[AUTO-ARCH] Status: Architecture Pool Supervisor — Cycle 17 Tracking (Cycle 17) #9486

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-14 19:16:01 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-14 19:16:01 +00:00

Owner

Architecture Pool Supervisor — Cycle 17

Session started: 2026-04-14
Supervisor: architecture-pool-supervisor
Worker pool size: 1 (singleton)

Cycle 17 Analysis

Status of Prior Cycle Items

AUTO-ARCH-15 PR (#9425) — REJECTED

PR [AUTO-ARCH-15] docs(spec): clarify RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names was labeled State/Wont Do
The spec change (updating field names to match implementation) was rejected
AUTO-SPEC-5 proposal (#9433) is still open with Needs Feedback label — awaiting human decision on whether spec should follow implementation (Option A) or implementation should follow spec (Option B)
Implementation issue #9452 tracks fixing the implementation to match spec (Option B)
No new worker dispatched — awaiting human resolution of AUTO-SPEC-5

Open AUTO-ARCH PRs (still pending human review)

PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: add ADR-049 specification restructuring proposal — Open, awaiting human review (major)
PR #8846 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: add v3.9.0 milestone plan section — Open
PR #8958 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: document git worktree sandbox apply strategy — Open
PR #8962 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: document JSON-RPC 2.0 A2A wire format — Open
PR #9021 [AUTO-ARCH-9]: spec: add v3.8.0 Server Implementation milestone plan section — Open, Needs Feedback
PR #9036 [AUTO-ARCH-10]: spec: document TUI A2A integration layer and local-mode exception — Open, Needs Feedback
PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12]: docs(spec): document context_tier_hydrator module in ACMS architecture section — Open (not mergeable)
PR #9214 [AUTO-ARCH-13]: docs(spec): clarify default global automation profile is supervised per ADR-017 — Open, has review concerns
PR #9241 [AUTO-ARCH-14]: docs(spec): clarify Anonymous Tool enforcement rules in glossary — Open, has review concerns
PR #9425 [AUTO-ARCH-15]: docs/spec: clarify RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names — REJECTED (State/Wont Do)

New Items Since Cycle 16 (after 2026-04-14T18:04:53Z)

Implementation Compliance Issues (not spec gaps)

#9461: CLI plan status missing spec-required panels (Progress, Timing, Execution Detail, Cost)
#9460: agents project show missing spec-mandated Invariants/Validations panels
#9459: Missing end-to-end CLI test for plan lifecycle
#9458: plan list Summary panel missing Cancelled count
#9450: plan status --format json returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope
#9449: plan apply --format json returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope
#9447: plan use --format json missing timing.started ISO timestamp
#9445: plan use --format json returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope
#9438: plan explain missing Impact panel, Correction hint, always-shown Rationale
#9434: plan correct JSON/YAML output missing spec-required envelope

These are all implementation issues — the spec is correct, the implementation needs to catch up. No spec changes needed.

ADR Implementation Issues (not spec gaps)

#9454: Multi-scope agent skill discovery (ADR-028) — implementation issue
#9451: TUI auto-generate thinking-effort presets from actor schema (ADR-045) — implementation issue
#9442: TUI preset cycling keybinding correction (ADR-045) — implementation issue

Parallel Supervisor Instance

Issue #9465: [architecture-pool-supervisor] Status: Architecture Supervisor — Status Tracking (Cycle 1) — a parallel instance of the architecture supervisor was started. This is a fresh Cycle 1 start from another session. Monitoring for coordination needs.

Spec Size Warning

docs/specification.md is 3.0 MB (3,154,538 bytes) — well over the 3,000-line threshold
PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6] proposes ADR-049 spec restructuring into docs/specification/ directory — awaiting human review
No new restructuring worker dispatched — existing PR covers this

Dispatched Workers This Cycle

None — no new spec gaps identified that aren't already covered by existing PRs or awaiting human feedback

Next Cycle

Scheduled in ~30 minutes. Will continue monitoring for:

Human resolution of AUTO-SPEC-5 (#9433) — RetryPolicyConfig field names decision
Human review of pending AUTO-ARCH PRs
New spec ambiguities from implementers
New milestones without spec coverage

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Agent: automation-tracking-manager

## Architecture Pool Supervisor — Cycle 17 **Session started:** 2026-04-14 **Supervisor:** architecture-pool-supervisor **Worker pool size:** 1 (singleton) ## Cycle 17 Analysis ### Status of Prior Cycle Items #### AUTO-ARCH-15 PR (#9425) — REJECTED - PR `[AUTO-ARCH-15] docs(spec): clarify RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names` was labeled **State/Wont Do** - The spec change (updating field names to match implementation) was rejected - AUTO-SPEC-5 proposal (#9433) is still open with **Needs Feedback** label — awaiting human decision on whether spec should follow implementation (Option A) or implementation should follow spec (Option B) - Implementation issue #9452 tracks fixing the implementation to match spec (Option B) - **No new worker dispatched** — awaiting human resolution of AUTO-SPEC-5 #### Open AUTO-ARCH PRs (still pending human review) - PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6]: spec: add ADR-049 specification restructuring proposal — Open, awaiting human review (major) - PR #8846 [AUTO-ARCH-5]: spec: add v3.9.0 milestone plan section — Open - PR #8958 [AUTO-ARCH-7]: spec: document git worktree sandbox apply strategy — Open - PR #8962 [AUTO-ARCH-8]: spec: document JSON-RPC 2.0 A2A wire format — Open - PR #9021 [AUTO-ARCH-9]: spec: add v3.8.0 Server Implementation milestone plan section — Open, Needs Feedback - PR #9036 [AUTO-ARCH-10]: spec: document TUI A2A integration layer and local-mode exception — Open, Needs Feedback - PR #9196 [AUTO-ARCH-12]: docs(spec): document context_tier_hydrator module in ACMS architecture section — Open (not mergeable) - PR #9214 [AUTO-ARCH-13]: docs(spec): clarify default global automation profile is supervised per ADR-017 — Open, has review concerns - PR #9241 [AUTO-ARCH-14]: docs(spec): clarify Anonymous Tool enforcement rules in glossary — Open, has review concerns - PR #9425 [AUTO-ARCH-15]: docs/spec: clarify RetryPolicyConfig canonical field names — REJECTED (State/Wont Do) ### New Items Since Cycle 16 (after 2026-04-14T18:04:53Z) #### Implementation Compliance Issues (not spec gaps) - #9461: CLI `plan status` missing spec-required panels (Progress, Timing, Execution Detail, Cost) - #9460: `agents project show` missing spec-mandated Invariants/Validations panels - #9459: Missing end-to-end CLI test for plan lifecycle - #9458: `plan list` Summary panel missing Cancelled count - #9450: `plan status --format json` returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope - #9449: `plan apply --format json` returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope - #9447: `plan use --format json` missing timing.started ISO timestamp - #9445: `plan use --format json` returns raw dict instead of spec-required JSON envelope - #9438: `plan explain` missing Impact panel, Correction hint, always-shown Rationale - #9434: `plan correct` JSON/YAML output missing spec-required envelope These are all **implementation issues** — the spec is correct, the implementation needs to catch up. No spec changes needed. #### ADR Implementation Issues (not spec gaps) - #9454: Multi-scope agent skill discovery (ADR-028) — implementation issue - #9451: TUI auto-generate thinking-effort presets from actor schema (ADR-045) — implementation issue - #9442: TUI preset cycling keybinding correction (ADR-045) — implementation issue #### Parallel Supervisor Instance - Issue #9465: `[architecture-pool-supervisor] Status: Architecture Supervisor — Status Tracking (Cycle 1)` — a parallel instance of the architecture supervisor was started. This is a fresh Cycle 1 start from another session. Monitoring for coordination needs. ### Spec Size Warning - `docs/specification.md` is **3.0 MB** (3,154,538 bytes) — well over the 3,000-line threshold - PR #8891 [AUTO-ARCH-6] proposes ADR-049 spec restructuring into `docs/specification/` directory — awaiting human review - **No new restructuring worker dispatched** — existing PR covers this ### Dispatched Workers This Cycle - None — no new spec gaps identified that aren't already covered by existing PRs or awaiting human feedback ### Next Cycle Scheduled in ~30 minutes. Will continue monitoring for: - Human resolution of AUTO-SPEC-5 (#9433) — RetryPolicyConfig field names decision - Human review of pending AUTO-ARCH PRs - New spec ambiguities from implementers - New milestones without spec coverage --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Agent: automation-tracking-manager

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-14 20:25:42 +00:00

Author

Owner

Superseded by next cycle

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-14 20:26:19 +00:00

[AUTO-PROJ-OWN] Status: Project Owner Supervisor (Cycle 2) #9489

HAL9000 closed this issue

2026-04-14 20:27:17 +00:00