[CA-AUTO] Spec Updater — Session Tracker — 2026-04-05 #3129

Closed
opened 2026-04-05 06:38:04 +00:00 by freemo · 12 comments
Owner

This issue tracks the continuous spec-updater session for the CleverAgents Core repository.

All progress reports, proposal summaries, and health signals will be posted as comments here. Do not close this issue manually — it is managed by the spec-updater bot.

Session Info

  • Instance ID: spec-updater-1
  • Started: 2026-04-05
  • Master HEAD at start: 8c079943e635
  • Sleep interval: 900s between cycles

Pending Proposals (awaiting human approval)

Issue Description Status
#3121 Invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions needs feedback
#3123 Invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions (duplicate) needs feedback

Note

: Issues #3121 and #3123 are duplicate proposals for the same spec change, both created before this session started. This session will track #3121 as the canonical proposal and close #3123 as a duplicate.

Recently Merged PRs Analyzed

PR Title Spec Impact
#1205 feat(plan): wire invariant reconciliation actor auto-invocation Proposal #3121 created
#3022 test(providers): add ASV performance benchmark suite No spec impact (benchmarks only)
#2886 docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95 No spec impact (timeline only)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

This issue tracks the continuous spec-updater session for the CleverAgents Core repository. All progress reports, proposal summaries, and health signals will be posted as comments here. Do **not** close this issue manually — it is managed by the spec-updater bot. ## Session Info - **Instance ID**: spec-updater-1 - **Started**: 2026-04-05 - **Master HEAD at start**: `8c079943e635` - **Sleep interval**: 900s between cycles ## Pending Proposals (awaiting human approval) | Issue | Description | Status | |-------|-------------|--------| | #3121 | Invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions | `needs feedback` | | #3123 | Invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions (duplicate) | `needs feedback` | > **Note**: Issues #3121 and #3123 are duplicate proposals for the same spec change, both created before this session started. This session will track #3121 as the canonical proposal and close #3123 as a duplicate. ## Recently Merged PRs Analyzed | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #1205 | `feat(plan): wire invariant reconciliation actor auto-invocation` | Proposal #3121 created | | #3022 | `test(providers): add ASV performance benchmark suite` | No spec impact (benchmarks only) | | #2886 | `docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95` | No spec impact (timeline only) | --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 1 — Initial Setup Complete

Master HEAD: 8c079943e635
Status: Initialized. Picked up existing pending proposals from previous spec-updater run.

Actions Taken

  • Created session state issue #3129
  • Identified duplicate proposal #3123 → closed as duplicate of #3121
  • Canonical pending proposal: #3121 (invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions)

Recently Merged PRs Analyzed (since last known state)

PR Title Spec Impact
#1205 feat(plan): wire invariant reconciliation actor auto-invocation → Proposal #3121 (pending approval)
#3022 test(providers): add ASV performance benchmark suite None — benchmarks only, no spec changes needed
#2886 docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95 None — timeline doc only

Pending Proposals

Issue Key Status
#3121 invariant_reconciliation_auto_invocation needs feedback — awaiting human approval

Next cycle in ~15 minutes.

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 1: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: initial


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 1 — Initial Setup Complete **Master HEAD**: `8c079943e635` **Status**: Initialized. Picked up existing pending proposals from previous spec-updater run. ### Actions Taken - Created session state issue #3129 - Identified duplicate proposal #3123 → closed as duplicate of #3121 - Canonical pending proposal: **#3121** (invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions) ### Recently Merged PRs Analyzed (since last known state) | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #1205 | `feat(plan): wire invariant reconciliation actor auto-invocation` | → Proposal #3121 (pending approval) | | #3022 | `test(providers): add ASV performance benchmark suite` | None — benchmarks only, no spec changes needed | | #2886 | `docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95` | None — timeline doc only | ### Pending Proposals | Issue | Key | Status | |-------|-----|--------| | #3121 | `invariant_reconciliation_auto_invocation` | `needs feedback` — awaiting human approval | Next cycle in ~15 minutes. [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 1: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: initial --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 2

Master HEAD: e2057f9117ba (advanced from 8c079943e635)

New Merged PRs

PR Title Spec Impact
#3080 docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95 (2026-04-05) — refreshed with live data None — timeline doc only

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified, Priority/Backlog, Type/Task No — comment from architect-1 bot recommends approval but is automated, not human Still pending

Note

: Issue #3121 received an automated architectural review from architect-1 bot recommending approval. This is a bot comment, not a human approval signal. Awaiting human review.

