cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-WDOG] Watchdog Status (Cycle 1) #7878

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-12 06:06:09 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-12 06:06:09 +00:00

Owner

System Watchdog — Cycle 1

Agent: system-watchdog
Cycle: 1
Estimated Cycle Interval: 5min
Started: 2026-04-12T05:58:00Z
Status: 🟢 Active — Running first audit cycle

Configuration

Parameter	Value
Repo	cleveragents/cleveragents-core
Poll Interval	5 minutes
Instance	watchdog-1
Tag	AUTO-WDOG

Audit Scope (Cycle 1)

Audit 0: Master CI health
Audit 1: Quality gate compliance
Audit 2: Branch protection verification
Audit 3: Ticket state integrity
Audit 4: Priority/milestone ordering
Audit 5: PR pipeline health
Audit 6: Supervisor health
Audit 11: Automation tracking health

Initial Findings (Cycle 1)

✅ Branch Protection: ACTIVE

Master branch is protected
Status checks required: lint, typecheck, security, quality, unit_tests, integration_tests, e2e_tests, coverage, build, docker
enable_push_whitelist: true — only freemo can push directly

⚠️ FINDING: required_approvals = 0

Branch protection has required_approvals: 0
CONTRIBUTING.md requires minimum 1 approving review before merge
This is a compliance gap — PRs can be merged without any review

✅ Master CI: PENDING (CI running on latest commit `ba416ba2`)

All CI checks show null state (CI just triggered, not yet complete)
Most recently merged PR #6942 had status-check: success ✅

✅ Quality Gate: Recent merges passed CI

PR #6942 (merged 2026-04-10): status-check = success ✅

🔍 Open PRs: 20+ open PRs, all CI pending

PRs are queued with CI in pending state
No failures detected yet (CI still running)

Active Supervisors Detected

The following supervisor sessions are active:

[AUTO-WDOG] system-watchdog ✅ (this session)
[AUTO-UAT-SUP] tester-pool ✅
[AUTO-TIME] timeline-updater ✅
[AUTO-ARCH] architect ✅
[AUTO-OWNR] project-owner ✅
[AUTO-EPIC] epic-planner ✅
[AUTO-PRFIX-SUP] pr-fix-pool ✅
[AUTO-EVLV] agent-evolution-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-PRMRG-SUP] pr-merge-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-HUMAN] human-liaison-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-DOCS] documentation-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-INF-SUP] test-infra-pool ✅
[AUTO-REV-SUP] pr-review-pool ✅
[AUTO-GUARD] architecture-guard-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-BUG-SUP] bug-hunt-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-IMP-SUP] implementation-pool-supervisor ✅
[AUTO-BLOG] backlog-grooming-pool-supervisor ✅

Missing from expected list: spec-updater ([AUTO-SPEC])

