cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-EVLV] Agent Evolution Report (Cycle 1) #8167

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-13 04:07:19 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 7 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 04:07:19 +00:00

Owner

## Agent Evolution Pool Supervisor — Cycle 1

**Agent**: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor
**Cycle**: 1
**Started**: 2026-04-13
**Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — Analysis complete, proposals being created

## Analysis Summary

Analyzed agent performance data from:
- System Watchdog reports (issues #7933, #7882)
- Existing AUTO-EVLV proposal issue #8107
- Product Builder session data
- All supervisor tracking issues

## Patterns Identified

### Pattern 1 (EXISTING — Awaiting Human Approval)
**Issue #8107**: `pr-merge-pool-supervisor` lists 6 merge criteria but runtime applies 10
- Status: Open, `Needs Feedback` label applied
- Action: Awaiting human approval before implementation

### Pattern 2 (NEW — Capability Gap)
**`product-builder.md` references non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` agent**
- The product-builder supervisor table lists `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` with tag `[AUTO-PRFIX-SUP]`
- No `pr-fix-pool-supervisor.md` file exists in `.opencode/agents/`
- Watchdog Cycle 6 (#7933) confirmed `AUTO-PRFIX-SUP` became a zombie: "I'm sorry, but I can't help with that."
- This causes the product-builder to launch a non-existent agent, which fails silently
- Category: Capability Gap (Category 7)
- Proposal issue: TBD (being created this cycle)

### Pattern 3 (NEW — Task-type Failure)
**`implementation-worker` missing PR diff/files permissions for PR fix mode**
- The worker has two modes: new issue implementation and PR fix
- PR fix mode requires reading PR diff and changed files to understand failures
- Missing permissions: `forgejo_list_pull_request_files`, `forgejo_get_pull_request_diff`
- Workers in PR fix mode cannot directly inspect what changed in the PR
- Category: Task-type failures (Category 1)
- Proposal issue: TBD (being created this cycle)

## Proposals Status

| # | Issue | Pattern | Status |
|---|-------|---------|--------|
| 1 | #8107 | pr-merge-pool-supervisor: 6 vs 10 criteria | ⏳ Awaiting human approval |
| 2 | TBD | product-builder: non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor | 🔄 Creating proposal |
| 3 | TBD | implementation-worker: missing PR diff permissions | 🔄 Creating proposal |

## Next Cycle Actions
- Monitor #8107 for human approval
- Create proposal issues for Patterns 2 and 3
- Continue monitoring for new patterns

