[AUTO-UAT-POOL] UAT Testing Report (Cycle 3) #6294

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 20:04:42 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 1 comment

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 20:04:42 +00:00

Owner

UAT Testing Pool Status — 2026-04-09

Agent: uat-tester (Pool Supervisor)
Instance ID: uat-pool-1
Cycle: 3
Master SHA: a8688d6be1
Status: Dispatching Workers

Feature Areas Being Tested This Cycle

From docs/specification.md, 8 workers dispatched across these areas:

Plan Lifecycle — Action→Strategize→Execute→Apply phases, states, transitions, decision tree
CLI Commands - Session — agents session create/list/show/delete/export/import/tell
CLI Commands - Project — agents project create/link-resource/unlink-resource/list/show/delete/context
CLI Commands - Actor — agents actor run/add/remove/list/show/context (list/show/clear)
Invariants & Automation Profiles — 4-tier precedence, non_overridable, 8 built-in profiles, safety profiles
ACMS & Context — UKO, CRP, context assembly pipeline, hot/warm/cold tiers, indexing
Resource System — ULID identity, DAG, physical/virtual, devcontainer auto-discovery
TUI Implementation — Textual app, persona system, slash commands, safety overlays

Previously Found Bugs (Open, from Cycle 2)

#6291 Devcontainer auto-discovery never registers children
#6289 subplan_parallel_spawn decisions run sequentially
#6287 ACMS indexing pipeline not wired into CLI
#6286 agents actor context missing list/show/clear commands
#6285 Project indexing_status field missing
#6284 ContextTierService never hydrated during plan execution
#6283 actor CLI ignores v3 Actor YAML schema
#6282 Skeleton context never propagates to child plans
#6281 agents plan apply JSON/YAML output wrong structure
#6280 agents plan cancel JSON/YAML output wrong structure
#6279 agents plan status JSON/YAML output wrong field names
#6278 agents plan list JSON/YAML output wrong field names
#6277 agents plan use JSON/YAML output wrong field names
#6276 Server-mode A2A HTTP transport is stub
#6275 _cleveragents/plan/diff always returns empty changes
#6274 CLI bypasses A2A protocol in local mode
#6270 agents project show omits Validations/Context/Indexing sections
#6269 agents session create --format json omits spec-required sections

Worker Dispatch Status

Worker	Feature Area	Status
W1	Plan Lifecycle	🚀 Dispatching
W2	CLI Commands - Session	🚀 Dispatching
W3	CLI Commands - Project	🚀 Dispatching
W4	CLI Commands - Actor	🚀 Dispatching
W5	Invariants & Automation Profiles	🚀 Dispatching
W6	ACMS & Context	🚀 Dispatching
W7	Resource System	🚀 Dispatching
W8	TUI Implementation	🚀 Dispatching

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

# UAT Testing Pool Status — 2026-04-09 **Agent**: uat-tester (Pool Supervisor) **Instance ID**: uat-pool-1 **Cycle**: 3 **Master SHA**: a8688d6be1d0b3d71a757ef6d3ebd240d2727680 **Status**: Dispatching Workers ## Feature Areas Being Tested This Cycle From `docs/specification.md`, 8 workers dispatched across these areas: 1. **Plan Lifecycle** — Action→Strategize→Execute→Apply phases, states, transitions, decision tree 2. **CLI Commands - Session** — `agents session create/list/show/delete/export/import/tell` 3. **CLI Commands - Project** — `agents project create/link-resource/unlink-resource/list/show/delete/context` 4. **CLI Commands - Actor** — `agents actor run/add/remove/list/show/context (list/show/clear)` 5. **Invariants & Automation Profiles** — 4-tier precedence, non_overridable, 8 built-in profiles, safety profiles 6. **ACMS & Context** — UKO, CRP, context assembly pipeline, hot/warm/cold tiers, indexing 7. **Resource System** — ULID identity, DAG, physical/virtual, devcontainer auto-discovery 8. **TUI Implementation** — Textual app, persona system, slash commands, safety overlays ## Previously Found Bugs (Open, from Cycle 2) - #6291 Devcontainer auto-discovery never registers children - #6289 subplan_parallel_spawn decisions run sequentially - #6287 ACMS indexing pipeline not wired into CLI - #6286 `agents actor context` missing list/show/clear commands - #6285 Project indexing_status field missing - #6284 ContextTierService never hydrated during plan execution - #6283 actor CLI ignores v3 Actor YAML schema - #6282 Skeleton context never propagates to child plans - #6281 `agents plan apply` JSON/YAML output wrong structure - #6280 `agents plan cancel` JSON/YAML output wrong structure - #6279 `agents plan status` JSON/YAML output wrong field names - #6278 `agents plan list` JSON/YAML output wrong field names - #6277 `agents plan use` JSON/YAML output wrong field names - #6276 Server-mode A2A HTTP transport is stub - #6275 `_cleveragents/plan/diff` always returns empty changes - #6274 CLI bypasses A2A protocol in local mode - #6270 `agents project show` omits Validations/Context/Indexing sections - #6269 `agents session create --format json` omits spec-required sections ## Worker Dispatch Status | Worker | Feature Area | Status | |--------|-------------|--------| | W1 | Plan Lifecycle | 🚀 Dispatching | | W2 | CLI Commands - Session | 🚀 Dispatching | | W3 | CLI Commands - Project | 🚀 Dispatching | | W4 | CLI Commands - Actor | 🚀 Dispatching | | W5 | Invariants & Automation Profiles | 🚀 Dispatching | | W6 | ACMS & Context | 🚀 Dispatching | | W7 | Resource System | 🚀 Dispatching | | W8 | TUI Implementation | 🚀 Dispatching | --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

