test(integration): workflow example 8 — cloud infrastructure management (supervised profile) #772

Closed
opened 2026-03-12 19:39:51 +00:00 by freemo · 5 comments
Owner

Metadata

  • Commit Message: test(integration): workflow example 8 — cloud infrastructure management (supervised profile)
  • Branch: test/int-wf08-cloud-infra

Background

Integration test for Specification Workflow Example 8: Cloud Infrastructure Management. Exercises the supervised automation profile with custom resource types (terraform-state), custom skills (terraform-ops), skill composition, and infrastructure invariants using mocked LLM providers.

Runs within the standard nox -s integration_tests session using mocked LLM providers.

Expected Behavior

The integration test validates infrastructure management with mocked LLM and mocked Terraform operations. Custom resource types, skills, and invariants are exercised.

Acceptance Criteria

  • Robot Framework test suite in robot/ directory (standard integration tests)
  • Test registers custom resource type and skill with tool composition
  • Test uses integration-appropriate mocking (mocked LLM providers, mocked Terraform)
  • Test verifies infrastructure analysis produces optimization recommendations
  • Test verifies invariant enforcement
  • Test passes via nox -s integration_tests
  • Coverage >=97% maintained

Subtasks

  • Write Robot Framework integration test suite for workflow example 8
  • Configure mocked LLM and Terraform responses
  • Create Terraform fixture files
  • Implement supervised infrastructure workflow
  • Verify via nox -s integration_tests
  • Verify coverage >=97% via nox -s coverage_report
  • Run nox (all default sessions), fix any errors

Definition of Done

This issue is complete when:

  • All subtasks above are completed and checked off.
  • A Git commit is created where the first line of the commit message matches the Commit Message in Metadata exactly, followed by a blank line, then additional lines providing relevant details.
  • The commit is pushed to the remote on the branch matching the Branch in Metadata exactly.
  • The commit is submitted as a pull request to master, reviewed, and merged before this issue is marked done.
## Metadata - **Commit Message**: `test(integration): workflow example 8 — cloud infrastructure management (supervised profile)` - **Branch**: `test/int-wf08-cloud-infra` ## Background Integration test for Specification Workflow Example 8: Cloud Infrastructure Management. Exercises the `supervised` automation profile with custom resource types (terraform-state), custom skills (terraform-ops), skill composition, and infrastructure invariants using mocked LLM providers. Runs within the standard `nox -s integration_tests` session using mocked LLM providers. ## Expected Behavior The integration test validates infrastructure management with mocked LLM and mocked Terraform operations. Custom resource types, skills, and invariants are exercised. ## Acceptance Criteria - [x] Robot Framework test suite in `robot/` directory (standard integration tests) - [x] Test registers custom resource type and skill with tool composition - [x] Test uses integration-appropriate mocking (mocked LLM providers, mocked Terraform) - [x] Test verifies infrastructure analysis produces optimization recommendations - [x] Test verifies invariant enforcement - [x] Test passes via `nox -s integration_tests` - [x] Coverage >=97% maintained ## Subtasks - [x] Write Robot Framework integration test suite for workflow example 8 - [x] Configure mocked LLM and Terraform responses - [x] Create Terraform fixture files - [x] Implement supervised infrastructure workflow - [x] Verify via `nox -s integration_tests` - [x] Verify coverage >=97% via `nox -s coverage_report` - [x] Run `nox` (all default sessions), fix any errors ## Definition of Done This issue is complete when: - All subtasks above are completed and checked off. - A Git commit is created where the **first line** of the commit message matches the Commit Message in Metadata exactly, followed by a blank line, then additional lines providing relevant details. - The commit is pushed to the remote on the branch matching the **Branch** in Metadata exactly. - The commit is submitted as a **pull request** to `master`, reviewed, and **merged** before this issue is marked done.
freemo added this to the v3.1.0 milestone 2026-03-12 19:39:51 +00:00
freemo modified the milestone from v3.1.0 to v3.6.0 2026-03-16 00:32:06 +00:00
Member

Implementation journal (Phase 1 + Phase 2, in-progress):

