	0	—
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted PR #5971 (docs writer follow-up)
Monitoring CI on a3762a4
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 23 Audit — 2026-04-09T12:48Z (Closed Item Interactions Check) ### Master CI: ✅ STILL GREEN on `a3762a4` - No new merges since Cycle 14 (docs PR at 09:22Z) - CI checks passing ### New PR: Docs Writer Created PR #5971 - `docs: add LSP and ACMS API reference pages; fix diagnostics provider table` - Docs writer Cycle 10 creating documentation for LSP and ACMS modules - System is working correctly — docs writer responding to code ### Bug-Hunter Pool Active - Worker started scanning `cleveragents.acms.uko.detail_level_maps` (#5974) - Pool is dispatching workers to modules ### Backlog Groomer Cycle 62 - 42 actions taken — very active cycle - Fixing labels and milestones on new UAT bugs ### New Critical Bugs (UAT Pool — TUI features) - **#5972** — Flash notification bar and Throbber widgets missing (Critical — v3.7.0) - **#5975** — `agents plan tree` node labels wrong format (Backlog) ### Closed Item Interactions Audit (Audit 14 — 3rd Cycle) - No suspicious bot comments on closed items detected - PR #5971 (new docs PR) — legitimate new PR ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 1 | tui_notification_system_missing (#5972) | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 0 | — | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted PR #5971 (docs writer follow-up) - Monitoring CI on `a3762a4` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 13:26:38 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 24 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:19Z (System Health Monitoring)

🎉 NEW MERGE: Human Developer Hamza Khyari Merged PR #4219!

New commit: 33d5c0b — fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline into CLI
Merged by: Hamza Khyari at 13:18:46Z
Impact: ContextTierService was starting empty on every CLI invocation — LLM received zero file context during plan execution. This is a critical fix for the ACMS pipeline.
CI Status: Running on new commit

System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle)

Positive Signs:

Human developer Hamza Khyari actively merging PRs
Bug-hunter pool dispatching workers to modules
Test-infra-improver filing more issues (#5991, #5992)
UAT pool continuing to find bugs

New UAT Bugs:

#5990 — PluginManager missing get_extension_point(name) method (High)
#5989 — WF04 E2E test has empty body (Backlog)
#5993 — PersonaBar missing cumulative session cost display

Automation Tracking Health:

Backlog Groomer: Cycle 62 (active, 42 actions)
Bug-hunter: Active, dispatching workers
Test-infra-improver: Active, filing issues

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	0	—
HIGH	1	plugin_manager_missing_method (#5990)
MEDIUM	0	—
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted human developer merge (PR #4219 by Hamza Khyari)
Monitoring CI on new commit 33d5c0b
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 24 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:19Z (System Health Monitoring) ### 🎉 NEW MERGE: Human Developer Hamza Khyari Merged PR #4219! - **New commit**: `33d5c0b` — `fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline into CLI` - **Merged by**: Hamza Khyari at 13:18:46Z - **Impact**: ContextTierService was starting empty on every CLI invocation — LLM received zero file context during plan execution. This is a critical fix for the ACMS pipeline. - **CI Status**: Running on new commit ### System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle) **Positive Signs**: - Human developer Hamza Khyari actively merging PRs - Bug-hunter pool dispatching workers to modules - Test-infra-improver filing more issues (#5991, #5992) - UAT pool continuing to find bugs **New UAT Bugs**: - #5990 — PluginManager missing `get_extension_point(name)` method (High) - #5989 — WF04 E2E test has empty body (Backlog) - #5993 — PersonaBar missing cumulative session cost display **Automation Tracking Health**: - Backlog Groomer: Cycle 62 (active, 42 actions) - Bug-hunter: Active, dispatching workers - Test-infra-improver: Active, filing issues ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 0 | — | | HIGH | 1 | plugin_manager_missing_method (#5990) | | MEDIUM | 0 | — | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted human developer merge (PR #4219 by Hamza Khyari) - Monitoring CI on new commit `33d5c0b` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-09 13:39:05 +00:00

[AUTO-GROOMER] Backlog Grooming Report (Cycle 61) #5909

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 13:44:18 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 25 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:39Z

Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `33d5c0b` (new commit from Cycle 24)

Latest commit: 33d5c0b (fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline — Hamza Khyari)
CI checks running on new commit

🔔 Prior Watchdog Instance Active (Issue #6012)

A prior watchdog instance (Cycle 15) filed a comprehensive health report
Found: PR #5271 struggling (9 review passes), posted human assistance request
Found: Multiple PRs with passing CI not yet merged
Found: Closed issues with wrong state labels
Note: This is a parallel watchdog instance — coordination needed