---
**Automated by CleverAgents Bot**
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

``` ## Agent Evolution Pool Supervisor — Cycle 1 **Agent**: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor **Cycle**: 1 **Started**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — Analysis complete, proposals being created ## Analysis Summary Analyzed agent performance data from: - System Watchdog reports (issues #7933, #7882) - Existing AUTO-EVLV proposal issue #8107 - Product Builder session data - All supervisor tracking issues ## Patterns Identified ### Pattern 1 (EXISTING — Awaiting Human Approval) **Issue #8107**: `pr-merge-pool-supervisor` lists 6 merge criteria but runtime applies 10 - Status: Open, `Needs Feedback` label applied - Action: Awaiting human approval before implementation ### Pattern 2 (NEW — Capability Gap) **`product-builder.md` references non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` agent** - The product-builder supervisor table lists `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` with tag `[AUTO-PRFIX-SUP]` - No `pr-fix-pool-supervisor.md` file exists in `.opencode/agents/` - Watchdog Cycle 6 (#7933) confirmed `AUTO-PRFIX-SUP` became a zombie: "I'm sorry, but I can't help with that." - This causes the product-builder to launch a non-existent agent, which fails silently - Category: Capability Gap (Category 7) - Proposal issue: TBD (being created this cycle) ### Pattern 3 (NEW — Task-type Failure) **`implementation-worker` missing PR diff/files permissions for PR fix mode** - The worker has two modes: new issue implementation and PR fix - PR fix mode requires reading PR diff and changed files to understand failures - Missing permissions: `forgejo_list_pull_request_files`, `forgejo_get_pull_request_diff` - Workers in PR fix mode cannot directly inspect what changed in the PR - Category: Task-type failures (Category 1) - Proposal issue: TBD (being created this cycle) ## Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Status | |---|-------|---------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | pr-merge-pool-supervisor: 6 vs 10 criteria | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | | 2 | TBD | product-builder: non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor | 🔄 Creating proposal | | 3 | TBD | implementation-worker: missing PR diff permissions | 🔄 Creating proposal | ## Next Cycle Actions - Monitor #8107 for human approval - Create proposal issues for Patterns 2 and 3 - Continue monitoring for new patterns --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor ```

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 04:15:39 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 1 Complete — Analysis Summary

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 proposals open, awaiting human approval

Analysis Performed

Data Sources Reviewed:

System Watchdog Cycle 6 report (issue #7933) — zombie session detection
Product Builder Cycle 1 report (issue #7882) — supervisor launch registry
PR Merge Supervisor Cycle 1 report (issue #7820) — merge criteria runtime behavior
All AUTO-EVLV proposal issues (searched pages 1-6 of open issues)
Agent definition files: product-builder.md, implementation-worker.md, pr-merge-pool-supervisor.md, implementation-pool-supervisor.md, pr-reviewer.md

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 merge criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	⏳ Awaiting human approval
2	#8169	`product-builder`: references non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	⏳ Awaiting human approval
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	⏳ Awaiting human approval

Key Findings

Pattern 1 (Issue #8107): The pr-merge-pool-supervisor documents 6 merge criteria but applies 10 at runtime. The 4 undocumented criteria (milestone, Type/ label, Closes reference, changelog) come from CONTRIBUTING.md. This inconsistency causes different supervisor instances to apply different criteria.

Pattern 2 (Issue #8169): The product-builder supervisor table references pr-fix-pool-supervisor (tag [AUTO-PRFIX-SUP]) but no such agent file exists. This caused a confirmed zombie session (Watchdog Cycle 6, issue #7933): the session responded "I'm sorry, but I can't help with that." PR fixing is already handled by implementation-pool-supervisor via its PR-First Priority rule.

Pattern 3 (Issue #8175): The implementation-worker lacks forgejo_list_pull_request_files and forgejo_get_pull_request_diff permissions despite having a PR fix mode that needs to read PR changes. The pr-reviewer agent (which also reads PRs) already has both permissions.

Next Cycle Actions

Monitor proposals #8107, #8169, #8175 for human approval
If any proposal is approved (label removed + State/Verified added), dispatch implementation worker
Continue scanning for new patterns in subsequent cycles

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 1 Complete — Analysis Summary **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 proposals open, awaiting human approval ### Analysis Performed **Data Sources Reviewed:** - System Watchdog Cycle 6 report (issue #7933) — zombie session detection - Product Builder Cycle 1 report (issue #7882) — supervisor launch registry - PR Merge Supervisor Cycle 1 report (issue #7820) — merge criteria runtime behavior - All AUTO-EVLV proposal issues (searched pages 1-6 of open issues) - Agent definition files: `product-builder.md`, `implementation-worker.md`, `pr-merge-pool-supervisor.md`, `implementation-pool-supervisor.md`, `pr-reviewer.md` ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 merge criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: references non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | ### Key Findings **Pattern 1 (Issue #8107):** The `pr-merge-pool-supervisor` documents 6 merge criteria but applies 10 at runtime. The 4 undocumented criteria (milestone, Type/ label, Closes reference, changelog) come from CONTRIBUTING.md. This inconsistency causes different supervisor instances to apply different criteria. **Pattern 2 (Issue #8169):** The `product-builder` supervisor table references `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` (tag `[AUTO-PRFIX-SUP]`) but no such agent file exists. This caused a confirmed zombie session (Watchdog Cycle 6, issue #7933): the session responded "I'm sorry, but I can't help with that." PR fixing is already handled by `implementation-pool-supervisor` via its PR-First Priority rule. **Pattern 3 (Issue #8175):** The `implementation-worker` lacks `forgejo_list_pull_request_files` and `forgejo_get_pull_request_diff` permissions despite having a PR fix mode that needs to read PR changes. The `pr-reviewer` agent (which also reads PRs) already has both permissions. ### Next Cycle Actions - Monitor proposals #8107, #8169, #8175 for human approval - If any proposal is approved (label removed + `State/Verified` added), dispatch implementation worker - Continue scanning for new patterns in subsequent cycles --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 05:08:31 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 2 Update — Implementation PR Created

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟢 ACTIVE — 1 PR created, 2 proposals still awaiting approval

Cycle 2 Actions

✅ Proposal #8107 Approved and Implemented

Issue #8107 was approved by the Project Owner (comment: "✅ Decision: APPROVED — Documentation consistency is important..."). Labels changed from Needs Feedback to State/Verified + MoSCoW/Should have.

Worker [AUTO-EVLV-1] was dispatched and successfully created:

PR #8228: docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour
URL: #8228
Branch: docs/agents/sync-pr-merge-criteria-8107 → master
Changes: Updated pr-merge-pool-supervisor.md — expanded 6 criteria to 10, clarified criterion wording
Labels: Needs Feedback, Type/Chore
Milestone: v3.2.0

⏳ Proposals #8169 and #8175 Still Awaiting Approval

Both proposals remain open with Needs Feedback label. No human action detected yet.

🔍 New Pattern Identified (Cycle 2 Scan)

Pattern 4 (NEW — Subtask Failures): 71% CI failure rate across the system

System Watchdog Cycle 8 (issue #8166) reports: 9,210 CI failures out of 12,989 total runs (71%)
263+ open PRs growing faster than being merged
This suggests implementation workers are creating PRs with failing CI despite the quality gate requirement
Assessment: This is a systemic issue but may be partially explained by historical early-project failures. Need more data before proposing an agent change. Will monitor in Cycle 3.

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ Implemented — PR #8228
2	#8169	`product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	⏳ Awaiting human approval
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	⏳ Awaiting human approval
4	TBD	71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code	Subtask failures (Cat 8)	🔍 Monitoring — need more data

Next Cycle Actions

Monitor PR #8228 for merge
Monitor proposals #8169 and #8175 for human approval
Gather more data on Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) before proposing

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 2 Update — Implementation PR Created **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — 1 PR created, 2 proposals still awaiting approval ### Cycle 2 Actions #### ✅ Proposal #8107 Approved and Implemented Issue #8107 was approved by the Project Owner (comment: "✅ Decision: APPROVED — Documentation consistency is important..."). Labels changed from `Needs Feedback` to `State/Verified` + `MoSCoW/Should have`. Worker `[AUTO-EVLV-1]` was dispatched and successfully created: - **PR #8228**: `docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour` - URL: https://git.cleverthis.com/cleveragents/cleveragents-core/pulls/8228 - Branch: `docs/agents/sync-pr-merge-criteria-8107` → `master` - Changes: Updated `pr-merge-pool-supervisor.md` — expanded 6 criteria to 10, clarified criterion wording - Labels: `Needs Feedback`, `Type/Chore` - Milestone: v3.2.0 #### ⏳ Proposals #8169 and #8175 Still Awaiting Approval Both proposals remain open with `Needs Feedback` label. No human action detected yet. #### 🔍 New Pattern Identified (Cycle 2 Scan) **Pattern 4 (NEW — Subtask Failures):** 71% CI failure rate across the system - System Watchdog Cycle 8 (issue #8166) reports: 9,210 CI failures out of 12,989 total runs (71%) - 263+ open PRs growing faster than being merged - This suggests implementation workers are creating PRs with failing CI despite the quality gate requirement - **Assessment:** This is a systemic issue but may be partially explained by historical early-project failures. Need more data before proposing an agent change. Will monitor in Cycle 3. ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ Implemented — PR #8228 | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ⏳ Awaiting human approval | | 4 | TBD | 71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code | Subtask failures (Cat 8) | 🔍 Monitoring — need more data | ### Next Cycle Actions - Monitor PR #8228 for merge - Monitor proposals #8169 and #8175 for human approval - Gather more data on Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) before proposing --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 06:11:56 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 3 Update — Two More Workers Dispatched

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs in progress, 2 workers running

Cycle 3 Actions

✅ Proposals #8169 and #8175 Both Approved

Issue #8169 (remove pr-fix-pool-supervisor): Approved by Project Owner — "Must Have. The watchdog has confirmed this creates zombie sessions every cycle, wasting resources and generating false alerts."

Issue #8175 (add PR diff/files permissions): Approved by Project Owner — "Adding read-only PR diff and file list permissions to the implementation-worker is a sound improvement."

🔄 Workers Dispatched

[AUTO-EVLV-2] (session ses_27a9cb8d4ffe8lnMVsOjmhgbJL): Implementing #8169 — removing pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder.md
[AUTO-EVLV-3] (session ses_27a90330affemEIOl55CIgPvAX): Implementing #8175 — adding PR diff/files permissions to implementation-worker.md

📊 PR #8228 Status

PR #8228 (docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour) is open and mergeable. Awaiting review and merge by the PR merge supervisor.

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ PR #8228 open
2	#8169	`product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	🔄 Worker [AUTO-EVLV-2] running
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	🔄 Worker [AUTO-EVLV-3] running
4	TBD	71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code	Subtask failures (Cat 8)	🔍 Monitoring

Next Cycle Actions

Check workers [AUTO-EVLV-2] and [AUTO-EVLV-3] for completion
Monitor PR #8228 for merge
Continue scanning for new patterns

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 3 Update — Two More Workers Dispatched **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs in progress, 2 workers running ### Cycle 3 Actions #### ✅ Proposals #8169 and #8175 Both Approved **Issue #8169** (remove pr-fix-pool-supervisor): Approved by Project Owner — "Must Have. The watchdog has confirmed this creates zombie sessions every cycle, wasting resources and generating false alerts." **Issue #8175** (add PR diff/files permissions): Approved by Project Owner — "Adding read-only PR diff and file list permissions to the implementation-worker is a sound improvement." #### 🔄 Workers Dispatched - **[AUTO-EVLV-2]** (session `ses_27a9cb8d4ffe8lnMVsOjmhgbJL`): Implementing #8169 — removing pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder.md - **[AUTO-EVLV-3]** (session `ses_27a90330affemEIOl55CIgPvAX`): Implementing #8175 — adding PR diff/files permissions to implementation-worker.md #### 📊 PR #8228 Status PR #8228 (`docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour`) is open and mergeable. Awaiting review and merge by the PR merge supervisor. ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ PR #8228 open | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | 🔄 Worker [AUTO-EVLV-2] running | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | 🔄 Worker [AUTO-EVLV-3] running | | 4 | TBD | 71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code | Subtask failures (Cat 8) | 🔍 Monitoring | ### Next Cycle Actions - Check workers [AUTO-EVLV-2] and [AUTO-EVLV-3] for completion - Monitor PR #8228 for merge - Continue scanning for new patterns --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 06:57:47 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 3 Complete — All 3 Implementation PRs Created

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs open, monitoring for merge and new patterns

Cycle 3 Results

✅ All Workers Completed Successfully

Worker	Session	Proposal	PR Created
[AUTO-EVLV-1]	`ses_27ad1a839ffe04J05WhzVACNw2`	#8107 (merge criteria)	PR #8228
[AUTO-EVLV-2]	`ses_27a9cb8d4ffe8lnMVsOjmhgbJL`	#8169 (remove pr-fix-pool-supervisor)	PR #8251
[AUTO-EVLV-3]	`ses_27a90330affemEIOl55CIgPvAX`	#8175 (impl-worker PR diff perms)	PR #8247

Open PRs Summary

PR	Title	Status
#8228	`docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour`	Open, mergeable
#8247	`fix(agents): add PR diff and file list permissions to implementation-worker`	Open
#8251	`chore(agents): remove non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder`	Open

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ PR #8228 — awaiting merge
2	#8169	`product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	✅ PR #8251 — awaiting merge
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ PR #8247 — awaiting merge
4	TBD	71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code	Subtask failures (Cat 8)	🔍 Monitoring — need more data

Next Cycle Actions

Monitor PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for merge
Continue scanning for new patterns (especially Pattern 4 — CI failure rate)
Check for any new proposals that need implementation

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 3 Complete — All 3 Implementation PRs Created **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs open, monitoring for merge and new patterns ### Cycle 3 Results #### ✅ All Workers Completed Successfully | Worker | Session | Proposal | PR Created | |--------|---------|----------|------------| | [AUTO-EVLV-1] | `ses_27ad1a839ffe04J05WhzVACNw2` | #8107 (merge criteria) | **PR #8228** | | [AUTO-EVLV-2] | `ses_27a9cb8d4ffe8lnMVsOjmhgbJL` | #8169 (remove pr-fix-pool-supervisor) | **PR #8251** | | [AUTO-EVLV-3] | `ses_27a90330affemEIOl55CIgPvAX` | #8175 (impl-worker PR diff perms) | **PR #8247** | ### Open PRs Summary | PR | Title | Status | |----|-------|--------| | #8228 | `docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria with runtime behaviour` | Open, mergeable | | #8247 | `fix(agents): add PR diff and file list permissions to implementation-worker` | Open | | #8251 | `chore(agents): remove non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder` | Open | ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ PR #8228 — awaiting merge | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | ✅ PR #8251 — awaiting merge | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ PR #8247 — awaiting merge | | 4 | TBD | 71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code | Subtask failures (Cat 8) | 🔍 Monitoring — need more data | ### Next Cycle Actions - Monitor PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for merge - Continue scanning for new patterns (especially Pattern 4 — CI failure rate) - Check for any new proposals that need implementation --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 07:41:34 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 4 Update — Monitoring PRs, No New Patterns

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs open and mergeable, monitoring for new patterns

Cycle 4 Actions

📊 PR Status Check

All 3 implementation PRs are open and mergeable:

PR	Title	State	Mergeable
#8228	`docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria`	Open	✅ Yes
#8247	`fix(agents): add PR diff and file list permissions to implementation-worker`	Open	✅ Yes
#8251	`chore(agents): remove non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder`	Open	✅ Yes

All PRs have State/Verified label (grooming system removed Needs Feedback and applied State/Verified). Awaiting review and merge by the PR merge supervisor.

🔍 Pattern Scan (Cycle 4)

Scanned pages 1-6 of open issues. No new AUTO-EVLV patterns found. The system is actively generating implementation work (new issues, PRs) but no new systemic agent failures detected.

Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) — Still Monitoring:

Previous data: 71% CI failure rate (9,210/12,989 runs) from Watchdog Cycle 8
No new watchdog reports found in this cycle's scan
Need to gather more data before proposing an agent change
This may be partially explained by historical early-project failures

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ PR #8228 — awaiting merge
2	#8169	`product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	✅ PR #8251 — awaiting merge
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	✅ PR #8247 — awaiting merge
4	TBD	71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code	Subtask failures (Cat 8)	🔍 Monitoring — need more data

Next Cycle Actions

Continue monitoring PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for merge
Look for latest watchdog report to assess CI failure rate trend
Continue scanning for new patterns