  • Verified issue metadata and workflow prerequisites:
    • Issue state: open
    • Assignment updated to brent.edwards (requirement check)
    • State label transitioned from State/Verified to State/In Progress
  • Created isolated workspace at /tmp/cleveragents-772 with remotes configured per parallel-agent rules (origin set to Forgejo HTTPS PAT URL, upstream set to /app) and git identity set to Brent E. Edwards.
  • Reviewed required project docs: docs/specification.md, CONTRIBUTING.md, and docs/timeline.md.
  • Mapped implementation to specification Workflow Example 8 section (docs/specification.md around Example 8), including:
    • custom resource type (local/terraform-state)
    • custom skill (local/terraform-ops)
    • supervised automation profile usage
    • optimization recommendation + invariant enforcement expectations

TDD progress:

  • Added new Robot integration suite: robot/wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.robot
  • Added helper driver: robot/helper_wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.py
  • Added Terraform and config fixtures under robot/fixtures/wf08/:
    • resource-types/terraform-state.yaml
    • skills/terraform-ops.yaml
    • terraform/terraform.tfstate.json
    • terraform/cloud-metrics.json
    • terraform/main.tf
  • Added deterministic mocked execution components in helper:
    • MockLLMPlanner for recommendation generation
    • MockTerraformOps for terraform_show/cloud_metrics/terraform_plan behavior
    • invariant enforcement gate that blocks critical resource deletions

Validation during TDD cycle:

  • Ran nox -s integration_tests -- --include wf08
  • First run caught one failure in WF08 registration path (incorrect Skill attribute access in helper).
  • Fixed helper (skill.name access) and re-ran same integration scope successfully:
    • 4 tests passed (WF08 Terraform Fixtures, WF08 Registers Terraform Resource Type And Skill Composition, WF08 Uses Mocked LLM And Mocked Terraform Operations, WF08 Supervised Infrastructure Workflow Enforces Invariants).

Next steps:

  • Run remaining required quality gates (lint, typecheck, unit_tests, full integration_tests, e2e_tests, coverage_report, then full nox)
  • Update issue subtasks checklist and proceed to commit/PR once all gates are green.
Implementation journal (Phase 1 + Phase 2, in-progress): - Verified issue metadata and workflow prerequisites: - Issue state: open - Assignment updated to `brent.edwards` (requirement check) - State label transitioned from `State/Verified` to `State/In Progress` - Created isolated workspace at `/tmp/cleveragents-772` with remotes configured per parallel-agent rules (`origin` set to Forgejo HTTPS PAT URL, `upstream` set to `/app`) and git identity set to Brent E. Edwards. - Reviewed required project docs: `docs/specification.md`, `CONTRIBUTING.md`, and `docs/timeline.md`. - Mapped implementation to specification Workflow Example 8 section (`docs/specification.md` around Example 8), including: - custom resource type (`local/terraform-state`) - custom skill (`local/terraform-ops`) - supervised automation profile usage - optimization recommendation + invariant enforcement expectations TDD progress: - Added new Robot integration suite: `robot/wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.robot` - Added helper driver: `robot/helper_wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.py` - Added Terraform and config fixtures under `robot/fixtures/wf08/`: - `resource-types/terraform-state.yaml` - `skills/terraform-ops.yaml` - `terraform/terraform.tfstate.json` - `terraform/cloud-metrics.json` - `terraform/main.tf` - Added deterministic mocked execution components in helper: - `MockLLMPlanner` for recommendation generation - `MockTerraformOps` for terraform_show/cloud_metrics/terraform_plan behavior - invariant enforcement gate that blocks critical resource deletions Validation during TDD cycle: - Ran `nox -s integration_tests -- --include wf08` - First run caught one failure in WF08 registration path (incorrect `Skill` attribute access in helper). - Fixed helper (`skill.name` access) and re-ran same integration scope successfully: - 4 tests passed (`WF08 Terraform Fixtures`, `WF08 Registers Terraform Resource Type And Skill Composition`, `WF08 Uses Mocked LLM And Mocked Terraform Operations`, `WF08 Supervised Infrastructure Workflow Enforces Invariants`). Next steps: - Run remaining required quality gates (`lint`, `typecheck`, `unit_tests`, full `integration_tests`, `e2e_tests`, `coverage_report`, then full `nox`) - Update issue subtasks checklist and proceed to commit/PR once all gates are green.
Member

