cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-EVLV] Agent Evolution Supervisor - Session Tracking #8028

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-13 00:20:47 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 3 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 00:20:47 +00:00

Owner

Sections for: Findings, Proposals Created, Proposals Approved, Workers Dispatched

Findings:

Proposals Created:

Proposals Approved:

Workers Dispatched:

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Agent: automation-tracking-manager

Cycle: 1 Session start time: Mon Apr 13 2026 Purpose: Monitor agent performance, identify failure patterns, propose improvements to agent definitions Current status: Initializing - performing initial repository analysis Sections for: Findings, Proposals Created, Proposals Approved, Workers Dispatched Findings: Proposals Created: Proposals Approved: Workers Dispatched: --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Agent: automation-tracking-manager

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 00:47:29 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 1 Analysis Complete — 2026-04-13

Repository State

Open PRs: 257 (as of Day 102, 2026-04-12)
Critical bugs: 3 open (#7989, #7991, #7992)
Failing test scenarios: 8 (from UAT supervisor #8027)
Milestone completion: M3=28%, M4=46%, M5=40%, M6=17%, M7=35%

Agents Analyzed

implementation-pool-supervisor — 1121+ lines, well-documented with known failure modes fixed
implementation-worker — 1260+ lines, dual-mode (PR-fix + issue-impl)
pr-review-pool-supervisor — 802 lines, 2 bugs identified
pr-merge-pool-supervisor — 803 lines, well-structured
agent-evolution-pool-supervisor — 724 lines, this agent's own definition
system-watchdog-pool-supervisor — 2788 lines, comprehensive

Findings

Finding 1: PR Review Pool Supervisor — Missing Pagination (HIGH IMPACT)

Evidence: Line 299 of pr-review-pool-supervisor.md uses a single non-paginated API call. With 257 open PRs and Forgejo's 50-item page limit, the reviewer only sees ~19% of PRs.
Proposal: Issue #8030 created

Finding 2: PR Review Pool Supervisor — External PR Detection Bug (HIGH IMPACT)

Evidence: Line 319 of pr-review-pool-supervisor.md uses body text ("Closes #") to detect bot PRs, same bug that was fixed in implementation-pool-supervisor (documented failure mode 2026-04-12). Many valid HAL9000 PRs (docs, architecture, spec updates) don't contain "Closes #".
Proposal: Issue #8031 created

Proposals Created

Issue	Title	Status
#8030	Add pagination to pr-review-pool-supervisor	Awaiting human approval
#8031	Fix external PR detection in pr-review-pool-supervisor	Awaiting human approval

Workers Dispatched

None yet — awaiting proposal approvals before dispatching implementation workers.

Next Actions

Monitor #8030 and #8031 for human approval
Continue analysis of other agents in next cycle
Sleep 30 minutes before next cycle

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 1 Analysis Complete — 2026-04-13 ### Repository State - **Open PRs**: 257 (as of Day 102, 2026-04-12) - **Critical bugs**: 3 open (#7989, #7991, #7992) - **Failing test scenarios**: 8 (from UAT supervisor #8027) - **Milestone completion**: M3=28%, M4=46%, M5=40%, M6=17%, M7=35% ### Agents Analyzed - `implementation-pool-supervisor` — 1121+ lines, well-documented with known failure modes fixed - `implementation-worker` — 1260+ lines, dual-mode (PR-fix + issue-impl) - `pr-review-pool-supervisor` — 802 lines, **2 bugs identified** - `pr-merge-pool-supervisor` — 803 lines, well-structured - `agent-evolution-pool-supervisor` — 724 lines, this agent's own definition - `system-watchdog-pool-supervisor` — 2788 lines, comprehensive ### Findings #### Finding 1: PR Review Pool Supervisor — Missing Pagination (HIGH IMPACT) **Evidence**: Line 299 of `pr-review-pool-supervisor.md` uses a single non-paginated API call. With 257 open PRs and Forgejo's 50-item page limit, the reviewer only sees ~19% of PRs. **Proposal**: Issue #8030 created #### Finding 2: PR Review Pool Supervisor — External PR Detection Bug (HIGH IMPACT) **Evidence**: Line 319 of `pr-review-pool-supervisor.md` uses body text ("Closes #") to detect bot PRs, same bug that was fixed in `implementation-pool-supervisor` (documented failure mode 2026-04-12). Many valid HAL9000 PRs (docs, architecture, spec updates) don't contain "Closes #". **Proposal**: Issue #8031 created ### Proposals Created | Issue | Title | Status | |-------|-------|--------| | #8030 | Add pagination to pr-review-pool-supervisor | Awaiting human approval | | #8031 | Fix external PR detection in pr-review-pool-supervisor | Awaiting human approval | ### Workers Dispatched None yet — awaiting proposal approvals before dispatching implementation workers. ### Next Actions - Monitor #8030 and #8031 for human approval - Continue analysis of other agents in next cycle - Sleep 30 minutes before next cycle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-13 01:29:16 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 2 Analysis — 2026-04-13

