[AUTO-UAT-POOL] UAT Testing Report (Cycle 1) #5369

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 06:14:01 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 06:14:01 +00:00

Owner

UAT Testing Pool Status — Active (Cycles 1-2+)

Agent: uat-tester
Instance ID: uat-pool-1
Status: ACTIVE — Multiple cycles running
Max Workers: 8
Scope: Milestones v3.0.0 through v3.7.0
Last Updated: 2026-04-09
Master SHA: ee2024046f

Cumulative Results

Feature Areas Tested: 20+ | Total Bugs Filed: ~100+

Feature Area	Bugs	Critical	Issues
autonomy-hierarchical-decomposition	3	2	#5363, #5364, #5366
a2a-facade-event-queue-guards	1	1	#5360
invariant-management	3	0	#5355, #5357, #5359
acms-context-scaling	(prev cycle)	-	-
subplans-checkpoints	3	3	#5348, #5350, #5352
decision-recording-plan-tree	4	1	#5336, #5341, #5344, #5346
tui-implementation	8	5	#5321, #5329, #5331, #5334, #5338, #5340, #5343, #5345
plan-correction-modes	4	2	#5302, #5307, #5312, #5317, #5319
plan-lifecycle-core	7	3	#5414, #5416, #5418, #5421, #5424, #5426, #5430, #5433
actor-system-compilation	7	4	#5425, #5427, #5462, #5467, #5471, #5475, #5477, #5480
projects-resources	9	3	#5482, #5493, #5496, #5500, #5509, #5513, #5515, #5520, #5528, #5534, #5546
tool-router-mcp-adapter	9	4	#5428, #5441, #5450, #5454, #5458, #5461, #5466, #5469, #5474
database-migrations	8	1	#5417, #5431, #5435, #5438, #5443, #5447, #5451, #5456, #5460, #5468
cli-commands-validation	10	2	#5440, #5457, #5463, #5470, #5478, #5485, #5492, #5497, #5510, #5525
git-worktree-sandbox	6	3	#5444, #5452, #5459, #5465, #5473, #5479, #5483
validation-runner	4	2	#5523, #5540, #5543, #5545, #5549
context-assembly-pipeline	10	6	#5568, #5569, #5586, #5588, #5591, #5594, #5596, #5599, #5603, #5605
langgraph-integration	4	1	#5565, #5579, #5587, #5593, #5598
pydantic-domain-models	5	2	#5554, #5557, #5559, #5608, #5616
resource-types-virtual	8	2	#5615, #5622, #5625, #5628, #5631, #5632, #5634, #5635
security-safety-profiles	6	3	#5619, #5624, #5629, #5633, #5637, #5640, #5642, #5645

Currently Active Workers

Session ID	Feature Area	Status
ses_28ef44a6dffeyTuTx59ZDtZtj3	error-handling-edge-cases	Running
ses_28ee3a086ffe6peWawRSzxMspR	test-coverage-quality	Running
ses_28edadbd3ffe28qFlcqmceJZKs	lsp-code-review-tools	Running
ses_28ec863f4fferreNgBkRFqWxk5	plugin-architecture	Running
ses_28ec4b91effepGAjq3B2JJ8Tnm	uko-knowledge-ontology	Running
ses_28ec0e68fffeI4lnOeXLxUnc4R	llm-provider-backends	Running
ses_28eb8c857ffed2pzfh4fH1JVQs	session-management	Running
ses_28eb46bebffewKhyVOM7sekTBs	audit-logging-observability	Running

Key Findings Summary

Most Critical Issues Found

#5444 — plan apply does not call SandboxManager.commit_all() — sandbox changes NEVER merged to repo
#5619 — AutomationGuard constraints never enforced at runtime — all guards are dead code
#5598 — Custom LangGraph class uses RxPy instead of native StateGraph — all LangGraph features unavailable
#5605 — ContextAssemblyPipeline not wired to plan execution — actors use stub pipeline
#5363 — Test coverage at 84.42% (12.58% below 97% threshold)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

# UAT Testing Pool Status — Active (Cycles 1-2+) **Agent**: uat-tester **Instance ID**: uat-pool-1 **Status**: ACTIVE — Multiple cycles running **Max Workers**: 8 **Scope**: Milestones v3.0.0 through v3.7.0 **Last Updated**: 2026-04-09 **Master SHA**: ee2024046ff9f8734596160fc06b6eaf42516437 ## Cumulative Results **Feature Areas Tested: 20+ | Total Bugs Filed: ~100+** | Feature Area | Bugs | Critical | Issues | |---|---|---|---| | autonomy-hierarchical-decomposition | 3 | 2 | #5363, #5364, #5366 | | a2a-facade-event-queue-guards | 1 | 1 | #5360 | | invariant-management | 3 | 0 | #5355, #5357, #5359 | | acms-context-scaling | (prev cycle) | - | - | | subplans-checkpoints | 3 | 3 | #5348, #5350, #5352 | | decision-recording-plan-tree | 4 | 1 | #5336, #5341, #5344, #5346 | | tui-implementation | 8 | 5 | #5321, #5329, #5331, #5334, #5338, #5340, #5343, #5345 | | plan-correction-modes | 4 | 2 | #5302, #5307, #5312, #5317, #5319 | | plan-lifecycle-core | 7 | 3 | #5414, #5416, #5418, #5421, #5424, #5426, #5430, #5433 | | actor-system-compilation | 7 | 4 | #5425, #5427, #5462, #5467, #5471, #5475, #5477, #5480 | | projects-resources | 9 | 3 | #5482, #5493, #5496, #5500, #5509, #5513, #5515, #5520, #5528, #5534, #5546 | | tool-router-mcp-adapter | 9 | 4 | #5428, #5441, #5450, #5454, #5458, #5461, #5466, #5469, #5474 | | database-migrations | 8 | 1 | #5417, #5431, #5435, #5438, #5443, #5447, #5451, #5456, #5460, #5468 | | cli-commands-validation | 10 | 2 | #5440, #5457, #5463, #5470, #5478, #5485, #5492, #5497, #5510, #5525 | | git-worktree-sandbox | 6 | 3 | #5444, #5452, #5459, #5465, #5473, #5479, #5483 | | validation-runner | 4 | 2 | #5523, #5540, #5543, #5545, #5549 | | context-assembly-pipeline | 10 | 6 | #5568, #5569, #5586, #5588, #5591, #5594, #5596, #5599, #5603, #5605 | | langgraph-integration | 4 | 1 | #5565, #5579, #5587, #5593, #5598 | | pydantic-domain-models | 5 | 2 | #5554, #5557, #5559, #5608, #5616 | | resource-types-virtual | 8 | 2 | #5615, #5622, #5625, #5628, #5631, #5632, #5634, #5635 | | security-safety-profiles | 6 | 3 | #5619, #5624, #5629, #5633, #5637, #5640, #5642, #5645 | ## Currently Active Workers | Session ID | Feature Area | Status | |---|---|---| | ses_28ef44a6dffeyTuTx59ZDtZtj3 | error-handling-edge-cases | Running | | ses_28ee3a086ffe6peWawRSzxMspR | test-coverage-quality | Running | | ses_28edadbd3ffe28qFlcqmceJZKs | lsp-code-review-tools | Running | | ses_28ec863f4fferreNgBkRFqWxk5 | plugin-architecture | Running | | ses_28ec4b91effepGAjq3B2JJ8Tnm | uko-knowledge-ontology | Running | | ses_28ec0e68fffeI4lnOeXLxUnc4R | llm-provider-backends | Running | | ses_28eb8c857ffed2pzfh4fH1JVQs | session-management | Running | | ses_28eb46bebffewKhyVOM7sekTBs | audit-logging-observability | Running | ## Key Findings Summary ### Most Critical Issues Found 1. **#5444** — `plan apply` does not call `SandboxManager.commit_all()` — sandbox changes NEVER merged to repo 2. **#5619** — `AutomationGuard` constraints never enforced at runtime — all guards are dead code 3. **#5598** — Custom LangGraph class uses RxPy instead of native StateGraph — all LangGraph features unavailable 4. **#5605** — `ContextAssemblyPipeline` not wired to plan execution — actors use stub pipeline 5. **#5363** — Test coverage at 84.42% (12.58% below 97% threshold) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

Rows
Columns