HAL9000 added the

labels

2026-04-09 20:04:57 +00:00

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 20:18:09 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 3 — Worker Results Summary

Completed: 2026-04-09 | All 8 workers finished

Results by Worker

Worker	Feature Area	Tested	Bugs Filed	Issue Numbers
W1	Plan Lifecycle	20/20	6	#6318, #6321, #6325, #6328, #6340, #6344
W2	CLI Commands - Session	7/7	4	#6302, #6307, #6311, #6316
W3	CLI Commands - Project	10/10	8	#6301, #6304, #6308, #6310, #6314, #6319, #6323, #6327, #6332
W4	CLI Commands - Actor	11/11	6	#6303, #6306, #6309, #6312, #6315, #6320
W5	Invariants & Automation Profiles	10/10	4	#6331, #6336, #6341, #6345
W6	ACMS & Context	9/9	4	#6330, #6335, #6339, #6342
W7	Resource System	9/9	5	#6322, #6326, #6329, #6333, #6337
W8	TUI Implementation	19/19	6	#6347, #6348, #6350, #6354, #6357, #6358, #6361

Total Bugs Filed This Cycle: 43

Notable Critical Findings

#6329 (CRITICAL): agents resource remove checks wrong edge table — resources with active DAG links can be silently deleted
#6303 (HIGH): agents actor run is single-shot only — missing interactive mode, --project, and --session flags
#6322 (HIGH): agents resource add missing --url flag — git resource type unusable from CLI
#6335 (HIGH): Vector embeddings all [1.0] placeholder — semantic search strategies non-functional
#6342 (HIGH): Phase 1 multi-strategy fusion disabled — pipeline filters to single strategy
TUI: 15 of 19 v3.7.0 TUI deliverables are incomplete or absent

Next Cycle

Sleeping 60 seconds, then dispatching Cycle 4 workers for remaining feature areas:

Tool/Skill/Validation CLI commands
A2A Protocol (local/server mode)
Sandbox & Checkpoints
Correction Model
Output Format compliance
Config system
LSP integration
Action commands

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

# Cycle 3 — Worker Results Summary **Completed**: 2026-04-09 | All 8 workers finished ## Results by Worker | Worker | Feature Area | Tested | Bugs Filed | Issue Numbers | |--------|-------------|--------|-----------|---------------| | W1 | Plan Lifecycle | 20/20 | 6 | #6318, #6321, #6325, #6328, #6340, #6344 | | W2 | CLI Commands - Session | 7/7 | 4 | #6302, #6307, #6311, #6316 | | W3 | CLI Commands - Project | 10/10 | 8 | #6301, #6304, #6308, #6310, #6314, #6319, #6323, #6327, #6332 | | W4 | CLI Commands - Actor | 11/11 | 6 | #6303, #6306, #6309, #6312, #6315, #6320 | | W5 | Invariants & Automation Profiles | 10/10 | 4 | #6331, #6336, #6341, #6345 | | W6 | ACMS & Context | 9/9 | 4 | #6330, #6335, #6339, #6342 | | W7 | Resource System | 9/9 | 5 | #6322, #6326, #6329, #6333, #6337 | | W8 | TUI Implementation | 19/19 | 6 | #6347, #6348, #6350, #6354, #6357, #6358, #6361 | **Total Bugs Filed This Cycle: 43** ## Notable Critical Findings - **#6329** (CRITICAL): `agents resource remove` checks wrong edge table — resources with active DAG links can be silently deleted - **#6303** (HIGH): `agents actor run` is single-shot only — missing interactive mode, `--project`, and `--session` flags - **#6322** (HIGH): `agents resource add` missing `--url` flag — git resource type unusable from CLI - **#6335** (HIGH): Vector embeddings all `[1.0]` placeholder — semantic search strategies non-functional - **#6342** (HIGH): Phase 1 multi-strategy fusion disabled — pipeline filters to single strategy - **TUI**: 15 of 19 v3.7.0 TUI deliverables are incomplete or absent ## Next Cycle Sleeping 60 seconds, then dispatching Cycle 4 workers for remaining feature areas: - Tool/Skill/Validation CLI commands - A2A Protocol (local/server mode) - Sandbox & Checkpoints - Correction Model - Output Format compliance - Config system - LSP integration - Action commands --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: uat-tester

HAL9000 closed this issue

2026-04-10 02:00:12 +00:00