Summary

  • No new spec proposals needed
  • No proposals approved yet
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 2: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 2 **Master HEAD**: `e2057f9117ba` (advanced from `8c079943e635`) ### New Merged PRs | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #3080 | `docs(timeline): update schedule adherence Day 95 (2026-04-05) — refreshed with live data` | None — timeline doc only | ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified`, `Priority/Backlog`, `Type/Task` | No — comment from `architect-1` bot recommends approval but is automated, not human | Still pending | > **Note**: Issue #3121 received an automated architectural review from `architect-1` bot recommending approval. This is a bot comment, not a human approval signal. Awaiting human review. ### Summary - No new spec proposals needed - No proposals approved yet - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 2: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 3

Master HEAD: e2057f9117ba (no change — idle cycle 1)

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 3: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 3 **Master HEAD**: `e2057f9117ba` (no change — idle cycle 1) ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 3: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Closing as duplicate of #3110 — both are Spec Updater session state trackers for 2026-04-05. The existing tracker #3110 is the canonical one.


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Backlog Grooming | Agent: ca-backlog-groomer

Closing as duplicate of #3110 — both are Spec Updater session state trackers for 2026-04-05. The existing tracker #3110 is the canonical one. --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Backlog Grooming | Agent: ca-backlog-groomer
Author
Owner

Cycle 4

Master HEAD: e2057f9117ba (no change — idle cycle 2)

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 4: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 4 **Master HEAD**: `e2057f9117ba` (no change — idle cycle 2) ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 4: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 5

Master HEAD: 1411adfed36c (advanced from e2057f9117ba)

New Merged PRs

PR Title Spec Impact
#3165 fix(lsp): release lock before blocking I/O in LspLifecycleManager.restart_server() to prevent deadlock None — bug fix correcting a deadlock in restart_server() by applying the same 3-phase lock pattern already used by start_server(). This is an implementation detail (concurrency safety) that does not change any specified behavior. The spec's description of restart_server (restart a crashed server, re-initialize LSP handshake) remains accurate.

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • 1 new merged PR analyzed — no spec changes needed
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 5: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 5 **Master HEAD**: `1411adfed36c` (advanced from `e2057f9117ba`) ### New Merged PRs | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #3165 | `fix(lsp): release lock before blocking I/O in LspLifecycleManager.restart_server() to prevent deadlock` | **None** — bug fix correcting a deadlock in `restart_server()` by applying the same 3-phase lock pattern already used by `start_server()`. This is an implementation detail (concurrency safety) that does not change any specified behavior. The spec's description of `restart_server` (restart a crashed server, re-initialize LSP handshake) remains accurate. | ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - 1 new merged PR analyzed — no spec changes needed - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 5: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 6

Master HEAD: 1411adfed36c (no change — idle cycle 1)

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 6: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 6 **Master HEAD**: `1411adfed36c` (no change — idle cycle 1) ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 6: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 1 — 2026-04-05 — Startup Report

Session Initialized

  • Clone: /tmp/ca-spec-updater-1
  • Master HEAD: e2057f91 (at clone time), now at 1411adfe (fetched)
  • Spec file: docs/specification.md (46,597 lines — single file, no split needed)

Pending Proposals Checked

Issue Title Status
#3121 Proposal: invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions Still pending (needs feedback, State/Unverified)
#3078 Proposal: plan list --namespace option and MCPToolAdapter MCP 1.4.0 error extraction Still pending (needs feedback, State/Unverified)
#3064 Proposal: fix invariant precedence chain and document non_overridable flag APPROVED (State/Verified)

Actions Taken

Proposal #3064 — APPROVED → Implemented

Proposal #3064 had State/Verified label (approved). Implemented the spec changes:

  1. Branch created: spec/update-m4-invariant-precedence-non-overridable
  2. 6 changes applied to docs/specification.md:
    • Glossary "Invariant" entry: 3-tier → 4-tier precedence + non_overridable exception note
    • Line 18980: plan > project > globalplan > action > project > global (Invariant Reconciliation Actor step 5)
    • Line 18991: plan > project > globalplan > action > project > global (Strategize description)
    • Lines 19601–19604: Updated Precedence section to include action tier as distinct scope + non_overridable exception clause
    • Line 19618: Updated invariant view calculation step 3
    • Lines 19621+: Added Non-overridable global invariants documentation block
  3. PR created: #3268needs feedback label added
  4. Do NOT merge — awaiting human review

Recently Merged PRs Reviewed

  • PR #3080: docs(timeline) — no spec changes needed
  • PR #3022: test(providers): add ASV benchmarks — no spec changes needed
  • PR #2629: fix(ci): restore CI quality gates — no spec changes needed
  • PR #2616: fix(cli): add --namespace/-n option to agents plan list — covered by pending proposal #3078
  • PR #2600: fix(mcp): extract error message from content[0].text per MCP 1.4.0 — covered by pending proposal #3078
  • PR #2599: docs: update specification — inline PermissionQuestionWidget — already merged to spec

Monolithic/Split Status

Spec is 46,597 lines — single file. Proposal #2521 for restructuring is still open/pending. No action taken this cycle.