New Critical Bug: Checkpoint Trigger Names Mismatch

Issue #6010 — Checkpoint auto-trigger names and config key namespace mismatch spec (v3.3.0 critical)

Config key: core.checkpoints.auto_create_on (wrong) vs sandbox.checkpoint.auto-create-on (spec)
Trigger names: before_tool_execute/after_tool_execute (wrong) vs on_tool_write/on_tool_write_complete (spec)
Impact: Users configuring checkpoints per spec will have no effect
Severity: Critical — v3.3.0 deliverable at risk

Bug-Hunter Pool Active

#6013 — map_domain_error hides non-CleverAgentsError exceptions
#6009 — Whitespace-only strings accepted in A2A client stubs

Architect Created PR #6011

docs(spec): document ReconciliationBlockedError and invariant reconciliation failure behavior
New spec PR awaiting human review

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	1	checkpoint_trigger_names_mismatch (#6010)
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	1	parallel_watchdog_instance (issue #6012)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted checkpoint trigger names mismatch (#6010)
Noted parallel watchdog instance (#6012)
Monitoring CI on 33d5c0b
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 25 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:39Z ### Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `33d5c0b` (new commit from Cycle 24) - Latest commit: `33d5c0b` (fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline — Hamza Khyari) - CI checks running on new commit ### 🔔 Prior Watchdog Instance Active (Issue #6012) - A prior watchdog instance (Cycle 15) filed a comprehensive health report - Found: PR #5271 struggling (9 review passes), posted human assistance request - Found: Multiple PRs with passing CI not yet merged - Found: Closed issues with wrong state labels - **Note**: This is a parallel watchdog instance — coordination needed ### New Critical Bug: Checkpoint Trigger Names Mismatch **Issue #6010** — Checkpoint auto-trigger names and config key namespace mismatch spec (v3.3.0 critical) - Config key: `core.checkpoints.auto_create_on` (wrong) vs `sandbox.checkpoint.auto-create-on` (spec) - Trigger names: `before_tool_execute`/`after_tool_execute` (wrong) vs `on_tool_write`/`on_tool_write_complete` (spec) - **Impact**: Users configuring checkpoints per spec will have no effect - **Severity**: Critical — v3.3.0 deliverable at risk ### Bug-Hunter Pool Active - #6013 — `map_domain_error` hides non-CleverAgentsError exceptions - #6009 — Whitespace-only strings accepted in A2A client stubs ### Architect Created PR #6011 - `docs(spec): document ReconciliationBlockedError and invariant reconciliation failure behavior` - New spec PR awaiting human review ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 1 | checkpoint_trigger_names_mismatch (#6010) | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 1 | parallel_watchdog_instance (issue #6012) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted checkpoint trigger names mismatch (#6010) - Noted parallel watchdog instance (#6012) - Monitoring CI on `33d5c0b` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 14:04:03 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 26 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:58Z (System Health Monitoring)

Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `33d5c0b`

Latest commit: 33d5c0b (fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline — Hamza Khyari)
No new merges since Cycle 24

🚨 NEW CRITICAL BUG: Invariant Add Broken

Issue #6038 — agents invariant add CLI uses isolated in-memory service — invariants not persisted and not enforced during strategize

CLI creates its own InvariantService instance disconnected from DI container
Invariants are lost on process exit
Invariants are NOT enforced during strategize (different service instance)
Directly blocks v3.2.0 acceptance criteria: "Invariants are enforced during strategize"
Severity: Critical

System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle)

Positive Signs:

Docs Writer Cycle 10 detected new commit 33d5c0b2
PR #5823 (CHANGELOG) open and mergeable
Bug-hunter pool actively filing issues
UAT pool finding critical bugs

Concerning Patterns:

Multiple critical bugs blocking v3.2.0 acceptance criteria
v3.2.0 has 229 open / 245 closed — growing again
Parallel watchdog instance (issue #6012) also monitoring

New UAT Bugs:

#6038 — invariant add broken (Critical — v3.2.0)
#6035 — plan status missing checkpoints (v3.3.0)
#6036 — ACMS config stored globally not per-view (Backlog)
#6034 — PluginManager duplicate registration inconsistency