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 4 Update — Monitoring PRs, No New Patterns **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟢 ACTIVE — 3 PRs open and mergeable, monitoring for new patterns ### Cycle 4 Actions #### 📊 PR Status Check All 3 implementation PRs are open and mergeable: | PR | Title | State | Mergeable | |----|-------|-------|-----------| | #8228 | `docs(agents): sync pr-merge-pool-supervisor merge criteria` | Open | ✅ Yes | | #8247 | `fix(agents): add PR diff and file list permissions to implementation-worker` | Open | ✅ Yes | | #8251 | `chore(agents): remove non-existent pr-fix-pool-supervisor from product-builder` | Open | ✅ Yes | All PRs have `State/Verified` label (grooming system removed `Needs Feedback` and applied `State/Verified`). Awaiting review and merge by the PR merge supervisor. #### 🔍 Pattern Scan (Cycle 4) Scanned pages 1-6 of open issues. No new AUTO-EVLV patterns found. The system is actively generating implementation work (new issues, PRs) but no new systemic agent failures detected. **Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) — Still Monitoring:** - Previous data: 71% CI failure rate (9,210/12,989 runs) from Watchdog Cycle 8 - No new watchdog reports found in this cycle's scan - Need to gather more data before proposing an agent change - This may be partially explained by historical early-project failures ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ PR #8228 — awaiting merge | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | ✅ PR #8251 — awaiting merge | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ✅ PR #8247 — awaiting merge | | 4 | TBD | 71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code | Subtask failures (Cat 8) | 🔍 Monitoring — need more data | ### Next Cycle Actions - Continue monitoring PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for merge - Look for latest watchdog report to assess CI failure rate trend - Continue scanning for new patterns --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 08:15:23 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 5 Update — PRs Stale, Awaiting Rebase

Completed: 2026-04-13
Status: 🟡 MONITORING — 3 PRs stale (master advanced), awaiting PR merge supervisor rebase

Cycle 5 Actions

⚠️ PRs Now Stale — Master Has Advanced

All 3 implementation PRs are behind master (master SHA changed from 2005b8ef to 978849412dff):

PR	Branch	merge_base	base.sha	Stale?
#8228	`docs/agents/sync-pr-merge-criteria-8107`	`96ff9d0f`	`97884941`	✅ Yes
#8247	`fix/agents/impl-worker-pr-diff-perms-8175`	`2005b8ef`	`97884941`	✅ Yes
#8251	`chore/agents/remove-prfix-supervisor-8169`	`2005b8ef`	`97884941`	✅ Yes

The PR merge supervisor should detect these as stale and dispatch rebase workers. No action needed from this supervisor — the merge supervisor handles rebasing.

🔍 Pattern Scan (Cycle 5)

Scanned pages 1-3 of open issues. No new AUTO-EVLV patterns found. The system continues to generate implementation work normally.

Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) — Still Monitoring:

No new watchdog reports found in this cycle's scan
Continuing to monitor

Proposals Status

#	Issue	Pattern	Category	Status
1	#8107	`pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	⏳ PR #8228 — stale, awaiting rebase
2	#8169	`product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor`	Capability Gap (Cat 7)	⏳ PR #8251 — stale, awaiting rebase
3	#8175	`implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions	Task-type failures (Cat 1)	⏳ PR #8247 — stale, awaiting rebase
4	TBD	71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code	Subtask failures (Cat 8)	🔍 Monitoring — need more data

Next Cycle Actions

Monitor PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for rebase and merge
Continue scanning for new patterns

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 5 Update — PRs Stale, Awaiting Rebase **Completed**: 2026-04-13 **Status**: 🟡 MONITORING — 3 PRs stale (master advanced), awaiting PR merge supervisor rebase ### Cycle 5 Actions #### ⚠️ PRs Now Stale — Master Has Advanced All 3 implementation PRs are behind master (master SHA changed from `2005b8ef` to `978849412dff`): | PR | Branch | merge_base | base.sha | Stale? | |----|--------|-----------|----------|--------| | #8228 | `docs/agents/sync-pr-merge-criteria-8107` | `96ff9d0f` | `97884941` | ✅ Yes | | #8247 | `fix/agents/impl-worker-pr-diff-perms-8175` | `2005b8ef` | `97884941` | ✅ Yes | | #8251 | `chore/agents/remove-prfix-supervisor-8169` | `2005b8ef` | `97884941` | ✅ Yes | The PR merge supervisor should detect these as stale and dispatch rebase workers. No action needed from this supervisor — the merge supervisor handles rebasing. #### 🔍 Pattern Scan (Cycle 5) Scanned pages 1-3 of open issues. No new AUTO-EVLV patterns found. The system continues to generate implementation work normally. **Pattern 4 (CI failure rate) — Still Monitoring:** - No new watchdog reports found in this cycle's scan - Continuing to monitor ### Proposals Status | # | Issue | Pattern | Category | Status | |---|-------|---------|----------|--------| | 1 | #8107 | `pr-merge-pool-supervisor`: 6 vs 10 criteria | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ⏳ PR #8228 — stale, awaiting rebase | | 2 | #8169 | `product-builder`: non-existent `pr-fix-pool-supervisor` | Capability Gap (Cat 7) | ⏳ PR #8251 — stale, awaiting rebase | | 3 | #8175 | `implementation-worker`: missing PR diff/files permissions | Task-type failures (Cat 1) | ⏳ PR #8247 — stale, awaiting rebase | | 4 | TBD | 71% CI failure rate — workers pushing failing code | Subtask failures (Cat 8) | 🔍 Monitoring — need more data | ### Next Cycle Actions - Monitor PRs #8228, #8247, #8251 for rebase and merge - Continue scanning for new patterns --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor