[AUTO-SPEC-1] Specification Evolution: v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 Feature Documentation #10526

Open
opened 2026-04-18 17:04:39 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment
Owner

Specification Evolution Monitoring

Supervisor: Specification Evolution Supervisor
Cycle: 1 (started 2026-04-18)
Status: ACTIVE

Current Focus

Monitoring and updating specification for v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 features.

Open PRs Being Monitored

  1. PR #10009 - "docs(spec): fix invariant reconciliation, add ACMS thread safety, v3.6.0 section, ADR-049"

    • Status: OPEN (awaiting feedback)
    • Updates: docs/specification.md with v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts section
    • Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation
  2. PR #9903 - "[AUTO-DOCS-5] docs(milestone): Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts and v3.7.0 TUI documentation"

    • Status: OPEN (in review)
    • Updates: docs/advanced-concepts.md, docs/tui.md, CHANGELOG.md, mkdocs.yml
    • Labels: Type/Documentation, Priority/Medium, State/In Review, MoSCoW/Should have
    • Issues: CI failures (e2e_tests), file size violations, missing metadata

Key Milestones

  • v3.6.0 (M7): Advanced Concepts 6 Deferred Features
  • v3.7.0 (M8): TUI Implementation

Next Steps

  1. Monitor PR #10009 for human feedback
  2. Monitor PR #9903 for CI resolution
  3. Identify specification gaps not covered by these PRs
  4. Create proposal issues for any additional spec updates needed
  5. Dispatch workers to implement approved spec changes

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Agent: automation-tracking-manager

## Specification Evolution Monitoring **Supervisor:** Specification Evolution Supervisor **Cycle:** 1 (started 2026-04-18) **Status:** ACTIVE ### Current Focus Monitoring and updating specification for v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 features. ### Open PRs Being Monitored 1. **PR #10009** - "docs(spec): fix invariant reconciliation, add ACMS thread safety, v3.6.0 section, ADR-049" - Status: OPEN (awaiting feedback) - Updates: docs/specification.md with v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts section - Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation 2. **PR #9903** - "[AUTO-DOCS-5] docs(milestone): Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts and v3.7.0 TUI documentation" - Status: OPEN (in review) - Updates: docs/advanced-concepts.md, docs/tui.md, CHANGELOG.md, mkdocs.yml - Labels: Type/Documentation, Priority/Medium, State/In Review, MoSCoW/Should have - Issues: CI failures (e2e_tests), file size violations, missing metadata ### Key Milestones - **v3.6.0 (M7)**: Advanced Concepts 6 Deferred Features - **v3.7.0 (M8)**: TUI Implementation ### Next Steps 1. Monitor PR #10009 for human feedback 2. Monitor PR #9903 for CI resolution 3. Identify specification gaps not covered by these PRs 4. Create proposal issues for any additional spec updates needed 5. Dispatch workers to implement approved spec changes --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Agent: automation-tracking-manager
Author
Owner

Specification Evolution Monitoring - Cycle 1 Update

Supervisor: Specification Evolution Supervisor
Cycle: 1 (started 2026-04-18)
Status: ACTIVE - Monitoring 5 specification PRs

Specification PRs Being Monitored

1. PR #10009 - v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts & ACMS Thread Safety

  • Title: docs(spec): fix invariant reconciliation, add ACMS thread safety, v3.6.0 section, ADR-049
  • Status: OPEN (awaiting feedback)
  • Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation
  • Changes:
    • Fix invariant reconciliation spec (multi-phase enforcement)
    • Document ACMS thread-safety model (threading.RLock usage)
    • Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts spec section
    • Create ADR-049 (CLI communication pattern)
  • Related Issues: Closes #9899, #9859
  • Priority: HIGH (core v3.6.0 specification)

2. PR #10026 - Invariant Phase Boundaries & ACMS Thread Safety Clarifications

  • Title: docs(spec): clarify invariant phase boundaries and ACMS thread-safety model [AUTO-ARCH-23]
  • Status: OPEN
  • Labels: Type/Documentation
  • Changes:
    • Clarify invariant phase boundaries (every phase boundary, not just Strategize)
    • Document ACMS context tier thread-safety (threading.RLock)
  • Related Issues: Fixes #9899, #9859
  • Priority: MEDIUM (minor clarifications)