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	1	invariant_add_broken (#6038)
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	0	—
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted invariant add critical bug (#6038)
Monitoring CI on 33d5c0b
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 26 Audit — 2026-04-09T13:58Z (System Health Monitoring) ### Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `33d5c0b` - Latest commit: `33d5c0b` (fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline — Hamza Khyari) - No new merges since Cycle 24 ### 🚨 NEW CRITICAL BUG: Invariant Add Broken **Issue #6038** — `agents invariant add` CLI uses isolated in-memory service — invariants not persisted and not enforced during strategize - CLI creates its own `InvariantService` instance disconnected from DI container - Invariants are lost on process exit - Invariants are NOT enforced during strategize (different service instance) - **Directly blocks v3.2.0 acceptance criteria**: "Invariants are enforced during strategize" - **Severity**: Critical ### System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle) **Positive Signs**: - Docs Writer Cycle 10 detected new commit `33d5c0b2` - PR #5823 (CHANGELOG) open and mergeable - Bug-hunter pool actively filing issues - UAT pool finding critical bugs **Concerning Patterns**: - Multiple critical bugs blocking v3.2.0 acceptance criteria - v3.2.0 has 229 open / 245 closed — growing again - Parallel watchdog instance (issue #6012) also monitoring **New UAT Bugs**: - #6038 — invariant add broken (Critical — v3.2.0) - #6035 — plan status missing checkpoints (v3.3.0) - #6036 — ACMS config stored globally not per-view (Backlog) - #6034 — PluginManager duplicate registration inconsistency ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 1 | invariant_add_broken (#6038) | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 0 | — | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted invariant add critical bug (#6038) - Monitoring CI on `33d5c0b` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 closed this issue

2026-04-09 14:13:24 +00:00

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 14:24:22 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 27 Audit — 2026-04-09T14:19Z

Master CI: ⏳ STILL RUNNING on `33d5c0b`

No new merges since Cycle 24 (Hamza Khyari's ACMS fix)
CI checks running

🆕 New Critical Bug: project context set data loss

Issue #6062 — agents project context set replaces entire view on each call — previously set fields silently lost

Every call creates a fresh ContextView from scratch
Fields not provided in current call are reset to defaults
Impact: Users cannot incrementally configure context views
Severity: High (data loss)

Bug-Hunter Pool: Needs Source Code

Issue #6060: Bug hunter cannot access source code for cleveragents.acms.uko.vocabulary_registry
This is a known limitation — bug hunter can't clone the repo
Proposal #4840 (git clone permission) pending human approval

New UAT Bugs

#6062 — project context set data loss (High)
#6058 — PluginManager state machine violation (Medium)

Test-Infra-Improver

#6059 — Create custom Docker image for CI (Backlog)

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	0	—
HIGH	1	project_context_set_data_loss (#6062)
MEDIUM	1	bug_hunter_no_repo_access (#6060)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted project context set data loss (#6062)
Monitoring CI on 33d5c0b
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 27 Audit — 2026-04-09T14:19Z ### Master CI: ⏳ STILL RUNNING on `33d5c0b` - No new merges since Cycle 24 (Hamza Khyari's ACMS fix) - CI checks running ### 🆕 New Critical Bug: project context set data loss **Issue #6062** — `agents project context set` replaces entire view on each call — previously set fields silently lost - Every call creates a fresh `ContextView` from scratch - Fields not provided in current call are reset to defaults - **Impact**: Users cannot incrementally configure context views - **Severity**: High (data loss) ### Bug-Hunter Pool: Needs Source Code - Issue #6060: Bug hunter cannot access source code for `cleveragents.acms.uko.vocabulary_registry` - This is a known limitation — bug hunter can't clone the repo - Proposal #4840 (git clone permission) pending human approval ### New UAT Bugs - #6062 — project context set data loss (High) - #6058 — PluginManager state machine violation (Medium) ### Test-Infra-Improver - #6059 — Create custom Docker image for CI (Backlog) ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 0 | — | | HIGH | 1 | project_context_set_data_loss (#6062) | | MEDIUM | 1 | bug_hunter_no_repo_access (#6060) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted project context set data loss (#6062) - Monitoring CI on `33d5c0b` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 14:44:44 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 28 Audit — 2026-04-09T14:35Z (System Health Monitoring)

🎉 MAJOR MERGE: Hamza Khyari Merged PR #5998!

New commit: 182eeab — feat(plan): implement git worktree sandbox for execute and merge-based apply
Merged by: Hamza Khyari at 14:33:33Z
Impact: CRITICAL FIX — implements spec-aligned git worktree flow for Execute and Apply phases
- Replaces flat shutil.copy2 apply with proper git worktree merge
- Directly addresses issue #5444 (plan apply broken — sandbox changes never merged)
- Also fixes context_tier_hydrator metadata types, A2A facade duplicate dispatch
CI Status: Running on new commit

System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle)

Positive Signs:

Hamza Khyari actively merging critical fixes (2 merges today!)
Agent Evolver Cycle 18 — 3 proposals approved (approval rate improved to 13.6%)
4 improvement PRs open (#4617, #5301, #5755, #5768)
Bug-hunter pool scanning 483+ modules

Key Finding from Agent Evolver:

Issue #5970 — test-infra-improver uses python3 instead of jq for session ID extraction
This is why the pool supervisor is blocked! python3 is not in allowed bash commands but jq IS
Proposal #5970 pending human approval

New Critical Bug:

#6098 — ContainerToolExecutor not wired in DI container — container execution never works in production

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	1	container_executor_not_wired (#6098)
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	1	test_infra_improver_python3_vs_jq (#5970)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted critical ACMS fix merged (PR #5998)
Noted container executor not wired (#6098)
Monitoring CI on 182eeab
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 28 Audit — 2026-04-09T14:35Z (System Health Monitoring) ### 🎉 MAJOR MERGE: Hamza Khyari Merged PR #5998! - **New commit**: `182eeab` — `feat(plan): implement git worktree sandbox for execute and merge-based apply` - **Merged by**: Hamza Khyari at 14:33:33Z - **Impact**: CRITICAL FIX — implements spec-aligned git worktree flow for Execute and Apply phases - Replaces flat shutil.copy2 apply with proper git worktree merge - Directly addresses issue #5444 (plan apply broken — sandbox changes never merged) - Also fixes context_tier_hydrator metadata types, A2A facade duplicate dispatch - **CI Status**: Running on new commit ### System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle) **Positive Signs**: - Hamza Khyari actively merging critical fixes (2 merges today!) - Agent Evolver Cycle 18 — 3 proposals approved (approval rate improved to 13.6%) - 4 improvement PRs open (#4617, #5301, #5755, #5768) - Bug-hunter pool scanning 483+ modules **Key Finding from Agent Evolver**: - Issue #5970 — test-infra-improver uses `python3` instead of `jq` for session ID extraction - This is why the pool supervisor is blocked! `python3` is not in allowed bash commands but `jq` IS - Proposal #5970 pending human approval **New Critical Bug**: - **#6098** — ContainerToolExecutor not wired in DI container — container execution never works in production ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 1 | container_executor_not_wired (#6098) | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 1 | test_infra_improver_python3_vs_jq (#5970) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted critical ACMS fix merged (PR #5998) - Noted container executor not wired (#6098) - Monitoring CI on `182eeab` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 15:07:43 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 29 Audit — 2026-04-09T15:01Z

Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `182eeab`

Latest commit: 182eeab (feat(plan): git worktree sandbox — Hamza Khyari)
No new merges since Cycle 28

⚠️ COORDINATION ISSUE: 4 Duplicate Spec PRs

Spec Updater Cycle 10 found 4 duplicate PRs for proposal #5942 (ReconciliationBlockedError):

PR #6065, #6011, #6007, #6004 — all documenting the same thing
Action needed: Humans should close 3 of these 4 duplicate PRs
This is a coordination failure — multiple agents created PRs for the same proposal

Docs Writer Active

PR #6119 created: docs: add context-tier-hydrator module guide, fix CHANGELOG placement
Docs writer responding to new merge 182eeab — system working correctly

Review Pool Cycle 3

16/16 reviewers dispatched
Reviewing PR #5998 (git worktree) and 19 other PRs
Very active review cycle

Test-Infra-Improver Cycle 20

CRITICAL FAILURE again (same bash security issue)
Note: Agent Evolver found root cause — agent uses python3 not jq
Proposal #5970 pending human approval

New UAT Bug

#6115 — 4 container tool routing scenarios permanently @skipped (Critical — no test coverage)