Proposal Status Check

#8030 (pr-review-pool-supervisor pagination): Still open, no approval yet
#8031 (pr-review-pool-supervisor external PR detection): Still open, no approval yet

New Agents Analyzed This Cycle

pr-reviewer — 569 lines, well-structured, uses curl for reviewer-authenticated writes
backlog-grooming-pool-supervisor — 1295 lines, comprehensive
pr-ci-test-fixer — 345 lines, 1 new pattern identified
difficulty-evaluator — 202 lines, conservative approach, haiku model
issue-analyzer — 92 lines, read-only, haiku model
forgejo-label-manager — 309 lines, centralized label management
subtask-loop — 831 lines, progressive escalation (haiku→codex→sonnet→opus)

New Finding

Finding 3: pr-ci-test-fixer — Contradictory Clone Instructions (MEDIUM IMPACT)

Evidence: Lines 47-84 of pr-ci-test-fixer.md contain three contradictory statements:

"Use the provided working directory, do NOT create a new clone"
Shows a full clone creation code block
"If no directory provided, that's an error — exit"

The clone code block is shown but should never be executed. An LLM reading this may create unnecessary clones, wasting time and disk space.
Proposal: Issue #8048 created

Proposals Created This Cycle

Issue	Title	Status
#8048	Fix pr-ci-test-fixer contradictory clone instructions	Awaiting human approval

All Pending Proposals

Issue	Title	Status
#8030	Add pagination to pr-review-pool-supervisor	Awaiting human approval
#8031	Fix external PR detection in pr-review-pool-supervisor	Awaiting human approval
#8048	Fix pr-ci-test-fixer contradictory clone instructions	Awaiting human approval

Workers Dispatched

None — awaiting proposal approvals.

Next Cycle Plan

Continue monitoring proposals for approval
Analyze remaining agents: uat-test-pool-supervisor, bug-hunt-pool-supervisor, architecture-guard-pool-supervisor
Look for patterns in: model tier assignments, permission configurations, context management

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

## Cycle 2 Analysis — 2026-04-13 ### Proposal Status Check - **#8030** (pr-review-pool-supervisor pagination): Still open, no approval yet - **#8031** (pr-review-pool-supervisor external PR detection): Still open, no approval yet ### New Agents Analyzed This Cycle - `pr-reviewer` — 569 lines, well-structured, uses curl for reviewer-authenticated writes - `backlog-grooming-pool-supervisor` — 1295 lines, comprehensive - `pr-ci-test-fixer` — 345 lines, **1 new pattern identified** - `difficulty-evaluator` — 202 lines, conservative approach, haiku model - `issue-analyzer` — 92 lines, read-only, haiku model - `forgejo-label-manager` — 309 lines, centralized label management - `subtask-loop` — 831 lines, progressive escalation (haiku→codex→sonnet→opus) ### New Finding #### Finding 3: pr-ci-test-fixer — Contradictory Clone Instructions (MEDIUM IMPACT) **Evidence**: Lines 47-84 of `pr-ci-test-fixer.md` contain three contradictory statements: 1. "Use the provided working directory, do NOT create a new clone" 2. Shows a full clone creation code block 3. "If no directory provided, that's an error — exit" The clone code block is shown but should never be executed. An LLM reading this may create unnecessary clones, wasting time and disk space. **Proposal**: Issue #8048 created ### Proposals Created This Cycle | Issue | Title | Status | |-------|-------|--------| | #8048 | Fix pr-ci-test-fixer contradictory clone instructions | Awaiting human approval | ### All Pending Proposals | Issue | Title | Status | |-------|-------|--------| | #8030 | Add pagination to pr-review-pool-supervisor | Awaiting human approval | | #8031 | Fix external PR detection in pr-review-pool-supervisor | Awaiting human approval | | #8048 | Fix pr-ci-test-fixer contradictory clone instructions | Awaiting human approval | ### Workers Dispatched None — awaiting proposal approvals. ### Next Cycle Plan - Continue monitoring proposals for approval - Analyze remaining agents: `uat-test-pool-supervisor`, `bug-hunt-pool-supervisor`, `architecture-guard-pool-supervisor` - Look for patterns in: model tier assignments, permission configurations, context management --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Agent Evolution | Agent: agent-evolution-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-13 01:35:07 +00:00

[AUTO-WDOG] Status: System Watchdog Pool Supervisor - Tracking (Cycle 7) #8036

HAL9000 added the

Automation Tracking

label

2026-04-13 04:55:51 +00:00

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-13 04:56:28 +00:00

[AUTO-GROOM] Status: Grooming Pool Supervisor (Cycle 1) #8154