3. PR #10052 - A2A Boundary Enforcement & ADR-049

  • Title: docs(spec): add ADR-049 and layer boundary enforcement specification [AUTO-ARCH-24]
  • Status: OPEN (awaiting feedback)
  • Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation
  • Changes:
    • Create ADR-049 (A2A boundary enforcement)
    • Add Layer Boundary Enforcement section to specification
    • Document forbidden import patterns
    • Document permitted communication flow
  • Related Issues: Closes #9962
  • Priority: HIGH (architectural enforcement)

4. PR #10451 - Architectural Clarifications (Layer Boundary DI, ULID Scope, TUI/ACMS)

  • Title: [AUTO-ARCH-1] Spec clarifications: layer boundary DI exception, ULID scope, TUI/ACMS gap-fill
  • Status: OPEN (awaiting feedback)
  • Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation
  • Milestone: v3.9.0
  • Changes:
    • Layer Boundary DI Container Exception (application/container.py)
    • ULID Scope Clarification (domain vs. internal IDs)
    • ACMS Pipeline Protocol Contracts (10-stage pipeline)
    • TUI Component Interfaces (8 components)
  • Priority: HIGH (fills architectural gaps)

5. PR #9903 - v3.6.0 & v3.7.0 Comprehensive Documentation

  • Title: [AUTO-DOCS-5] docs(milestone): Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts and v3.7.0 TUI documentation
  • Status: OPEN (in review with CI failures)
  • Labels: Type/Documentation, Priority/Medium, State/In Review, MoSCoW/Should have
  • Milestone: v3.7.0
  • Changes:
    • Create docs/advanced-concepts.md (v3.6.0 features)
    • Create docs/tui.md (v3.7.0 features)
    • Update CHANGELOG.md with v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 sections
    • Update mkdocs.yml with new documentation entries
  • Issues:
    • CI failures (e2e_tests, status-check)
    • File size violations (advanced-concepts.md: 554 lines, tui.md: 634 lines - limit 500)
    • Missing Closes #N reference
    • Branch naming convention violation (docs/ prefix instead of feature/mN-)
    • Missing ISSUES CLOSED footer in commit
    • CONTRIBUTORS.md not updated
  • Priority: HIGH (comprehensive v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 documentation)

Specification Coverage Analysis

v3.6.0 (M7): Advanced Concepts & Deferred Features

Covered by PRs:

  • Advanced Context Strategies (PR #9903)
  • Additional LLM Backends (PR #9903)
  • New Resource Types (PR #9903)
  • ACP to A2A Module Rename (PR #9903)
  • Container Tool Execution (PR #9903)
  • Pluggable Scope Chain Resolution (PR #9903)
  • Cost and Session Budgets (PR #9903)
  • E2E Workflow Specification Tests (PR #9903)
  • Code Review Tool Examples (PR #9903)
  • Plugin Architecture Extensions (PR #9903)
  • ACMS Pipeline Protocol Contracts (PR #10451)
  • ACMS Thread Safety (PR #10009, #10026)
  • Invariant Phase Boundaries (PR #10009, #10026)

v3.7.0 (M8): TUI Implementation

Covered by PRs:

  • TUI Installation and Setup (PR #9903)
  • MainScreen Layout (PR #9903)
  • Persona System (PR #9903)
  • Reference and Command Input System (PR #9903)
  • Session Management (PR #9903)
  • Settings and Configuration (PR #9903)
  • Theming and UI (PR #9903)
  • TuiMaterializer Integration (PR #9903)
  • TUI Component Interfaces (PR #10451)

Architectural Clarifications

Covered by PRs:

  • Layer Boundary DI Exception (PR #10451)
  • ULID Scope Clarification (PR #10451)
  • A2A Boundary Enforcement (PR #10052)
  • ADR-049 Documentation (PR #10009, #10052)

Monitoring Plan

Cycle 1 (Current):

  1. Identified all specification PRs
  2. Created proposal issue (#10533)
  3. Analyzed coverage and gaps
  4. Created tracking issue (#10526)
  5. Monitor PR #10009 for human feedback
  6. Monitor PR #10451 for human feedback
  7. Monitor PR #10052 for human feedback
  8. Monitor PR #9903 for CI resolution

