[AUTO-ARCH] Status: Architecture (Cycle 25) #9724

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-15 06:20:07 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-15 06:20:07 +00:00

Owner

Architecture Pool Supervisor — Cycle 25

Session started: 2026-04-15
Supervisor: architecture-pool-supervisor
Worker pool size: 1 (singleton)

Cycle 25 Analysis

Status Changes Since Cycle 24

AUTO-ARCH-17 PR Not Found:
The worker dispatched in Cycle 24 for comprehensive ACMS v1 spec did not produce a visible PR. Dispatching [AUTO-ARCH-18] as replacement.

Open AUTO-ARCH PRs (unchanged from Cycle 24):

PR #9566 [AUTO-ARCH-16]: spec: update prompt injection mitigation to use XML-delimited tags — Open, Needs Feedback, mergeable
PR #9241 [AUTO-ARCH-14]: spec: clarify Anonymous Tool enforcement rules — Open, State/In Review, mergeable
PR #9214 [AUTO-ARCH-13]: spec: clarify default global automation profile — Open, State/In Review, mergeable
PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12]: spec: document context_tier_hydrator module — Open, State/In Review, NOT mergeable (conflicts)
PR #9177 [AUTO-ARCH-1]: spec: add v3.8.0 and v3.9.0 milestone plan sections — Open, Needs Feedback, mergeable
PR #9036 [AUTO-ARCH-10]: spec: TUI A2A integration layer — Open, State/Wont Do
PR #9021 [AUTO-ARCH-9]: spec: v3.8.0 Server Implementation milestone plan — Open, NOT mergeable
PR #8962 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: JSON-RPC 2.0 A2A wire format — Open, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8958 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: git worktree sandbox apply strategy — Open, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: ADR-049 specification restructuring proposal — Open, Priority/Medium, mergeable
PR #8846 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: v3.9.0 milestone plan section — Open, NOT mergeable
PR #8737 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: Three-Way Merge Strategy (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8736 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: Checkpoint System (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8733 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: Subplan System (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, NOT mergeable
PR #8658 [AUTO-ARCH-2B]: spec: Invariant Management System (v3.2.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8581 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8579 [AUTO-ARCH-1]: spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable
PR #8578 [AUTO-ARCH-4]: spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/Critical, mergeable
PR #8437 [AUTO-ARCH-4]: docs(adr): ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy — Open, NOT mergeable

AUTO-SPEC Proposals Awaiting Architectural Decisions (>15 hours old):

Issue #9283 [AUTO-SPEC-1]: LockService advisory locking — implementation found better approach; needs spec update (v3.2.0)
Issue #9284 [AUTO-SPEC-2]: fail_fast semantics for already-running subplans — implementation clarified behavior (v3.3.0)
Issue #9285 [AUTO-SPEC-3]: validation gate empty-run guard — security fix, needs spec update (v3.2.0)
Issue #9287 [AUTO-SPEC-4]: automation profile unknown-name error behavior — implementation found better approach (v3.5.0)
Issue #9433 [AUTO-SPEC-5]: RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names — contested decision, awaiting human feedback

New Supervisors Active:

AUTO-GUARD (Architecture Guard): Cycles 1-2 active, monitoring architectural compliance
AUTO-IMP-POOL: Implementation Pool Supervisor initializing

Spec Gap Identified

ACMS v1 Comprehensive Spec Coverage (v3.4.0):
PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12] is NOT mergeable due to conflicts. The ACMS v1 implementation has expanded to 7 PRs covering the full feature set. A fresh, comprehensive ACMS v1 spec section is needed.

Dispatched Workers This Cycle

[AUTO-ARCH-18]: Comprehensive ACMS v1 spec section (major change, needs feedback) — replacing failed AUTO-ARCH-17

Next Cycle

Scheduled in ~30 minutes. Will continue monitoring for:

AUTO-ARCH-18 PR creation and status
Human resolution of pending AUTO-ARCH PRs
New spec ambiguities from implementers
Resolution of AUTO-SPEC proposals (#9283-#9287, #9433)
New milestones without spec coverage

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor

## Architecture Pool Supervisor — Cycle 25 **Session started:** 2026-04-15 **Supervisor:** architecture-pool-supervisor **Worker pool size:** 1 (singleton) ## Cycle 25 Analysis ### Status Changes Since Cycle 24 **AUTO-ARCH-17 PR Not Found:** The worker dispatched in Cycle 24 for comprehensive ACMS v1 spec did not produce a visible PR. Dispatching [AUTO-ARCH-18] as replacement. **Open AUTO-ARCH PRs (unchanged from Cycle 24):** - PR #9566 [AUTO-ARCH-16]: spec: update prompt injection mitigation to use XML-delimited tags — Open, Needs Feedback, mergeable - PR #9241 [AUTO-ARCH-14]: spec: clarify Anonymous Tool enforcement rules — Open, State/In Review, mergeable - PR #9214 [AUTO-ARCH-13]: spec: clarify default global automation profile — Open, State/In Review, mergeable - PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12]: spec: document context_tier_hydrator module — Open, State/In Review, NOT mergeable (conflicts) - PR #9177 [AUTO-ARCH-1]: spec: add v3.8.0 and v3.9.0 milestone plan sections — Open, Needs Feedback, mergeable - PR #9036 [AUTO-ARCH-10]: spec: TUI A2A integration layer — Open, State/Wont Do - PR #9021 [AUTO-ARCH-9]: spec: v3.8.0 Server Implementation milestone plan — Open, NOT mergeable - PR #8962 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: JSON-RPC 2.0 A2A wire format — Open, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8958 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: git worktree sandbox apply strategy — Open, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: ADR-049 specification restructuring proposal — Open, Priority/Medium, mergeable - PR #8846 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: v3.9.0 milestone plan section — Open, NOT mergeable - PR #8737 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: Three-Way Merge Strategy (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8736 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: Checkpoint System (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8733 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: Subplan System (v3.3.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, NOT mergeable - PR #8658 [AUTO-ARCH-2B]: spec: Invariant Management System (v3.2.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8581 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8579 [AUTO-ARCH-1]: spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/High, mergeable - PR #8578 [AUTO-ARCH-4]: spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) — Open, Needs Feedback, Priority/Critical, mergeable - PR #8437 [AUTO-ARCH-4]: docs(adr): ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy — Open, NOT mergeable **AUTO-SPEC Proposals Awaiting Architectural Decisions (>15 hours old):** - Issue #9283 [AUTO-SPEC-1]: LockService advisory locking — implementation found better approach; needs spec update (v3.2.0) - Issue #9284 [AUTO-SPEC-2]: fail_fast semantics for already-running subplans — implementation clarified behavior (v3.3.0) - Issue #9285 [AUTO-SPEC-3]: validation gate empty-run guard — security fix, needs spec update (v3.2.0) - Issue #9287 [AUTO-SPEC-4]: automation profile unknown-name error behavior — implementation found better approach (v3.5.0) - Issue #9433 [AUTO-SPEC-5]: RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names — contested decision, awaiting human feedback **New Supervisors Active:** - AUTO-GUARD (Architecture Guard): Cycles 1-2 active, monitoring architectural compliance - AUTO-IMP-POOL: Implementation Pool Supervisor initializing ### Spec Gap Identified **ACMS v1 Comprehensive Spec Coverage (v3.4.0):** PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12] is NOT mergeable due to conflicts. The ACMS v1 implementation has expanded to 7 PRs covering the full feature set. A fresh, comprehensive ACMS v1 spec section is needed. ### Dispatched Workers This Cycle - [AUTO-ARCH-18]: Comprehensive ACMS v1 spec section (major change, needs feedback) — replacing failed AUTO-ARCH-17 ### Next Cycle Scheduled in ~30 minutes. Will continue monitoring for: - AUTO-ARCH-18 PR creation and status - Human resolution of pending AUTO-ARCH PRs - New spec ambiguities from implementers - Resolution of AUTO-SPEC proposals (#9283-#9287, #9433) - New milestones without spec coverage --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 closed this issue

2026-04-15 08:36:47 +00:00