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	0	—
HIGH	1	duplicate_spec_prs (4 PRs for same proposal #5942)
MEDIUM	1	test_infra_improver_blocked (persistent, cycle 20)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted 4 duplicate spec PRs — humans need to close 3
Monitoring CI on 182eeab
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 29 Audit — 2026-04-09T15:01Z ### Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `182eeab` - Latest commit: `182eeab` (feat(plan): git worktree sandbox — Hamza Khyari) - No new merges since Cycle 28 ### ⚠️ COORDINATION ISSUE: 4 Duplicate Spec PRs **Spec Updater Cycle 10** found 4 duplicate PRs for proposal #5942 (ReconciliationBlockedError): - PR #6065, #6011, #6007, #6004 — all documenting the same thing - **Action needed**: Humans should close 3 of these 4 duplicate PRs - This is a coordination failure — multiple agents created PRs for the same proposal ### Docs Writer Active - PR #6119 created: `docs: add context-tier-hydrator module guide, fix CHANGELOG placement` - Docs writer responding to new merge `182eeab` — system working correctly ### Review Pool Cycle 3 - 16/16 reviewers dispatched - Reviewing PR #5998 (git worktree) and 19 other PRs - Very active review cycle ### Test-Infra-Improver Cycle 20 - CRITICAL FAILURE again (same bash security issue) - Note: Agent Evolver found root cause — agent uses `python3` not `jq` - Proposal #5970 pending human approval ### New UAT Bug - #6115 — 4 container tool routing scenarios permanently @skipped (Critical — no test coverage) ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 0 | — | | HIGH | 1 | duplicate_spec_prs (4 PRs for same proposal #5942) | | MEDIUM | 1 | test_infra_improver_blocked (persistent, cycle 20) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted 4 duplicate spec PRs — humans need to close 3 - Monitoring CI on `182eeab` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-09 15:14:09 +00:00

[AUTO-GROOMER] Backlog Grooming Report (Cycle 63) #6025

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 15:34:21 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 30 Audit — 2026-04-09T15:24Z (System Health Monitoring)

Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `182eeab`

No new merges since Cycle 28 (git worktree sandbox)
CI checks running

🔔 Human Activity Detected (Human Liaison Cycle 20)

hamza.khyari created issue #6055: feat(plan): run tests, lint, and typecheck in sandbox during execute phase
hurui200320 commented on PR #5659 (e2e fix in progress)
Human liaison is monitoring and responding correctly

🚨 NEW CRITICAL BUG: cleveragents-tool-exec binary missing

Issue #6133 — cleveragents-tool-exec binary not defined as entry point — ALL container tool execution broken

ContainerToolExecutor calls cleveragents-tool-exec inside container
But this binary is NEVER registered in pyproject.toml
Every container tool execution fails with "command not found"
Severity: Critical — blocks all v3.6.0 container tool execution

System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle)

Positive Signs:

Human liaison active and detecting human activity
Architecture guard filing code quality issues
UAT pool finding container execution bugs

Ongoing Concerns:

Test-infra-improver still blocked (Cycle 20)
4 duplicate spec PRs for proposal #5942 need human cleanup
Container execution completely broken (#6133)

Findings This Cycle

Severity	Count	Types
CRITICAL	1	container_tool_exec_binary_missing (#6133)
HIGH	0	—
MEDIUM	1	test_infra_improver_blocked (persistent, cycle 20)
LOW	0	—

Actions Taken

Noted container tool exec binary missing (#6133)
Monitoring CI on 182eeab
No one-off agents dispatched

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 30 Audit — 2026-04-09T15:24Z (System Health Monitoring) ### Master CI: ⏳ RUNNING on `182eeab` - No new merges since Cycle 28 (git worktree sandbox) - CI checks running ### 🔔 Human Activity Detected (Human Liaison Cycle 20) - **hamza.khyari** created issue #6055: feat(plan): run tests, lint, and typecheck in sandbox during execute phase - **hurui200320** commented on PR #5659 (e2e fix in progress) - Human liaison is monitoring and responding correctly ### 🚨 NEW CRITICAL BUG: cleveragents-tool-exec binary missing **Issue #6133** — `cleveragents-tool-exec` binary not defined as entry point — ALL container tool execution broken - `ContainerToolExecutor` calls `cleveragents-tool-exec` inside container - But this binary is NEVER registered in `pyproject.toml` - Every container tool execution fails with "command not found" - **Severity**: Critical — blocks all v3.6.0 container tool execution ### System Health Monitoring (Audit 15 — Even Cycle) **Positive Signs**: - Human liaison active and detecting human activity - Architecture guard filing code quality issues - UAT pool finding container execution bugs **Ongoing Concerns**: - Test-infra-improver still blocked (Cycle 20) - 4 duplicate spec PRs for proposal #5942 need human cleanup - Container execution completely broken (#6133) ### Findings This Cycle | Severity | Count | Types | |----------|-------|-------| | CRITICAL | 1 | container_tool_exec_binary_missing (#6133) | | HIGH | 0 | — | | MEDIUM | 1 | test_infra_improver_blocked (persistent, cycle 20) | | LOW | 0 | — | ### Actions Taken - Noted container tool exec binary missing (#6133) - Monitoring CI on `182eeab` - No one-off agents dispatched --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog