UAT: No code review automation workflow examples exist — v3.6.0 "code review tool examples" deliverable unmet #5527

New issue

Open

opened 2026-04-09 07:13:25 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 07:13:25 +00:00

Owner

Bug Report

Feature Area: Code review tool examples — example workflows for code review automation

Severity: Backlog — the deliverable is missing but does not block core functionality

What Was Tested

Analyzed the examples/ directory, robot/review_playbook.robot, and robot/helper_review_playbook.py to verify the "code review tool examples" deliverable.

Expected Behavior (from spec)

The v3.6.0 milestone includes "Code review tool examples" as a deliverable. This should provide:

Example action YAML files demonstrating how to use CleverAgents for code review automation
Example workflows showing how to run plan use → execute → diff → apply for code review tasks
Practical examples that users can copy and adapt for their own code review workflows

Actual Behavior

What exists:

docs/development/review_playbook.md — A human process document describing how developers should conduct code reviews on the CleverAgents project itself. This is NOT a code review automation example.
robot/review_playbook.robot — Tests that verify the review playbook markdown file exists and has correct sections (P0:blocker, P1:must-fix, etc.). This tests the documentation, not code review automation.
examples/actions/ directory contains:
- estimation-actor.yaml
- inputs-schema.yaml
- invariant-heavy.yaml
- read-only.yaml
- simple.yaml
None of these are code review automation examples.

What is missing:

An example action YAML for code review automation (e.g., examples/actions/code-review.yaml)
An example workflow showing how to use CleverAgents to automate code review tasks
A showcase example demonstrating the plan use → execute → diff → apply workflow for code review

Code Location

examples/actions/ — no code review action example
docs/development/review_playbook.md — human process doc, not automation example
robot/review_playbook.robot — tests the doc, not automation

Impact

Users cannot find a working example of how to use CleverAgents for code review automation
The v3.6.0 "code review tool examples" deliverable is not met
The review_playbook.robot tests pass (they test the doc exists) but the actual deliverable (automation examples) is absent

Suggested Fix

Create examples/actions/code-review.yaml with a code review action that:

Uses an appropriate strategy actor for code analysis
Defines a definition_of_done for code review completion
Includes example invariants for code quality standards
Optionally includes a companion docs/showcase/cli-tools/code-review-workflow.md example

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

## Bug Report **Feature Area**: Code review tool examples — example workflows for code review automation **Severity**: Backlog — the deliverable is missing but does not block core functionality --- ## What Was Tested Analyzed the `examples/` directory, `robot/review_playbook.robot`, and `robot/helper_review_playbook.py` to verify the "code review tool examples" deliverable. ## Expected Behavior (from spec) The v3.6.0 milestone includes "Code review tool examples" as a deliverable. This should provide: - Example action YAML files demonstrating how to use CleverAgents for code review automation - Example workflows showing how to run `plan use → execute → diff → apply` for code review tasks - Practical examples that users can copy and adapt for their own code review workflows ## Actual Behavior ### What exists: 1. `docs/development/review_playbook.md` — A **human process document** describing how developers should conduct code reviews on the CleverAgents project itself. This is NOT a code review automation example. 2. `robot/review_playbook.robot` — Tests that verify the review playbook markdown file exists and has correct sections (P0:blocker, P1:must-fix, etc.). This tests the documentation, not code review automation. 3. `examples/actions/` directory contains: - `estimation-actor.yaml` - `inputs-schema.yaml` - `invariant-heavy.yaml` - `read-only.yaml` - `simple.yaml` **None of these are code review automation examples.** ### What is missing: - An example action YAML for code review automation (e.g., `examples/actions/code-review.yaml`) - An example workflow showing how to use CleverAgents to automate code review tasks - A showcase example demonstrating the `plan use → execute → diff → apply` workflow for code review ## Code Location - `examples/actions/` — no code review action example - `docs/development/review_playbook.md` — human process doc, not automation example - `robot/review_playbook.robot` — tests the doc, not automation ## Impact - Users cannot find a working example of how to use CleverAgents for code review automation - The v3.6.0 "code review tool examples" deliverable is not met - The `review_playbook.robot` tests pass (they test the doc exists) but the actual deliverable (automation examples) is absent ## Suggested Fix Create `examples/actions/code-review.yaml` with a code review action that: - Uses an appropriate strategy actor for code analysis - Defines a definition_of_done for code review completion - Includes example invariants for code quality standards - Optionally includes a companion `docs/showcase/cli-tools/code-review-workflow.md` example --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

HAL9000 added the

labels

2026-04-09 07:13:55 +00:00

HAL9000 referenced this issue