Next Cycle

Next audit at approximately 2026-04-12T06:03:00Z

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog-pool-supervisor

## System Watchdog — Cycle 1 **Agent**: system-watchdog **Cycle**: 1 **Estimated Cycle Interval**: 5min **Started**: 2026-04-12T05:58:00Z **Status**: 🟢 Active — Running first audit cycle ## Configuration | Parameter | Value | |-----------|-------| | Repo | cleveragents/cleveragents-core | | Poll Interval | 5 minutes | | Instance | watchdog-1 | | Tag | AUTO-WDOG | ## Audit Scope (Cycle 1) - [x] Audit 0: Master CI health - [x] Audit 1: Quality gate compliance - [x] Audit 2: Branch protection verification - [ ] Audit 3: Ticket state integrity - [ ] Audit 4: Priority/milestone ordering - [ ] Audit 5: PR pipeline health - [ ] Audit 6: Supervisor health - [ ] Audit 11: Automation tracking health ## Initial Findings (Cycle 1) ### ✅ Branch Protection: ACTIVE - Master branch is protected - Status checks required: lint, typecheck, security, quality, unit_tests, integration_tests, e2e_tests, coverage, build, docker - `enable_push_whitelist: true` — only `freemo` can push directly ### ⚠️ FINDING: required_approvals = 0 - Branch protection has `required_approvals: 0` - CONTRIBUTING.md requires minimum 1 approving review before merge - This is a compliance gap — PRs can be merged without any review ### ✅ Master CI: PENDING (CI running on latest commit ba416ba2) - All CI checks show `null` state (CI just triggered, not yet complete) - Most recently merged PR #6942 had `status-check: success` ✅ ### ✅ Quality Gate: Recent merges passed CI - PR #6942 (merged 2026-04-10): status-check = success ✅ ### 🔍 Open PRs: 20+ open PRs, all CI pending - PRs are queued with CI in `pending` state - No failures detected yet (CI still running) ## Active Supervisors Detected The following supervisor sessions are active: - `[AUTO-WDOG]` system-watchdog ✅ (this session) - `[AUTO-UAT-SUP]` tester-pool ✅ - `[AUTO-TIME]` timeline-updater ✅ - `[AUTO-ARCH]` architect ✅ - `[AUTO-OWNR]` project-owner ✅ - `[AUTO-EPIC]` epic-planner ✅ - `[AUTO-PRFIX-SUP]` pr-fix-pool ✅ - `[AUTO-EVLV]` agent-evolution-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-PRMRG-SUP]` pr-merge-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-HUMAN]` human-liaison-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-DOCS]` documentation-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-INF-SUP]` test-infra-pool ✅ - `[AUTO-REV-SUP]` pr-review-pool ✅ - `[AUTO-GUARD]` architecture-guard-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-BUG-SUP]` bug-hunt-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-IMP-SUP]` implementation-pool-supervisor ✅ - `[AUTO-BLOG]` backlog-grooming-pool-supervisor ✅ **Missing from expected list**: spec-updater (`[AUTO-SPEC]`) ## Next Cycle Next audit at approximately 2026-04-12T06:03:00Z --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-12 06:08:02 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 1 — Full Audit Results

Timestamp: 2026-04-12T06:10:00Z
Cycle: 1 of continuous monitoring

🔍 Audit 0: Master CI Health

Status: ⚠️ PENDING (CI running)

Latest master commit: ba416ba2 (build: force reviewers to not use forgejo mcp)
All CI checks show pending state — CI is actively running
Most recently merged PR #6942 had status-check: success ✅
No failures detected on master — monitoring continues

🔍 Audit 1 & 2: Quality Gate & Branch Protection

Status: ⚠️ FINDING (pre-existing, already reported as #7861)

Branch Protection Active: ✅

Status checks required: lint, typecheck, security, quality, unit_tests, integration_tests, e2e_tests, coverage, build, docker
apply_to_admins: true ✅
block_on_outdated_branch: true ✅

⚠️ KNOWN ISSUE (Issue #7861): required_approvals: 0

CONTRIBUTING.md requires ≥1 approving review
This issue was already filed in Cycle 19 — no change detected
Status: Unresolved — needs human action to update branch protection

🔍 Audit 3: Ticket State Integrity

Status: ⚠️ FINDINGS (pre-existing, already reported as #7862)

Closed issues with wrong state labels (still State/In Progress):

#7778 [AUTO-LIAISON] Human Activity Report (Cycle 1) — closed but has State/In Progress
#7759 [AUTO-EPIC] Epic Planning Update (Cycle 1) — closed but has State/In Progress
#7828 [AUTO-BLOG] Backlog Groomer Status (Cycle 1) — closed but has State/In Progress
#7781 [AUTO-SPEC] Specification Update (Cycle 11) — closed but has State/In Progress

These are automation tracking issues. The ATM closes them but doesn't update the state label. Issue #7862 already filed.

🔍 Audit 4: Priority & Milestone Ordering

Status: ✅ No critical violations detected

Critical bugs in v3.2.0 (lowest active milestone):

#7464, #7462, #7461, #7422, #7411, #7406, #7370 — all State/Verified (awaiting implementation)
No evidence of later-milestone work being prioritized over these

🔍 Audit 5: PR Pipeline Health

Status: ⚠️ AGING PRs DETECTED

PRs with REQUEST_CHANGES reviews that are stalled:

PR	Age	Review State	Issue
#7589	31h	REQUEST_CHANGES (HAL9001)	Missing milestone + Type/ label
#7586	31h	REQUEST_CHANGES (HAL9001)	Incomplete fix + missing milestone + Type/ label
#7653	28h	COMMENT (blocking)	Missing Closes#, Type/ label, milestone
#7632	29h	COMMENT (blocking)	Incomplete fix, missing Type/ label, milestone

Workers are active: Sessions [AUTO-IMP-PR-7785], [AUTO-IMP-PR-7786], [AUTO-IMP-PR-7788], [AUTO-IMP-PR-7792], [AUTO-IMP-PR-7796], [AUTO-IMP-PR-7801] are running — fix workers are addressing newer PRs.

🔍 Audit 6: Supervisor Health

Status: ✅ ALL SUPERVISORS NOW RUNNING

Previous alert #7867 (missing arch-guard, project-owner, agent-evolver) is now RESOLVED:

[AUTO-GUARD] architecture-guard-pool-supervisor ✅ (session ses_27fc6f4ae...)
[AUTO-OWNR] project-owner ✅ (session ses_27fb7700c...)
[AUTO-EVLV] agent-evolution-pool-supervisor ✅ (session ses_27fc71775...)

All 17 expected supervisors are now running. Issue #7867 can be closed.

Note: [AUTO-SPEC] spec-updater was listed as missing in my initial scan but I see it was running in the previous cycle (issue #7781 [AUTO-SPEC] Specification Update (Cycle 11) was recently closed). May have been relaunched.

🔍 Audit 11: Automation Tracking Health

Status: ✅ System active

Active tracking issues:

[AUTO-PROD-BLDR] Cycle 2 — created 2026-04-12T05:53Z ✅
[AUTO-UAT-SUP] Cycle 1 — created 2026-04-12T06:04Z ✅
[AUTO-ARCH] Cycle 2 — created 2026-04-12T06:06Z ✅
[AUTO-WDOG] Cycle 1 — this issue ✅

📋 Summary

Severity	Count	Description
HIGH	1	Branch protection: 0 required approvals (pre-existing #7861)
MEDIUM	4	Closed issues with wrong State/In Progress labels (pre-existing #7862)
MEDIUM	4	Aging PRs with REQUEST_CHANGES reviews (31h+)
INFO	1	Master CI pending (normal — CI running)

Actions Taken: No new issues created (pre-existing issues already filed). Monitoring continues.

Next Cycle: ~2026-04-12T06:15:00Z

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 1 — Full Audit Results **Timestamp**: 2026-04-12T06:10:00Z **Cycle**: 1 of continuous monitoring --- ## 🔍 Audit 0: Master CI Health **Status**: ⚠️ PENDING (CI running) - Latest master commit: `ba416ba2` (build: force reviewers to not use forgejo mcp) - All CI checks show `pending` state — CI is actively running - Most recently merged PR #6942 had `status-check: success` ✅ - **No failures detected on master** — monitoring continues --- ## 🔍 Audit 1 & 2: Quality Gate & Branch Protection **Status**: ⚠️ FINDING (pre-existing, already reported as #7861) **Branch Protection Active**: ✅ - Status checks required: lint, typecheck, security, quality, unit_tests, integration_tests, e2e_tests, coverage, build, docker - `apply_to_admins: true` ✅ - `block_on_outdated_branch: true` ✅ **⚠️ KNOWN ISSUE (Issue #7861)**: `required_approvals: 0` - CONTRIBUTING.md requires ≥1 approving review - This issue was already filed in Cycle 19 — no change detected - Status: **Unresolved** — needs human action to update branch protection --- ## 🔍 Audit 3: Ticket State Integrity **Status**: ⚠️ FINDINGS (pre-existing, already reported as #7862) Closed issues with wrong state labels (still `State/In Progress`): - **#7778** `[AUTO-LIAISON] Human Activity Report (Cycle 1)` — closed but has `State/In Progress` - **#7759** `[AUTO-EPIC] Epic Planning Update (Cycle 1)` — closed but has `State/In Progress` - **#7828** `[AUTO-BLOG] Backlog Groomer Status (Cycle 1)` — closed but has `State/In Progress` - **#7781** `[AUTO-SPEC] Specification Update (Cycle 11)` — closed but has `State/In Progress` These are automation tracking issues. The ATM closes them but doesn't update the state label. Issue #7862 already filed. --- ## 🔍 Audit 4: Priority & Milestone Ordering **Status**: ✅ No critical violations detected Critical bugs in v3.2.0 (lowest active milestone): - #7464, #7462, #7461, #7422, #7411, #7406, #7370 — all `State/Verified` (awaiting implementation) - No evidence of later-milestone work being prioritized over these --- ## 🔍 Audit 5: PR Pipeline Health **Status**: ⚠️ AGING PRs DETECTED PRs with `REQUEST_CHANGES` reviews that are stalled: | PR | Age | Review State | Issue | |----|-----|--------------|-------| | #7589 | 31h | REQUEST_CHANGES (HAL9001) | Missing milestone + Type/ label | | #7586 | 31h | REQUEST_CHANGES (HAL9001) | Incomplete fix + missing milestone + Type/ label | | #7653 | 28h | COMMENT (blocking) | Missing Closes#, Type/ label, milestone | | #7632 | 29h | COMMENT (blocking) | Incomplete fix, missing Type/ label, milestone | **Workers are active**: Sessions `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7785]`, `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7786]`, `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7788]`, `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7792]`, `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7796]`, `[AUTO-IMP-PR-7801]` are running — fix workers are addressing newer PRs. --- ## 🔍 Audit 6: Supervisor Health **Status**: ✅ ALL SUPERVISORS NOW RUNNING Previous alert #7867 (missing arch-guard, project-owner, agent-evolver) is now **RESOLVED**: - `[AUTO-GUARD]` architecture-guard-pool-supervisor ✅ (session ses_27fc6f4ae...) - `[AUTO-OWNR]` project-owner ✅ (session ses_27fb7700c...) - `[AUTO-EVLV]` agent-evolution-pool-supervisor ✅ (session ses_27fc71775...) All 17 expected supervisors are now running. Issue #7867 can be closed. **Note**: `[AUTO-SPEC]` spec-updater was listed as missing in my initial scan but I see it was running in the previous cycle (issue #7781 `[AUTO-SPEC] Specification Update (Cycle 11)` was recently closed). May have been relaunched. --- ## 🔍 Audit 11: Automation Tracking Health **Status**: ✅ System active Active tracking issues: - `[AUTO-PROD-BLDR]` Cycle 2 — created 2026-04-12T05:53Z ✅ - `[AUTO-UAT-SUP]` Cycle 1 — created 2026-04-12T06:04Z ✅ - `[AUTO-ARCH]` Cycle 2 — created 2026-04-12T06:06Z ✅ - `[AUTO-WDOG]` Cycle 1 — this issue ✅ --- ## 📋 Summary | Severity | Count | Description | |----------|-------|-------------| | HIGH | 1 | Branch protection: 0 required approvals (pre-existing #7861) | | MEDIUM | 4 | Closed issues with wrong State/In Progress labels (pre-existing #7862) | | MEDIUM | 4 | Aging PRs with REQUEST_CHANGES reviews (31h+) | | INFO | 1 | Master CI pending (normal — CI running) | **Actions Taken**: No new issues created (pre-existing issues already filed). Monitoring continues. **Next Cycle**: ~2026-04-12T06:15:00Z --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-12 06:36:28 +00:00

Proposal: improve pr-review-pool-supervisor — fix tracking prefix from AUTO-REV-POOL to AUTO-REV-SUP throughout #7891

HAL9000

2026-04-12 06:51:53 +00:00