Next Cycle (15 minutes):

  1. Check for human feedback on "Needs Feedback" PRs
  2. Monitor CI status of PR #9903
  3. Check for any new specification-related PRs
  4. Identify any remaining gaps
  5. Create additional proposal issues if needed

Key Metrics

  • Total Specification PRs: 5
  • Awaiting Feedback: 3 (PR #10009, #10052, #10451)
  • In Review with Issues: 1 (PR #9903)
  • Minor Clarifications: 1 (PR #10026)
  • Specification Coverage: ~95% for v3.6.0 and v3.7.0

Next Steps

  1. Monitor PR #10009 - Awaiting human feedback on v3.6.0 section and ADR-049
  2. Monitor PR #10451 - Awaiting human feedback on architectural clarifications
  3. Monitor PR #10052 - Awaiting human feedback on A2A boundary enforcement
  4. Resolve PR #9903 Issues:
    • Fix e2e_tests CI failure
    • Split documentation files to comply with 500-line limit
    • Add missing metadata (Closes #N, ISSUES CLOSED footer, CONTRIBUTORS.md)
    • Fix branch naming convention
  5. Merge approved PRs in order of dependency
  6. Verify specification matches implementation after merges

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Agent: automation-tracking-manager

## Specification Evolution Monitoring - Cycle 1 Update **Supervisor:** Specification Evolution Supervisor **Cycle:** 1 (started 2026-04-18) **Status:** ACTIVE - Monitoring 5 specification PRs ### Specification PRs Being Monitored #### 1. PR #10009 - v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts & ACMS Thread Safety - **Title:** docs(spec): fix invariant reconciliation, add ACMS thread safety, v3.6.0 section, ADR-049 - **Status:** OPEN (awaiting feedback) - **Labels:** Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation - **Changes:** - Fix invariant reconciliation spec (multi-phase enforcement) - Document ACMS thread-safety model (threading.RLock usage) - Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts spec section - Create ADR-049 (CLI communication pattern) - **Related Issues:** Closes #9899, #9859 - **Priority:** HIGH (core v3.6.0 specification) #### 2. PR #10026 - Invariant Phase Boundaries & ACMS Thread Safety Clarifications - **Title:** docs(spec): clarify invariant phase boundaries and ACMS thread-safety model [AUTO-ARCH-23] - **Status:** OPEN - **Labels:** Type/Documentation - **Changes:** - Clarify invariant phase boundaries (every phase boundary, not just Strategize) - Document ACMS context tier thread-safety (threading.RLock) - **Related Issues:** Fixes #9899, #9859 - **Priority:** MEDIUM (minor clarifications) #### 3. PR #10052 - A2A Boundary Enforcement & ADR-049 - **Title:** docs(spec): add ADR-049 and layer boundary enforcement specification [AUTO-ARCH-24] - **Status:** OPEN (awaiting feedback) - **Labels:** Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation - **Changes:** - Create ADR-049 (A2A boundary enforcement) - Add Layer Boundary Enforcement section to specification - Document forbidden import patterns - Document permitted communication flow - **Related Issues:** Closes #9962 - **Priority:** HIGH (architectural enforcement) #### 4. PR #10451 - Architectural Clarifications (Layer Boundary DI, ULID Scope, TUI/ACMS) - **Title:** [AUTO-ARCH-1] Spec clarifications: layer boundary DI exception, ULID scope, TUI/ACMS gap-fill - **Status:** OPEN (awaiting feedback) - **Labels:** Needs Feedback, Type/Documentation - **Milestone:** v3.9.0 - **Changes:** - Layer Boundary DI Container Exception (application/container.py) - ULID Scope Clarification (domain vs. internal IDs) - ACMS Pipeline Protocol Contracts (10-stage pipeline) - TUI Component Interfaces (8 components) - **Priority:** HIGH (fills architectural gaps) #### 5. PR #9903 - v3.6.0 & v3.7.0 Comprehensive Documentation - **Title:** [AUTO-DOCS-5] docs(milestone): Add v3.6.0 Advanced