[AUTO-SPEC] Status: Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking (Cycle 6) #8682

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-13 22:13:08 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 22:13:08 +00:00

Owner

\n## [AUTO-SPEC] Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking\n\n**Session Tag**: `[AUTO-SPEC]`\n**Started**: 2026-04-13\n**Model**: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-6\n**Cycle Interval**: 15 minutes\n**Worker Pool**: Up to 8 workers (spec-update-worker)\n\n---\n\n## Current State\n\n**Master SHA**: `5438540803a60085dd1cc0983ae364382732c30e`\n**Last checked**: 2026-04-13 ~21:45 UTC\n**SHA change from Cycle 4**: `c5afe1f3` → `5438540803a6` (1 new commit)\n\n---\n\n## Open Spec PRs Being Monitored\n\n| PR | Title | Status | Notes |\n|----|-------|--------|-------|\n| #8276 | docs/spec): clarify sandbox path containment, datetime comparison, and plugin validation contracts | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | ⚠️ DUPLICATE: Content already merged via PR #7362. Notified. Awaiting closure. |\n| #8437 | docs(adr): add ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | AUTO-ARCH-5 claims fixes applied. Awaiting human re-review. |\n| #8578 | spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | Fills spec gap. Missing CHANGELOG/CONTRIBUTORS. |\n| #8579 | spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | Consistent with spec. Missing `Needs Feedback` label, milestone, CHANGELOG. |\n| #8581 | spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy | Open — COMMENT review posted | ⚠️ Five-layer model inconsistent with existing four-layer description at line 43177. |\n| #8627 | docs(spec): add Plan Correction Engine specification (v3.2.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | ⚠️ CLI interface spec conflicts with existing spec (uses `--decision` flag instead of positional arg). UUID/ULID inconsistency. |\n\n---\n\n## Cycle 6 Summary\n\n**New commits analyzed**: 1\n- `9998b4f9ada1`: "Build: Removed unnessecary status-check target as well" — CI/build only, no spec implications\n\n**New spec PRs detected**: 1\n- PR #8658: Invariant Management System (v3.2.0) — reviewed, multiple discrepancies found\n\n**Notable non-spec PRs**:\n- PR #8640: `fix(cli): remove positional NAME from agents actor add — read name from YAML file` — Fixes known deviation #5855. ✅\n- PR #8636: `fix(actor): validate v3 YAML via ActorConfigSchema in agents actor add CLI` — Fixes known deviation #5869. ✅\n- PR #8661: `fix(cli): add agents plan start alias or update spec to reflect v3 plan use/execute commands` — ⚠️ FALSE PREMISE: Spec uses `plan use`, not `plan start`. Review posted recommending closure.\n\n**Actions taken**:\n1. ✅ Detected master SHA advance (5438540803a6 → 9998b4f9ada1)\n2. ✅ Analyzed new commit — CI/build only, no spec implications\n3. ✅ Reviewed PR #8658 — multiple discrepancies found (CLI interface, scopes, UUID/ULID, missing non-overridable)\n4. ✅ Reviewed PR #8661 — false premise (spec uses `plan use`, not `plan start`)\n5. ✅ Noted PRs #8640 and #8636 as positive — fix known deviations #5855 and #5869\n\n**Key Findings**:\n- PR #8658 (Invariant Management System): CLI interface uses `--name`/`--description` flags but existing spec uses positional text argument. Only 2 scopes vs 4 in existing spec.\n- PR #8661 (plan start alias): Based on false premise — spec uses `plan use` throughout, not `plan start`.\n\n---\n\n## Pending Proposals\n\nNone currently open.\n\n---\n\n## Known Implementation Deviations (Tracked Separately)\n\n| Issue | Description | Status |\n|-------|-------------|--------|\n| #5855 | `agents actor add` requires undocumented positional NAME argument | Open — PR #8640 in review |\n| #5869 | `agents actor add --config` uses v2 parser instead of v3 ActorConfigSchema | Open — PR #8636 in review |\n| #8570 | CLI→Infrastructure violation in `actor.py` (`_get_services` calls `get_container()`) | Open — implementation bug |\n\n---\n\n## Next Cycle Actions\n\n- Check if master SHA has advanced\n- Monitor PRs #8578, #8579, #8581 for human review\n- Monitor PR #8437 for human re-review\n- Monitor PR #8276 for closure (duplicate)\n- Monitor PR #8636 for merge (fixes deviation #5869)\n- Continue proactive spec-vs-code comparison (sandbox, checkpoint modules)\n\n---\n\n## Activity Log\n\n| Cycle | Time | Action | Result |\n|-------|------|--------|--------|\n| 1 | 2026-04-13 20:10 UTC | Startup, PR review, commit analysis | No new divergences; reviews posted on #8276 and #8437 |\n| 2 | 2026-04-13 20:35 UTC | SHA advance detected, duplicate PR identified | No new divergences; PR #8276 notified of duplicate status |\n| 3 | 2026-04-13 20:55 UTC | Idle cycle, proactive spec-vs-code comparison | No new divergences; context/automation-profile/actor modules checked |\n| 4 | 2026-04-13 21:20 UTC | Idle cycle, 3 new spec PRs detected and reviewed | Reviews posted on #8578, #8579, #8581; inconsistency in #8581 noted |\n| 5 | 2026-04-13 21:45 UTC | SHA advance, new spec PR #8627 reviewed | CLI interface discrepancy found in #8627; PR #8636 fixes deviation #5869 |\n\n---\n**Automated by CleverAgents Bot**\nSupervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor\n\n---\nAutomated by CleverAgents Bot\nAgent: automation-tracking-manager

```\n## [AUTO-SPEC] Spec Update Pool Supervisor — Status Tracking\n\n**Session Tag**: `[AUTO-SPEC]`\n**Started**: 2026-04-13\n**Model**: anthropic/claude-sonnet-4-6\n**Cycle Interval**: 15 minutes\n**Worker Pool**: Up to 8 workers (spec-update-worker)\n\n---\n\n## Current State\n\n**Master SHA**: `5438540803a60085dd1cc0983ae364382732c30e`\n**Last checked**: 2026-04-13 ~21:45 UTC\n**SHA change from Cycle 4**: `c5afe1f3` → `5438540803a6` (1 new commit)\n\n---\n\n## Open Spec PRs Being Monitored\n\n| PR | Title | Status | Notes |\n|----|-------|--------|-------|\n| #8276 | docs/spec): clarify sandbox path containment, datetime comparison, and plugin validation contracts | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | ⚠️ DUPLICATE: Content already merged via PR #7362. Notified. Awaiting closure. |\n| #8437 | docs(adr): add ADR-049 Layered Architecture Boundary Enforcement Policy | Open — REQUEST_CHANGES | AUTO-ARCH-5 claims fixes applied. Awaiting human re-review. |\n| #8578 | spec: TuiMaterializer A2A Integration Layer (v3.7.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | Fills spec gap. Missing CHANGELOG/CONTRIBUTORS. |\n| #8579 | spec: Decision Recording System (v3.2.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | Consistent with spec. Missing `Needs Feedback` label, milestone, CHANGELOG. |\n| #8581 | spec: Layered Architecture Boundary Policy | Open — COMMENT review posted | ⚠️ Five-layer model inconsistent with existing four-layer description at line 43177. |\n| #8627 | docs(spec): add Plan Correction Engine specification (v3.2.0) | Open — COMMENT review posted | ⚠️ CLI interface spec conflicts with existing spec (uses `--decision` flag instead of positional arg). UUID/ULID inconsistency. |\n\n---\n\n## Cycle 6 Summary\n\n**New commits analyzed**: 1\n- `9998b4f9ada1`: "Build: Removed unnessecary status-check target as well" — CI/build only, no spec implications\n\n**New spec PRs detected**: 1\n- PR #8658: Invariant Management System (v3.2.0) — reviewed, multiple discrepancies found\n\n**Notable non-spec PRs**:\n- PR #8640: `fix(cli): remove positional NAME from agents actor add — read name from YAML file` — Fixes known deviation #5855. ✅\n- PR #8636: `fix(actor): validate v3 YAML via ActorConfigSchema in agents actor add CLI` — Fixes known deviation #5869. ✅\n- PR #8661: `fix(cli): add agents plan start alias or update spec to reflect v3 plan use/execute commands` — ⚠️ FALSE PREMISE: Spec uses `plan use`, not `plan start`. Review posted recommending closure.\n\n**Actions taken**:\n1. ✅ Detected master SHA advance (5438540803a6 → 9998b4f9ada1)\n2. ✅ Analyzed new commit — CI/build only, no spec implications\n3. ✅ Reviewed PR #8658 — multiple discrepancies found (CLI interface, scopes, UUID/ULID, missing non-overridable)\n4. ✅ Reviewed PR #8661 — false premise (spec uses `plan use`, not `plan start`)\n5. ✅ Noted PRs #8640 and #8636 as positive — fix known deviations #5855 and #5869\n\n**Key Findings**:\n- PR #8658 (Invariant Management System): CLI interface uses `--name`/`--description` flags but existing spec uses positional text argument. Only 2 scopes vs 4 in existing spec.\n- PR #8661 (plan start alias): Based on false premise — spec uses `plan use` throughout, not `plan start`.\n\n---\n\n## Pending Proposals\n\nNone currently open.\n\n---\n\n## Known Implementation Deviations (Tracked Separately)\n\n| Issue | Description | Status |\n|-------|-------------|--------|\n| #5855 | `agents actor add` requires undocumented positional NAME argument | Open — PR #8640 in review |\n| #5869 | `agents actor add --config` uses v2 parser instead of v3 ActorConfigSchema | Open — PR #8636 in review |\n| #8570 | CLI→Infrastructure violation in `actor.py` (`_get_services` calls `get_container()`) | Open — implementation bug |\n\n---\n\n## Next Cycle Actions\n\n- Check if master SHA has advanced\n- Monitor PRs #8578, #8579, #8581 for human review\n- Monitor PR #8437 for human re-review\n- Monitor PR #8276 for closure (duplicate)\n- Monitor PR #8636 for merge (fixes deviation #5869)\n- Continue proactive spec-vs-code comparison (sandbox, checkpoint modules)\n\n---\n\n## Activity Log\n\n| Cycle | Time | Action | Result |\n|-------|------|--------|--------|\n| 1 | 2026-04-13 20:10 UTC | Startup, PR review, commit analysis | No new divergences; reviews posted on #8276 and #8437 |\n| 2 | 2026-04-13 20:35 UTC | SHA advance detected, duplicate PR identified | No new divergences; PR #8276 notified of duplicate status |\n| 3 | 2026-04-13 20:55 UTC | Idle cycle, proactive spec-vs-code comparison | No new divergences; context/automation-profile/actor modules checked |\n| 4 | 2026-04-13 21:20 UTC | Idle cycle, 3 new spec PRs detected and reviewed | Reviews posted on #8578, #8579, #8581; inconsistency in #8581 noted |\n| 5 | 2026-04-13 21:45 UTC | SHA advance, new spec PR #8627 reviewed | CLI interface discrepancy found in #8627; PR #8636 fixes deviation #5869 |\n\n---\n**Automated by CleverAgents Bot**\nSupervisor: Spec Evolution | Agent: spec-update-pool-supervisor\n```\n---\n**Automated by CleverAgents Bot**\nAgent: automation-tracking-manager

Rows
Columns