[AUTO-SPEC] Specification Update (Cycle 1) #6196

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 17:35:54 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 17:35:54 +00:00

Owner

Specification Update — Cycle 1

Agent: spec-updater
Cycle: 1
Date: 2026-04-09 17:35 UTC
Master SHA: 64b72307d3ef2ffc37a664453f4dc454d75d7941
Status: Active — Awaiting Human Approval on Proposals

Summary

Initial scan of the specification against the implementation. Analyzed recently merged PRs and source code to identify discrepancies between docs/specification.md and the implementation.

Spec Proposals Created (Awaiting Human Approval)

Issue	Title	Milestone	Triggered By
#6192	GitWorktreeSandbox implementation and merge-based apply	v3.4.0	PR #5998
#6193	`agents validation attach` uses `--key value` format	v3.2.0	PR #3837
#6194	ACMS built-in strategy real retrieval algorithms	v3.4.0	PRs #3635, #3682
#6195	Restructure monolithic spec (47k lines) into `docs/specification/`	—	Proactive scan

Proposals Approved This Cycle

None (first cycle — all proposals are new).

Proposals Rejected This Cycle

None.

PRs Created This Cycle

None (awaiting human approval on proposals).

Issues Created for Incorrect Deviations

None identified. All discrepancies found are cases where the implementation is better than the spec (concrete implementations of abstract designs), not incorrect deviations.

Specification Alignment Status

Area	Status	Notes
Sandbox / Execute / Apply	⚠️ Needs update	GitWorktreeSandbox not documented in spec
Validation CLI	⚠️ Needs update	`--key value` format not explicitly documented
ACMS Context Strategies	⚠️ Needs update	Real retrieval algorithms not documented
Spec Structure	⚠️ Needs restructure	47,039 lines — 15× over threshold
CLI Commands	✅ Aligned	No discrepancies found
Core Concepts	✅ Aligned	No discrepancies found
Architecture	✅ Aligned	No discrepancies found

Monolithic/Split Status

docs/specification.md is a single monolithic file at 47,039 lines (~3.1 MB). Proposal #6195 proposes splitting it into docs/specification/ directory. Awaiting human approval.

Recently Merged PRs Analyzed

PR	Title	Spec Impact
#5998	feat(plan): git worktree sandbox	Proposal #6192 created
#5614	docs: invariant-reconciliation module guide	Already documented in reference docs
#4219	fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline	No spec change needed (internal wiring)
#4197	fix(plan): upsert action arguments	No spec change needed (bug fix)
#3837	fix(cli): validation attach --key value	Proposal #6193 created
#3682	docs: ACMS real retrieval logic	Proposal #6194 created (spec not yet updated)
#3676	fix(acms): SkeletonCompressor	No spec change needed (bug fix)
#3657	docs: session export panels	Already documented in reference docs
#3635	fix(acms): real retrieval logic	Proposal #6194 created

Next Actions

Monitor proposals #6192, #6193, #6194, #6195 for human approval
Continue polling for new merged PRs every 15 minutes
Perform proactive scan every 5th idle cycle (~75 minutes)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-updater

# Specification Update — Cycle 1 **Agent**: spec-updater **Cycle**: 1 **Date**: 2026-04-09 17:35 UTC **Master SHA**: `64b72307d3ef2ffc37a664453f4dc454d75d7941` **Status**: Active — Awaiting Human Approval on Proposals ## Summary Initial scan of the specification against the implementation. Analyzed recently merged PRs and source code to identify discrepancies between `docs/specification.md` and the implementation. ## Spec Proposals Created (Awaiting Human Approval) | Issue | Title | Milestone | Triggered By | |-------|-------|-----------|--------------| | #6192 | GitWorktreeSandbox implementation and merge-based apply | v3.4.0 | PR #5998 | | #6193 | `agents validation attach` uses `--key value` format | v3.2.0 | PR #3837 | | #6194 | ACMS built-in strategy real retrieval algorithms | v3.4.0 | PRs #3635, #3682 | | #6195 | Restructure monolithic spec (47k lines) into `docs/specification/` | — | Proactive scan | ## Proposals Approved This Cycle None (first cycle — all proposals are new). ## Proposals Rejected This Cycle None. ## PRs Created This Cycle None (awaiting human approval on proposals). ## Issues Created for Incorrect Deviations None identified. All discrepancies found are cases where the implementation is **better than the spec** (concrete implementations of abstract designs), not incorrect deviations. ## Specification Alignment Status | Area | Status | Notes | |------|--------|-------| | Sandbox / Execute / Apply | ⚠️ Needs update | GitWorktreeSandbox not documented in spec | | Validation CLI | ⚠️ Needs update | `--key value` format not explicitly documented | | ACMS Context Strategies | ⚠️ Needs update | Real retrieval algorithms not documented | | Spec Structure | ⚠️ Needs restructure | 47,039 lines — 15× over threshold | | CLI Commands | ✅ Aligned | No discrepancies found | | Core Concepts | ✅ Aligned | No discrepancies found | | Architecture | ✅ Aligned | No discrepancies found | ## Monolithic/Split Status `docs/specification.md` is a **single monolithic file** at 47,039 lines (~3.1 MB). Proposal #6195 proposes splitting it into `docs/specification/` directory. **Awaiting human approval.** ## Recently Merged PRs Analyzed | PR | Title | Spec Impact | |----|-------|-------------| | #5998 | feat(plan): git worktree sandbox | Proposal #6192 created | | #5614 | docs: invariant-reconciliation module guide | Already documented in reference docs | | #4219 | fix(acms): wire ACMS indexing pipeline | No spec change needed (internal wiring) | | #4197 | fix(plan): upsert action arguments | No spec change needed (bug fix) | | #3837 | fix(cli): validation attach --key value | Proposal #6193 created | | #3682 | docs: ACMS real retrieval logic | Proposal #6194 created (spec not yet updated) | | #3676 | fix(acms): SkeletonCompressor | No spec change needed (bug fix) | | #3657 | docs: session export panels | Already documented in reference docs | | #3635 | fix(acms): real retrieval logic | Proposal #6194 created | ## Next Actions - Monitor proposals #6192, #6193, #6194, #6195 for human approval - Continue polling for new merged PRs every 15 minutes - Perform proactive scan every 5th idle cycle (~75 minutes) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-updater

HAL9000

2026-04-09 17:36:06 +00:00