Concepts and v3.7.0 TUI documentation - **Status:** OPEN (in review with CI failures) - **Labels:** Type/Documentation, Priority/Medium, State/In Review, MoSCoW/Should have - **Milestone:** v3.7.0 - **Changes:** - Create docs/advanced-concepts.md (v3.6.0 features) - Create docs/tui.md (v3.7.0 features) - Update CHANGELOG.md with v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 sections - Update mkdocs.yml with new documentation entries - **Issues:** - ❌ CI failures (e2e_tests, status-check) - ❌ File size violations (advanced-concepts.md: 554 lines, tui.md: 634 lines - limit 500) - ❌ Missing Closes #N reference - ❌ Branch naming convention violation (docs/ prefix instead of feature/mN-) - ❌ Missing ISSUES CLOSED footer in commit - ❌ CONTRIBUTORS.md not updated - **Priority:** HIGH (comprehensive v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 documentation) ### Specification Coverage Analysis #### v3.6.0 (M7): Advanced Concepts & Deferred Features **Covered by PRs:** - ✅ Advanced Context Strategies (PR #9903) - ✅ Additional LLM Backends (PR #9903) - ✅ New Resource Types (PR #9903) - ✅ ACP to A2A Module Rename (PR #9903) - ✅ Container Tool Execution (PR #9903) - ✅ Pluggable Scope Chain Resolution (PR #9903) - ✅ Cost and Session Budgets (PR #9903) - ✅ E2E Workflow Specification Tests (PR #9903) - ✅ Code Review Tool Examples (PR #9903) - ✅ Plugin Architecture Extensions (PR #9903) - ✅ ACMS Pipeline Protocol Contracts (PR #10451) - ✅ ACMS Thread Safety (PR #10009, #10026) - ✅ Invariant Phase Boundaries (PR #10009, #10026) #### v3.7.0 (M8): TUI Implementation **Covered by PRs:** - ✅ TUI Installation and Setup (PR #9903) - ✅ MainScreen Layout (PR #9903) - ✅ Persona System (PR #9903) - ✅ Reference and Command Input System (PR #9903) - ✅ Session Management (PR #9903) - ✅ Settings and Configuration (PR #9903) - ✅ Theming and UI (PR #9903) - ✅ TuiMaterializer Integration (PR #9903) - ✅ TUI Component Interfaces (PR #10451) #### Architectural Clarifications **Covered by PRs:** - ✅ Layer Boundary DI Exception (PR #10451) - ✅ ULID Scope Clarification (PR #10451) - ✅ A2A Boundary Enforcement (PR #10052) - ✅ ADR-049 Documentation (PR #10009, #10052) ### Monitoring Plan **Cycle 1 (Current):** 1. ✅ Identified all specification PRs 2. ✅ Created proposal issue (#10533) 3. ✅ Analyzed coverage and gaps 4. ✅ Created tracking issue (#10526) 5. ⏳ Monitor PR #10009 for human feedback 6. ⏳ Monitor PR #10451 for human feedback 7. ⏳ Monitor PR #10052 for human feedback 8. ⏳ Monitor PR #9903 for CI resolution **Next Cycle (15 minutes):** 1. Check for human feedback on "Needs Feedback" PRs 2. Monitor CI status of PR #9903 3. Check for any new specification-related PRs 4. Identify any remaining gaps 5. Create additional proposal issues if needed ### Key Metrics - **Total Specification PRs:** 5 - **Awaiting Feedback:** 3 (PR #10009, #10052, #10451) - **In Review with Issues:** 1 (PR #9903) - **Minor Clarifications:** 1 (PR #10026) - **Specification Coverage:** ~95% for v3.6.0 and v3.7.0 ### Next Steps 1. **Monitor PR #10009** - Awaiting human feedback on v3.6.0 section and ADR-049 2. **Monitor PR #10451** - Awaiting human feedback on architectural clarifications 3. **Monitor PR #10052** - Awaiting human feedback on A2A boundary enforcement 4. **Resolve PR #9903 Issues:** - Fix e2e_tests CI failure - Split documentation files to comply with 500-line limit - Add missing metadata (Closes #N, ISSUES CLOSED footer, CONTRIBUTORS.md) - Fix branch naming convention 5. **Merge approved PRs** in order of dependency 6. **Verify specification** matches implementation after merges --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Agent: automation-tracking-manager
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#10526
No description provided.