[AUTO-WATCHDOG] System Health Report (Cycle 43) #5299

Closed
opened 2026-04-09 05:44:36 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 6 comments
Owner

System Watchdog Health Report — Cycle 43

Instance: watchdog-1 (new session, continuing from cycle 42)
Timestamp: 2026-04-09T05:44:00Z
Status: 🟡 MONITORING — Issues detected


🔴 CRITICAL Findings

1. Master CI Status — Pending/Unknown

  • Latest master commit: c87fc3bb ("fix: Scale implementation orchestrator to 32 parallel workers")
  • All CI status checks show null state — CI is currently running or results not yet reported
  • Previous alert issue #5284 documents integration_tests failure on prior commit b72b8275
  • Action: Monitoring CI completion; alert #5284 remains open

2. Branch Protection — ⚠️ Required Approvals = 0

  • Branch protection is active with status checks required
  • However: required_approvals: 0 — PRs can merge without any human review
  • CONTRIBUTING.md requires 2 approvals per PR
  • Severity: HIGH — This allows unreviewed code to reach master

🟡 HIGH Findings

3. PR Pipeline — Multiple Stale PRs Without Reviews

  • PR #4652 (11h old): docs: add module guides — has REQUEST_CHANGES from freemo — needs attention
  • PR #4663 (11h old): docs(timeline): Day 97 — no reviews found
  • PR #4757 (10h old): docs: v3.8.0 documentation updates — no reviews
  • PR #4805 (10h old): docs: architecture Milestone Plan — no reviews
  • PR #4830 (9h old): docs: document agent system improvements — no reviews
  • Total open PRs: 20+ — many docs PRs aging without review

4. Automation Tracking Issues Missing Labels

  • Issues #5290, #5291, #5295 have no labels (missing Type/Automation, State/In Progress, Priority/Medium)
  • These are new tracking issues from recently started agents

🟢 HEALTHY

Supervisor Sessions

  • All 17 supervisor sessions are busy (active)
  • Sessions checked: implementor-pool, reviewer-pool, tester-pool, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool, architect, epic-planner, human-liaison, agent-evolver, arch-guard, spec-updater, backlog-groomer, docs-writer, timeline-updater, project-owner, system-watchdog (old), product-builder
  • No zombie/sleep-only patterns detected in spot checks
  • human-liaison is aware of master CI issue

Branch Protection

  • Master branch protection active
  • Status checks required: build, coverage, docker, integration_tests, lint, quality, security, typecheck, unit_tests, e2e_tests
  • Push whitelist: only freemo can push directly

Improvement Generation

  • Multiple tracking issues being created regularly
  • Agents are active and producing Forgejo activity

Actions Taken This Cycle

  • Created this health report tracking issue
  • Identified branch protection approval gap (0 vs required 2)
  • Identified stale PRs needing review attention

Next Cycle

  • Verify master CI results for commit c87fc3bb
  • Monitor PR review coverage
  • Check if stale PRs get reviewed or merged

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## System Watchdog Health Report — Cycle 43 **Instance**: watchdog-1 (new session, continuing from cycle 42) **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T05:44:00Z **Status**: 🟡 MONITORING — Issues detected --- ## 🔴 CRITICAL Findings ### 1. Master CI Status — Pending/Unknown - Latest master commit: `c87fc3bb` ("fix: Scale implementation orchestrator to 32 parallel workers") - All CI status checks show `null` state — CI is currently running or results not yet reported - Previous alert issue #5284 documents integration_tests failure on prior commit `b72b8275` - **Action**: Monitoring CI completion; alert #5284 remains open ### 2. Branch Protection — ⚠️ Required Approvals = 0 - Branch protection is active with status checks required ✅ - However: `required_approvals: 0` — PRs can merge without any human review - CONTRIBUTING.md requires 2 approvals per PR - **Severity**: HIGH — This allows unreviewed code to reach master --- ## 🟡 HIGH Findings ### 3. PR Pipeline — Multiple Stale PRs Without Reviews - **PR #4652** (11h old): `docs: add module guides` — has REQUEST_CHANGES from `freemo` — needs attention - **PR #4663** (11h old): `docs(timeline): Day 97` — no reviews found - **PR #4757** (10h old): `docs: v3.8.0 documentation updates` — no reviews - **PR #4805** (10h old): `docs: architecture Milestone Plan` — no reviews - **PR #4830** (9h old): `docs: document agent system improvements` — no reviews - Total open PRs: 20+ — many docs PRs aging without review ### 4. Automation Tracking Issues Missing Labels - Issues #5290, #5291, #5295 have no labels (missing Type/Automation, State/In Progress, Priority/Medium) - These are new tracking issues from recently started agents --- ## 🟢 HEALTHY ### Supervisor Sessions - All 17 supervisor sessions are **busy** (active) ✅ - Sessions checked: implementor-pool, reviewer-pool, tester-pool, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool, architect, epic-planner, human-liaison, agent-evolver, arch-guard, spec-updater, backlog-groomer, docs-writer, timeline-updater, project-owner, system-watchdog (old), product-builder - No zombie/sleep-only patterns detected in spot checks - human-liaison is aware of master CI issue ✅ ### Branch Protection - Master branch protection active ✅ - Status checks required: build, coverage, docker, integration_tests, lint, quality, security, typecheck, unit_tests, e2e_tests ✅ - Push whitelist: only `freemo` can push directly ✅ ### Improvement Generation - Multiple tracking issues being created regularly ✅ - Agents are active and producing Forgejo activity ✅ --- ## Actions Taken This Cycle - Created this health report tracking issue - Identified branch protection approval gap (0 vs required 2) - Identified stale PRs needing review attention ## Next Cycle - Verify master CI results for commit `c87fc3bb` - Monitor PR review coverage - Check if stale PRs get reviewed or merged --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 44 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T05:54:00Z

Master CI Now GREEN

  • Commit c87fc3bb — all required CI checks passing
  • integration_tests completed successfully in 4m26s
  • Alert issue #5284 closed

Supervisor Health

  • All 15 primary supervisor sessions: busy
  • 36 total active sessions (up from 18 — workers spawned)
  • implementor-pool on cycle 5, actively monitoring workers

PR Pipeline

Label Fixes

  • Fixed missing labels on issue #5332 (AUTO-BUG-POOL)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 44 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T05:54:00Z ### ✅ Master CI Now GREEN - Commit `c87fc3bb` — all required CI checks passing - `integration_tests` completed successfully in 4m26s - Alert issue #5284 closed ### Supervisor Health - All 15 primary supervisor sessions: **busy** ✅ - 36 total active sessions (up from 18 — workers spawned) - implementor-pool on cycle 5, actively monitoring workers ### PR Pipeline - Multiple PRs with REQUEST_CHANGES from `freemo` (PRs #4805, #4830, #4979) - PR #4932, #5035, #5133 have no reviews (5-6h old) - New PRs #5301, #5303 created this cycle ### Label Fixes - Fixed missing labels on issue #5332 (AUTO-BUG-POOL) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 45 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T06:01:00Z

Master CI — FULLY GREEN

  • All required checks passing on c87fc3bb including status-check
  • No new commits to master this cycle

Supervisor Health — All Active

  • 32 active sessions (workers spawning/completing normally)
  • implementor-pool: cycle 11, monitoring workers
  • reviewer-pool: 16 sessions active
  • arch-guard: actively scanning codebase, created refactoring issue
  • epic-planner: creating new epics for TUI Legendary

PR Pipeline

  • PRs #4805, #4830: REQUEST_CHANGES from freemo — agents need to address
  • PR #4932: 7h old, no reviews, CI pending
  • New PRs #5325, #5303, #5301 created this cycle

UAT Findings (New)

  • UAT agent filed multiple Critical bugs in v3.2.0 milestone:
    • #5346: plan.py docstring missing commands
    • #5344: plan explain JSON format wrong
    • #5341: plan tree JSON format wrong
    • #5336: PlanExecutor not persisting StrategyDecision
    • #5307, #5302: plan correct issues
  • These are correctly in v3.2.0 (lowest milestone) — priority ordering OK

Label Fixes

  • Fixed missing labels on issue #5354 (AUTO-BUG-POOL worker announcement)

Milestone Status

  • v3.2.0: 173 open / 243 closed (41% complete)
  • v3.3.0: 89 open / 108 closed (55% complete)
  • v3.5.0: 779 open / 193 closed (20% complete) — large milestone

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 45 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T06:01:00Z ### ✅ Master CI — FULLY GREEN - All required checks passing on `c87fc3bb` including `status-check` ✅ - No new commits to master this cycle ### Supervisor Health — All Active - 32 active sessions (workers spawning/completing normally) - implementor-pool: cycle 11, monitoring workers - reviewer-pool: 16 sessions active - arch-guard: actively scanning codebase, created refactoring issue - epic-planner: creating new epics for TUI Legendary ### PR Pipeline - PRs #4805, #4830: REQUEST_CHANGES from `freemo` — agents need to address - PR #4932: 7h old, no reviews, CI pending - New PRs #5325, #5303, #5301 created this cycle ### UAT Findings (New) - UAT agent filed multiple Critical bugs in v3.2.0 milestone: - #5346: plan.py docstring missing commands - #5344: plan explain JSON format wrong - #5341: plan tree JSON format wrong - #5336: PlanExecutor not persisting StrategyDecision - #5307, #5302: plan correct issues - These are correctly in v3.2.0 (lowest milestone) — priority ordering OK ✅ ### Label Fixes - Fixed missing labels on issue #5354 (AUTO-BUG-POOL worker announcement) ### Milestone Status - v3.2.0: 173 open / 243 closed (41% complete) - v3.3.0: 89 open / 108 closed (55% complete) - v3.5.0: 779 open / 193 closed (20% complete) — large milestone --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 46 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T06:07:00Z

Master CI — GREEN (unchanged)

  • status-check passing on c87fc3bb
  • No new commits to master

Supervisor Health

  • 29 active sessions
  • implementor-pool: cycle 11, monitoring workers
  • reviewer-pool: 16 sessions, PR-4583 reviewer active
  • arch-guard: cycle 2, scanning for new commits
  • hunter-pool: cycle 35-36, workers still busy
  • epic-planner: updating TUI Legendary with new epics
  • agent-evolver: created proposal #5323

⚠️ test-infra-pool Struggling

  • Session ses_28f3f2adfffewuPUlOkXpFl8cE is having trouble with security constraints
  • Agent mentions "security policies" blocking worker adoption attempts
  • Still active (busy) but may not be making full progress
  • This is a known pattern — Gemini-based agents sometimes struggle with bash restrictions
  • Action: Monitoring; will escalate if no progress in next 2 cycles

PR Pipeline

  • PRs #4805, #4830: Still have REQUEST_CHANGES from freemo (10h old)
    • Agents have posted review comments but cannot self-approve
    • These need human attention from freemo to resolve
  • No new PRs older than 8h

Automation Tracking

  • All recent tracking issues have correct labels
  • New issues: #5361 (REV-POOL cycle 12), #5356 (GROOMER cycle 42)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 46 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T06:07:00Z ### ✅ Master CI — GREEN (unchanged) - `status-check` passing on `c87fc3bb` ✅ - No new commits to master ### Supervisor Health - 29 active sessions - implementor-pool: cycle 11, monitoring workers - reviewer-pool: 16 sessions, PR-4583 reviewer active - arch-guard: cycle 2, scanning for new commits - hunter-pool: cycle 35-36, workers still busy - epic-planner: updating TUI Legendary with new epics - agent-evolver: created proposal #5323 ### ⚠️ test-infra-pool Struggling - Session `ses_28f3f2adfffewuPUlOkXpFl8cE` is having trouble with security constraints - Agent mentions "security policies" blocking worker adoption attempts - Still active (busy) but may not be making full progress - This is a known pattern — Gemini-based agents sometimes struggle with bash restrictions - **Action**: Monitoring; will escalate if no progress in next 2 cycles ### PR Pipeline - PRs #4805, #4830: Still have REQUEST_CHANGES from `freemo` (10h old) - Agents have posted review comments but cannot self-approve - These need human attention from `freemo` to resolve - No new PRs older than 8h ### Automation Tracking - All recent tracking issues have correct labels ✅ - New issues: #5361 (REV-POOL cycle 12), #5356 (GROOMER cycle 42) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 47 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T06:19:00Z

🆕 New Master Commit

  • Commit ee202404: "fix(plan): upsert action arguments during plan use to avoid UNIQUE constraint violation"
  • CI running: integration_tests , lint , unit_tests , e2e_tests
  • Still pending: coverage, docker, status-check

Supervisor Health

  • 50 active sessions (high activity — workers spawning)
  • All primary supervisors: busy
  • hunter-pool: 8 workers active scanning modules (cycle 60)
  • epic-planner: creating new epics

⚠️ test-infra-pool — Systemic Issue Detected

  • Multiple sessions (ses_28f3f2adfffewuPUlOkXpFl8cE, ses_28f29a82effe1vrXzn1Fsv5c0s, ses_28f217beaffe3cx78mHQYth2b8) stuck
  • Root cause: agent uses bash pipelines (curl | jq) which are blocked by security policy
  • Action: Created Needs Feedback issue #5396 for human review
  • Agent-evolver should pick this up and propose a fix

Label Fixes

  • Fixed missing labels on issue #5388 (AUTO-BUG-POOL cycle 60)

PR Pipeline

  • PRs #4805, #4830: Still have REQUEST_CHANGES from freemo (11h old)
  • New PR #5380 created this cycle

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 47 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T06:19:00Z ### 🆕 New Master Commit - Commit `ee202404`: "fix(plan): upsert action arguments during plan use to avoid UNIQUE constraint violation" - CI running: integration_tests ✅, lint ✅, unit_tests ✅, e2e_tests ✅ - Still pending: coverage, docker, status-check ### Supervisor Health - 50 active sessions (high activity — workers spawning) - All primary supervisors: busy ✅ - hunter-pool: 8 workers active scanning modules (cycle 60) - epic-planner: creating new epics ### ⚠️ test-infra-pool — Systemic Issue Detected - Multiple sessions (`ses_28f3f2adfffewuPUlOkXpFl8cE`, `ses_28f29a82effe1vrXzn1Fsv5c0s`, `ses_28f217beaffe3cx78mHQYth2b8`) stuck - Root cause: agent uses bash pipelines (`curl | jq`) which are blocked by security policy - **Action**: Created `Needs Feedback` issue #5396 for human review - Agent-evolver should pick this up and propose a fix ### Label Fixes - Fixed missing labels on issue #5388 (AUTO-BUG-POOL cycle 60) ### PR Pipeline - PRs #4805, #4830: Still have REQUEST_CHANGES from `freemo` (11h old) - New PR #5380 created this cycle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 48 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T06:30:00Z

Master CI — GREEN

  • Commit ee202404 — all checks passing including status-check
  • No new commits to master

Supervisor Health — 91 Active Sessions

  • High activity: workers spawning for PR fixes and issue implementations
  • implementor-pool (primary): monitoring issue-5284 worker (1 worker, 31 slots available)
  • implementor-pool (secondary ses_28f2503e9ffe): looking for new issues to work on
  • PR-fix workers active: PRs #4381, #5271, #5175, #5276
  • reviewer-pool: 16 sessions active

⚠️ Implementor-Pool Primary Stuck on Closed Issue

  • ses_28f3f4120ffeZ34ApUoHmkqZ7C is monitoring worker for issue #5284 (master CI alert)
  • Issue #5284 was closed by watchdog in cycle 44 (CI resolved)
  • Worker ses_28f3740b4ffePPImjLdtdlrV0A is still busy working on it
  • The secondary implementor-pool is correctly looking for new work
  • Severity: MEDIUM — system has redundancy, secondary pool is working

test-infra-pool — Confirmed Blocked

  • Issue #5401 self-reports: "CRITICAL FAILURE — cannot extract session ID from API response"
  • Needs Feedback issue #5396 created last cycle
  • Agent-evolver should propose a fix

Label Fixes

  • Fixed missing labels on issue #5401 (AUTO-INF-POOL critical failure)
  • Closed stale watchdog tracking issue #5370 (old session)

PR Pipeline


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 48 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T06:30:00Z ### ✅ Master CI — GREEN - Commit `ee202404` — all checks passing including `status-check` ✅ - No new commits to master ### Supervisor Health — 91 Active Sessions - High activity: workers spawning for PR fixes and issue implementations - implementor-pool (primary): monitoring issue-5284 worker (1 worker, 31 slots available) - implementor-pool (secondary `ses_28f2503e9ffe`): looking for new issues to work on - PR-fix workers active: PRs #4381, #5271, #5175, #5276 - reviewer-pool: 16 sessions active ### ⚠️ Implementor-Pool Primary Stuck on Closed Issue - `ses_28f3f4120ffeZ34ApUoHmkqZ7C` is monitoring worker for issue #5284 (master CI alert) - Issue #5284 was **closed** by watchdog in cycle 44 (CI resolved) - Worker `ses_28f3740b4ffePPImjLdtdlrV0A` is still busy working on it - The secondary implementor-pool is correctly looking for new work - **Severity**: MEDIUM — system has redundancy, secondary pool is working ### test-infra-pool — Confirmed Blocked - Issue #5401 self-reports: "CRITICAL FAILURE — cannot extract session ID from API response" - Needs Feedback issue #5396 created last cycle ✅ - Agent-evolver should propose a fix ### Label Fixes - Fixed missing labels on issue #5401 (AUTO-INF-POOL critical failure) - Closed stale watchdog tracking issue #5370 (old session) ### PR Pipeline - No PRs older than 8h ✅ - Workers actively fixing PRs #4381, #5271, #5175, #5276 --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Author
Owner

Cycle 49 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T06:43:00Z

Master CI — GREEN

  • Commit ee202404status-check passing
  • No new commits to master

Supervisor Health — 115 Active Sessions

  • Very high activity — system is scaling up workers
  • All primary supervisors: busy
  • epic-planner: cycle 12, checking epic completeness for v3.5.0-v3.7.0
  • New PRs created: #5410, #5403, #5393

⚠️ Implementor-Pool Primary — Persistent Stuck Pattern

  • ses_28f3f4120ffeZ34ApUoHmkqZ7C still on cycle 11 monitoring issue-5284 worker
  • This has been the same state for 3+ cycles (15+ minutes)
  • Worker ses_28f3740b4ffePPImjLdtdlrV0A is using Gemini reasoning model, still busy
  • Issue #5284 (master CI alert) was closed — worker may be confused
  • Severity: MEDIUM — secondary pool ses_28f2503e9ffe is working normally
  • Action: Will escalate to HIGH if still stuck in cycle 51

Label Fixes

  • Fixed missing labels on issue #5422 (AUTO-EPIC cycle 12)

PR Pipeline


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 49 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T06:43:00Z ### ✅ Master CI — GREEN - Commit `ee202404` — `status-check` passing ✅ - No new commits to master ### Supervisor Health — 115 Active Sessions - Very high activity — system is scaling up workers - All primary supervisors: busy ✅ - epic-planner: cycle 12, checking epic completeness for v3.5.0-v3.7.0 - New PRs created: #5410, #5403, #5393 ### ⚠️ Implementor-Pool Primary — Persistent Stuck Pattern - `ses_28f3f4120ffeZ34ApUoHmkqZ7C` still on cycle 11 monitoring issue-5284 worker - This has been the same state for 3+ cycles (15+ minutes) - Worker `ses_28f3740b4ffePPImjLdtdlrV0A` is using Gemini reasoning model, still busy - Issue #5284 (master CI alert) was closed — worker may be confused - **Severity**: MEDIUM — secondary pool `ses_28f2503e9ffe` is working normally - **Action**: Will escalate to HIGH if still stuck in cycle 51 ### Label Fixes - Fixed missing labels on issue #5422 (AUTO-EPIC cycle 12) ### PR Pipeline - New PRs: #5410, #5403, #5393, #5380 — all recently created - No stale PRs detected --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#5299
No description provided.