[AUTO-SPEC] Status: Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking (Cycle 4) #8622

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-13 21:22:35 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 21:22:35 +00:00

Owner

[AUTO-SPEC] Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking

Session Tag: [AUTO-SPEC]
Started: 2026-04-13
Model: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-6
Cycle Interval: 15 minutes
Worker Pool: Up to 8 workers (spec-update-worker)

Current State

Master SHA: c5afe1f3a7c2cb4a25efd5016788b12029c1edea
Last checked: 2026-04-13 ~21:20 UTC
SHA change from Cycle 3: None (2nd idle cycle)

Open Spec PRs Being Monitored

PR	Title	Status	Notes
#8276	docs(spec): clarify sandbox path containment, datetime comparison, and plugin validation contracts	Open — REQUEST_CHANGES	⚠️ DUPLICATE: Content already merged via PR #7362. Notified. Awaiting closure.
#8437	docs(adr): add ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy	Open — REQUEST_CHANGES	AUTO-ARCH-5 claims fixes applied. Stale reviews. Reminder posted. Awaiting human re-review.
#8578	spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0)	Open — No reviews	NEW: Fills spec gap for TuiMaterializer. Has `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted.
#8579	spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0)	Open — No reviews	NEW: Adds Decision Recording System spec. Missing `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted.
#8581	spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy	Open — No reviews	NEW: Adds five-layer architecture policy. Has `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted. ⚠️ Inconsistency with existing four-layer description at line 43177.

Cycle 4 Summary (2nd Idle Cycle — No New Merges)

New commits: None (master SHA unchanged)

New spec PRs detected: 3

PR #8578: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) — fills genuine spec gap
PR #8579: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) — adds implementation detail
PR #8581: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy — major spec addition, five-layer model

Actions taken:

✅ Confirmed master SHA unchanged
✅ Reviewed PR #8578 — consistent with existing TUI spec, fills spec gap
✅ Reviewed PR #8579 — consistent with existing spec, minor ULID/UUID inconsistency noted
✅ Reviewed PR #8581 — technically sound, but introduces five-layer model inconsistent with existing four-layer description at line 43177
✅ Proactive spec-vs-code comparison: plan correct, invariant add/list/remove — all consistent with spec
✅ No new spec divergences detected in implementation

Key Finding — PR #8581:
The existing spec (line 43177) says "four primary layers — Presentation, Application, Domain, and Infrastructure" with CLI and TUI both in Presentation. PR #8581 introduces a five-layer model where TUI is separate from CLI. This is architecturally sound but creates an inconsistency. The PR author should update line 43177 before merge.

Pending Proposals

None currently open.

Known Implementation Deviations (Tracked Separately)

Issue	Description	Status
#5855	`agents actor add` requires undocumented positional NAME argument	Open — implementation bug
#5869	`agents actor add --config` uses v2 parser instead of v3 ActorConfigSchema	Open — implementation bug
#8570	CLI→Infrastructure violation in `actor.py` (`_get_services` calls `get_container()`)	Open — implementation bug

Next Cycle Actions

Check if master SHA has advanced
Monitor PRs #8578, #8579, #8581 for human review
Monitor PR #8437 for human re-review
Monitor PR #8276 for closure (duplicate)
Continue proactive spec-vs-code comparison (sandbox, checkpoint modules)

Activity Log

Cycle	Time	Action	Result
1	2026-04-13 20:10 UTC	Startup, PR review, commit analysis	No new divergences; reviews posted on #8276 and #8437
2	2026-04-13 20:35 UTC	SHA advance detected, duplicate PR identified	No new divergences; PR #8276 notified of duplicate status
3	2026-04-13 20:55 UTC	Idle cycle, proactive spec-vs-code comparison	No new divergences; context/automation-profile/actor modules checked
4	2026-04-13 21:20 UTC	Idle cycle, 3 new spec PRs detected and reviewed	Reviews posted on #8578, #8579, #8581; inconsistency in #8581 noted

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor

## [AUTO-SPEC] Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking **Session Tag**: `[AUTO-SPEC]` **Started**: 2026-04-13 **Model**: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-6 **Cycle Interval**: 15 minutes **Worker Pool**: Up to 8 workers (spec-update-worker) --- ## Current State **Master SHA**: `c5afe1f3a7c2cb4a25efd5016788b12029c1edea` **Last checked**: 2026-04-13 ~21:20 UTC **SHA change from Cycle 3**: None (2nd idle cycle) --- ## Open Spec PRs Being Monitored | PR | Title | Status | Notes | |----|-------|--------|-------| | #8276 | docs(spec): clarify sandbox path containment, datetime comparison, and plugin validation contracts | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | ⚠️ DUPLICATE: Content already merged via PR #7362. Notified. Awaiting closure. | | #8437 | docs(adr): add ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | AUTO-ARCH-5 claims fixes applied. Stale reviews. Reminder posted. Awaiting human re-review. | | #8578 | spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) | Open — No reviews | NEW: Fills spec gap for TuiMaterializer. Has `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted. | | #8579 | spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) | Open — No reviews | NEW: Adds Decision Recording System spec. Missing `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted. | | #8581 | spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy | Open — No reviews | NEW: Adds five-layer architecture policy. Has `Needs Feedback` label. Review posted. ⚠️ Inconsistency with existing four-layer description at line 43177. | --- ## Cycle 4 Summary (2nd Idle Cycle — No New Merges) **New commits**: None (master SHA unchanged) **New spec PRs detected**: 3 - PR #8578: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) — fills genuine spec gap - PR #8579: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) — adds implementation detail - PR #8581: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy — major spec addition, five-layer model **Actions taken**: 1. ✅ Confirmed master SHA unchanged 2. ✅ Reviewed PR #8578 — consistent with existing TUI spec, fills spec gap 3. ✅ Reviewed PR #8579 — consistent with existing spec, minor ULID/UUID inconsistency noted 4. ✅ Reviewed PR #8581 — technically sound, but introduces five-layer model inconsistent with existing four-layer description at line 43177 5. ✅ Proactive spec-vs-code comparison: plan correct, invariant add/list/remove — all consistent with spec 6. ✅ No new spec divergences detected in implementation **Key Finding — PR #8581**: The existing spec (line 43177) says "four primary layers — Presentation, Application, Domain, and Infrastructure" with CLI and TUI both in Presentation. PR #8581 introduces a five-layer model where TUI is separate from CLI. This is architecturally sound but creates an inconsistency. The PR author should update line 43177 before merge. --- ## Pending Proposals None currently open. --- ## Known Implementation Deviations (Tracked Separately) | Issue | Description | Status | |-------|-------------|--------| | #5855 | `agents actor add` requires undocumented positional NAME argument | Open — implementation bug | | #5869 | `agents actor add --config` uses v2 parser instead of v3 ActorConfigSchema | Open — implementation bug | | #8570 | CLI→Infrastructure violation in `actor.py` (`_get_services` calls `get_container()`) | Open — implementation bug | --- ## Next Cycle Actions - Check if master SHA has advanced - Monitor PRs #8578, #8579, #8581 for human review - Monitor PR #8437 for human re-review - Monitor PR #8276 for closure (duplicate) - Continue proactive spec-vs-code comparison (sandbox, checkpoint modules) --- ## Activity Log | Cycle | Time | Action | Result | |-------|------|--------|--------| | 1 | 2026-04-13 20:10 UTC | Startup, PR review, commit analysis | No new divergences; reviews posted on #8276 and #8437 | | 2 | 2026-04-13 20:35 UTC | SHA advance detected, duplicate PR identified | No new divergences; PR #8276 notified of duplicate status | | 3 | 2026-04-13 20:55 UTC | Idle cycle, proactive spec-vs-code comparison | No new divergences; context/automation-profile/actor modules checked | | 4 | 2026-04-13 21:20 UTC | Idle cycle, 3 new spec PRs detected and reviewed | Reviews posted on #8578, #8579, #8581; inconsistency in #8581 noted | --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 added the

Automation Tracking

label

2026-04-13 21:23:24 +00:00

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-13 21:24:30 +00:00

[AUTO-OWNR] Status: Project Owner Pool Supervisor (Cycle 5) #8624

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 21:44:31 +00:00

Author

Owner

Superseded by next cycle