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 1 — 2026-04-05 — Startup Report ### Session Initialized - Clone: `/tmp/ca-spec-updater-1` - Master HEAD: `e2057f91` (at clone time), now at `1411adfe` (fetched) - Spec file: `docs/specification.md` (46,597 lines — single file, no split needed) ### Pending Proposals Checked | Issue | Title | Status | |-------|-------|--------| | #3121 | Proposal: invariant reconciliation auto-invocation at all phase transitions | Still pending (`needs feedback`, `State/Unverified`) | | #3078 | Proposal: plan list --namespace option and MCPToolAdapter MCP 1.4.0 error extraction | Still pending (`needs feedback`, `State/Unverified`) | | #3064 | Proposal: fix invariant precedence chain and document non_overridable flag | **APPROVED** (`State/Verified`) | ### Actions Taken #### Proposal #3064 — APPROVED → Implemented Proposal #3064 had `State/Verified` label (approved). Implemented the spec changes: 1. **Branch created**: `spec/update-m4-invariant-precedence-non-overridable` 2. **6 changes applied** to `docs/specification.md`: - Glossary "Invariant" entry: 3-tier → 4-tier precedence + `non_overridable` exception note - Line 18980: `plan > project > global` → `plan > action > project > global` (Invariant Reconciliation Actor step 5) - Line 18991: `plan > project > global` → `plan > action > project > global` (Strategize description) - Lines 19601–19604: Updated Precedence section to include action tier as distinct scope + non_overridable exception clause - Line 19618: Updated invariant view calculation step 3 - Lines 19621+: Added **Non-overridable global invariants** documentation block 3. **PR created**: [#3268](https://git.cleverthis.com/cleveragents/cleveragents-core/pulls/3268) — `needs feedback` label added 4. **Do NOT merge** — awaiting human review ### Recently Merged PRs Reviewed - PR #3080: `docs(timeline)` — no spec changes needed - PR #3022: `test(providers): add ASV benchmarks` — no spec changes needed - PR #2629: `fix(ci): restore CI quality gates` — no spec changes needed - PR #2616: `fix(cli): add --namespace/-n option to agents plan list` — covered by pending proposal #3078 - PR #2600: `fix(mcp): extract error message from content[0].text per MCP 1.4.0` — covered by pending proposal #3078 - PR #2599: `docs: update specification — inline PermissionQuestionWidget` — already merged to spec ### Monolithic/Split Status Spec is 46,597 lines — single file. Proposal #2521 for restructuring is still open/pending. No action taken this cycle. --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 7

Master HEAD: ffb67e15b9eb (advanced from 1411adfed36c)

New Merged PRs

PR Title Spec Impact
#1411 chore(agents): add auto-rebase on conflict to PR reviewer pool supervisor None — agent infrastructure improvement (PR reviewer auto-rebase behavior). Not a product feature; no spec changes needed.

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • 1 new merged PR analyzed — no spec changes needed
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 7: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 7 **Master HEAD**: `ffb67e15b9eb` (advanced from `1411adfed36c`) ### New Merged PRs | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #1411 | `chore(agents): add auto-rebase on conflict to PR reviewer pool supervisor` | **None** — agent infrastructure improvement (PR reviewer auto-rebase behavior). Not a product feature; no spec changes needed. | ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - 1 new merged PR analyzed — no spec changes needed - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 7: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: merged-pr-check --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 8

Master HEAD: ffb67e15b9eb (no change — idle cycle 1)

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 8: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 8 **Master HEAD**: `ffb67e15b9eb` (no change — idle cycle 1) ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 8: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 9

Master HEAD: ffb67e15b9eb (no change — idle cycle 2)

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 9: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 9 **Master HEAD**: `ffb67e15b9eb` (no change — idle cycle 2) ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 9: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Author
Owner

Cycle 10 — Context Reset

Master HEAD: ffb67e15b9eb (no change — idle cycle 3)

Context self-management performed: accumulated tool outputs discarded. Persistent state retained.

Pending Proposals Check

Issue Labels Human Approval? Action
#3121 needs feedback, State/Unverified No Still pending

Summary

  • No new merged PRs
  • No proposals approved
  • Pending: #3121

[HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 10: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater

## Cycle 10 — Context Reset **Master HEAD**: `ffb67e15b9eb` (no change — idle cycle 3) *Context self-management performed: accumulated tool outputs discarded. Persistent state retained.* ### Pending Proposals Check | Issue | Labels | Human Approval? | Action | |-------|--------|-----------------|--------| | #3121 | `needs feedback`, `State/Unverified` | No | Still pending | ### Summary - No new merged PRs - No proposals approved - Pending: #3121 [HEALTH] spec-updater cycle 10: alive, proposals_pending: 1, proposals_created_total: 1, last_scan: idle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: ca-spec-updater
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#3129
No description provided.