TDD: M4 validation integration test race condition test #635

Closed
opened 2026-03-07 23:05:53 +00:00 by freemo · 2 comments
Owner

Metadata

  • Commit Message: test(integration): add TDD failing tests for M4 validation race condition
  • Branch: tdd/m4-validation-race-condition

Parent

Bug: #563 — Racing condition in integration test for M4 validation

Background and Context

Per CONTRIBUTING.md TDD Bug Fix Workflow. Bug #563 root cause: M4 validation integration test intermittently fails due to database state leaking between parallel test runs. Test isolation is insufficient.

Note: TDD tests and fix already exist in PR #619 (opened by @brent.edwards). This issue is the formal tracking counterpart.

Acceptance Criteria

  • Behave BDD scenarios tagged @tdd_bug @tdd_bug_563 @tdd_expected_fail
  • Robot Framework integration smoke tests demonstrating race condition
  • Tests fail intermittently until bug #563 is fixed
  • Tests include both sequential and parallel execution modes

Dependencies

  • Blocked by: #627, #628 (TDD infrastructure)
  • Blocks: #563 (bug fix)

Definition of Done

TDD tests reproducing bug #563 are merged to master.

## Metadata - **Commit Message**: `test(integration): add TDD failing tests for M4 validation race condition` - **Branch**: `tdd/m4-validation-race-condition` ## Parent Bug: #563 — Racing condition in integration test for M4 validation ## Background and Context Per CONTRIBUTING.md TDD Bug Fix Workflow. Bug #563 root cause: M4 validation integration test intermittently fails due to database state leaking between parallel test runs. Test isolation is insufficient. **Note**: TDD tests and fix already exist in PR #619 (opened by @brent.edwards). This issue is the formal tracking counterpart. ## Acceptance Criteria - [ ] Behave BDD scenarios tagged `@tdd_bug @tdd_bug_563 @tdd_expected_fail` - [ ] Robot Framework integration smoke tests demonstrating race condition - [ ] Tests fail intermittently until bug #563 is fixed - [ ] Tests include both sequential and parallel execution modes ## Dependencies - Blocked by: #627, #628 (TDD infrastructure) - Blocks: #563 (bug fix) ## Definition of Done TDD tests reproducing bug #563 are merged to master.
freemo added this to the v3.3.0 milestone 2026-03-07 23:06:36 +00:00
Author
Owner

PM Note (Day 29) — Reassignment

Changes:

Rationale: This is a TDD test-writing issue (2 SP) for the M4 validation race condition bug (#563). Brent is the one fixing the bug itself (PR #619 on active branch fix/m4-validation-race-condition), but the TDD test that proves the bug exists can be written by anyone. Rui has capacity and this gives him direct involvement in the bug pipeline.

@hurui200320 — Write the failing TDD test that reproduces the race condition described in #563. Tag it with @wip for now (until #628 provides @tdd_expected_fail support). Coordinate with @brent.edwards on the exact reproduction conditions.

**PM Note (Day 29) — Reassignment** **Changes:** - **Assignee**: @brent.edwards → @hurui200320 **Rationale:** This is a TDD test-writing issue (2 SP) for the M4 validation race condition bug (#563). Brent is the one fixing the bug itself (PR #619 on active branch `fix/m4-validation-race-condition`), but the TDD test that proves the bug exists can be written by anyone. Rui has capacity and this gives him direct involvement in the bug pipeline. @hurui200320 — Write the failing TDD test that reproduces the race condition described in #563. Tag it with `@wip` for now (until #628 provides `@tdd_expected_fail` support). Coordinate with @brent.edwards on the exact reproduction conditions.
Author
Owner

PM Decision (Day 31): Closing as State/Wont Do.

Rationale: The parent bug #563 (M4 validation race condition) was already fixed by PR #619 (merged Day 30, @brent.edwards). The fix was applied without following TDD workflow — the bugfix PR merged before this TDD counterpart was started. Since the bug is resolved and verified, writing a retroactive TDD test provides no additional value.

No follow-up regression test issue will be created. The existing M4 integration test suite (PR #619) covers the race condition scenario.

Ref: CONTRIBUTING.md TDD workflow exception — bug already fixed before TDD test written.

**PM Decision (Day 31)**: Closing as `State/Wont Do`. **Rationale**: The parent bug #563 (M4 validation race condition) was already fixed by PR #619 (merged Day 30, @brent.edwards). The fix was applied without following TDD workflow — the bugfix PR merged before this TDD counterpart was started. Since the bug is resolved and verified, writing a retroactive TDD test provides no additional value. No follow-up regression test issue will be created. The existing M4 integration test suite (PR #619) covers the race condition scenario. Ref: CONTRIBUTING.md TDD workflow exception — bug already fixed before TDD test written.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#635
No description provided.