Implementation Notes (Fresh Implementation)

Background

The previous LLM working on this ticket created a workspace at /tmp/cleveragents-772 but no remote branch was pushed. The prior work is not reusable. An existing test/e2e-wf08-cloud-infra branch exists for the E2E variant of this test (different issue) but this is the integration test variant.

Design Decisions

Test Architecture: Followed the established integration test pattern from wf07_cicd_integration.robot and int_wf05_db_migration.robot:

  • Robot Framework .robot file dispatches to Python helper subcommands
  • Each subcommand is self-contained, prints sentinel on success
  • Uses real service layer (PlanLifecycleService, ResourceRegistryService, SkillService, AutomationProfileService) with in-memory SQLite for DB-dependent tests
  • Mock AI enabled via CLEVERAGENTS_TESTING_USE_MOCK_AI env var (set by common.resource)

Test Cases (6 total):

  1. register-terraform-resource-type — Registers local/terraform-state via YAML fixture with copy_on_write sandbox strategy, 2 cli_args, and creates a resource instance
  2. register-terraform-skill — Creates local/terraform-ops skill with 3 anonymous tools and includes: [local/file-ops] skill composition
  3. supervised-profile-behavior — Verifies supervised profile gates both strategize→execute (create_tool=1.0) and execute→apply (select_tool=1.0) transitions via should_auto_progress()
  4. create-infra-optimize-action — Creates action with supervised profile, 2 typed arguments (STRING + FLOAT), 2 invariants; verifies plan creation and invariant propagation via InvariantSource.ACTION
  5. infra-analysis-recommendations — Runs mocked infrastructure analysis using fixture data, verifies right-sizing recommendations for over-provisioned resources, confirms critical resources are skipped
  6. invariant-enforcement — Verifies invariants propagate to plans, simulates enforcement check blocking critical resource modifications while allowing non-critical changes

Fixture Files (under robot/fixtures/wf08/):

  • terraform-state.yaml — Custom resource type definition matching spec Example 8 Step 1
  • terraform.tfstate.json — Mock Terraform state with 3 resources (web instance, API instance, S3 bucket)
  • cloud-metrics.json — Mock CloudWatch metrics showing web instance at ~12% avg CPU (over-provisioned)
  • main.tf — Sample Terraform config file for reference

Key Spec Alignment:

  • Resource type uses copy_on_write (not filesystem_copy — aligned with SandboxStrategy enum values)
  • child_types field expects list[str] (resource type names), not dicts
  • FLOAT arguments require actual numeric values (not string representations) when passed to use_action()
  • Supervised profile has create_tool=1.0, select_tool=1.0 → both transitions gated

Quality Gate Results

All 11 nox sessions pass:

  • lint
  • format
  • typecheck (pyright: 0 errors)
  • security_scan (bandit + semgrep + vulture)
  • dead_code
  • unit_tests (509 features, 12989 scenarios)
  • integration_tests (1862 tests, 0 failed — includes 6 new WF08 tests)
  • docs
  • build
  • benchmark
  • coverage_report (97.0% ≥ 97% threshold)
## Implementation Notes (Fresh Implementation) ### Background The previous LLM working on this ticket created a workspace at `/tmp/cleveragents-772` but no remote branch was pushed. The prior work is not reusable. An existing `test/e2e-wf08-cloud-infra` branch exists for the E2E variant of this test (different issue) but this is the **integration** test variant. ### Design Decisions **Test Architecture:** Followed the established integration test pattern from `wf07_cicd_integration.robot` and `int_wf05_db_migration.robot`: - Robot Framework `.robot` file dispatches to Python helper subcommands - Each subcommand is self-contained, prints sentinel on success - Uses real service layer (PlanLifecycleService, ResourceRegistryService, SkillService, AutomationProfileService) with in-memory SQLite for DB-dependent tests - Mock AI enabled via `CLEVERAGENTS_TESTING_USE_MOCK_AI` env var (set by `common.resource`) **Test Cases (6 total):** 1. `register-terraform-resource-type` — Registers `local/terraform-state` via YAML fixture with `copy_on_write` sandbox strategy, 2 cli_args, and creates a resource instance 2. `register-terraform-skill` — Creates `local/terraform-ops` skill with 3 anonymous tools and `includes: [local/file-ops]` skill composition 3. `supervised-profile-behavior` — Verifies supervised profile gates both strategize→execute (`create_tool=1.0`) and execute→apply (`select_tool=1.0`) transitions via `should_auto_progress()` 4. `create-infra-optimize-action` — Creates action with supervised profile, 2 typed arguments (STRING + FLOAT), 2 invariants; verifies plan creation and invariant propagation via `InvariantSource.ACTION` 5. `infra-analysis-recommendations` — Runs mocked infrastructure analysis using fixture data, verifies right-sizing recommendations for over-provisioned resources, confirms critical resources are skipped 6. `invariant-enforcement` — Verifies invariants propagate to plans, simulates enforcement check blocking critical resource modifications while allowing non-critical changes **Fixture Files (under `robot/fixtures/wf08/`):** - `terraform-state.yaml` — Custom resource type definition matching spec Example 8 Step 1 - `terraform.tfstate.json` — Mock Terraform state with 3 resources (web instance, API instance, S3 bucket) - `cloud-metrics.json` — Mock CloudWatch metrics showing web instance at ~12% avg CPU (over-provisioned) - `main.tf` — Sample Terraform config file for reference **Key Spec Alignment:** - Resource type uses `copy_on_write` (not `filesystem_copy` — aligned with `SandboxStrategy` enum values) - `child_types` field expects `list[str]` (resource type names), not dicts - FLOAT arguments require actual numeric values (not string representations) when passed to `use_action()` - Supervised profile has `create_tool=1.0, select_tool=1.0` → both transitions gated ### Quality Gate Results All 11 nox sessions pass: - ✅ lint - ✅ format - ✅ typecheck (pyright: 0 errors) - ✅ security_scan (bandit + semgrep + vulture) - ✅ dead_code - ✅ unit_tests (509 features, 12989 scenarios) - ✅ integration_tests (1862 tests, 0 failed — includes 6 new WF08 tests) - ✅ docs - ✅ build - ✅ benchmark - ✅ coverage_report (97.0% ≥ 97% threshold)
Author
Owner

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged.

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged.
freemo self-assigned this 2026-04-02 06:14:00 +00:00
Author
Owner

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged.

Review summary: All 6 integration test cases for Workflow Example 8 (Cloud Infrastructure Management with supervised profile) passed independent code review. The implementation correctly exercises custom resource types, skill composition, supervised profile gating, action creation with invariants, infrastructure analysis, and invariant enforcement — all aligned with the specification. Code follows established patterns from wf05/wf07 integration tests.

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged. **Review summary:** All 6 integration test cases for Workflow Example 8 (Cloud Infrastructure Management with supervised profile) passed independent code review. The implementation correctly exercises custom resource types, skill composition, supervised profile gating, action creation with invariants, infrastructure analysis, and invariant enforcement — all aligned with the specification. Code follows established patterns from wf05/wf07 integration tests.
Author
Owner

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged.

Integration test for Workflow Example 8 (Cloud Infrastructure Management with supervised profile) is now on master. All 6 test cases covering custom resource types, skill composition, supervised profile gating, action creation with invariants, infrastructure analysis, and invariant enforcement are merged.

PR #1231 reviewed, approved, and merged. Integration test for Workflow Example 8 (Cloud Infrastructure Management with supervised profile) is now on `master`. All 6 test cases covering custom resource types, skill composition, supervised profile gating, action creation with invariants, infrastructure analysis, and invariant enforcement are merged.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
2 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#772
No description provided.