cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-WATCHDOG] System Health Report (Cycle 6) #5092

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 01:00:40 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 4 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:00:40 +00:00

Owner

System Health Report — Cycle 6 (Deep Introspection)

Supervisor: System Watchdog
Status: Active
Timestamp: 2026-04-09T01:03:00Z
Instance: watchdog-1
Reporting Period: Cycles 1-6 (~30 minutes)

🟡 Overall System Status: DEGRADED — Multiple Issues Active

Audit Results

🔴 Audit 0: Master CI Health — CRITICAL

Latest master commit 92f533dc — FAILING for 50+ minutes
Failing checks: lint, integration_tests, benchmark-publish, status-check
Passing checks: unit_tests, e2e_tests, typecheck, security, quality, build, helm
No new commits to master — no fix has been pushed yet
Alert issue created: #4996

✅ Audit 2: Branch Protection

Master branch protection: ACTIVE ✅
Status checks required: YES ✅
Push whitelist: freemo only ✅

🟡 Audit 3: Ticket State Integrity

Automation tracking issues correctly labeled
New UAT issues being labeled by human-liaison

✅ Audit 4: Priority and Milestone Ordering

No evidence of lower-milestone critical bugs being ignored

🔴 Audit 5: PR Pipeline Health

PR #4979 — CI FAILING (lint + integration_tests) — 80+ min old
PR #4932 — CI FAILING (lint + integration_tests) — 2+ hours old
PR #4830 — mergeable: false (merge conflict)
PR #4805 — mergeable: false (merge conflict)
New PR #5085 — just created, being reviewed
Reviewer pool very active: PRs 3473, 3478, 3480, 3551, 3554, 4217, 4453, 4932, 4979, 5007, 5085 all being reviewed

🟡 Audit 6: Supervisor Health

Active Supervisors (13/16):

Supervisor	Session	Status
implementor-pool	ses_2906630e4ffe	⚠️ COMPLETED (no workers dispatched)
reviewer-pool	ses_2906608daffe	✅ Active (many workers)
tester-pool	ses_29065efe1ffe	✅ Active
hunter-pool	ses_29044b480ffe	🔄 NEW SESSION (replacing dead Gemini one)
test-infra-pool	ses_29044df8dffe	🔄 NEW SESSION (replacing dead Gemini one)
architect	ses_29065a3e7ffe	✅ Active
epic-planner	ses_290658946ffe	✅ Active
human-liaison	ses_290657292ffe	✅ Active (labeling issues)
agent-evolver	ses_2906556beffe	✅ Active
arch-guard	ses_290653ee5ffe	❌ DEAD (Gemini 403)
spec-updater	ses_2906529c2ffe	✅ Active
backlog-groomer	ses_290651345ffe	✅ Active
docs-writer	ses_29064fca6ffe	✅ Active
timeline-updater	ses_29064e5aaffe	✅ Active
project-owner	ses_29064cf31ffe	✅ Active
system-watchdog	ses_29064b741ffe	✅ Active (this session)

Dead Supervisors (1/16):

[AUTO-GUARD] arch-guard — Gemini API 403 (no replacement yet)

Recovered Supervisors (2/16):

[AUTO-BUG-SUP] hunter-pool — NEW session spawned (ses_29044b480ffe)
[AUTO-INF-SUP] test-infra-pool — NEW session spawned (ses_29044df8dffe)

🔴 Audit 9: Test Infrastructure Health

SYSTEMIC: lint + integration_tests failing on master and all PRs
CI log fetchers actively investigating failures for PRs 4217, 3473, 4453, 4979
No fix has been pushed yet

✅ Audit 10: Improvement Generation

Automation tracking issues being created by all supervisors ✅
New tracking issues: #5010 (spec-updater), #4990 (implementor-pool)

✅ Audit 11: Automation Tracking Health

All active supervisors have recent tracking issues
No stalled automation tracking issues detected

✅ Audit 12: Session Spot-Check

No force_merge usage detected
No direct pushes to master detected
No type: ignore suppressions detected

Deep Session Introspection (Cycle 6)

Implementation Orchestrator Analysis

Status: COMPLETED without dispatching workers
Root cause: Tool access limitation (cannot use task tool to dispatch subagents)
Impact: No implementation work being done
Alert: Issue #5070 created

Reviewer Pool Analysis

Status: VERY ACTIVE — 11+ reviewer workers running simultaneously
PRs being reviewed: 3473, 3478, 3480, 3551, 3554, 4217, 4453, 4932, 4979, 5007, 5085
CI log fetchers: Multiple fetchers investigating failures
No policy violations detected: No force_merge, no direct pushes

UAT Pool Analysis

Status: ACTIVE — 8+ UAT workers running
Areas covered: CLI Commands, TUI Interactions, ACMS, Actor System, Sandbox, Projects, Tools, A2A Protocol, Configuration, Validation, Provider Registry
New UAT bugs being filed: System is finding spec deviations

Human Liaison Analysis

Status: ACTIVE — dispatching label managers for UAT issues
Recent activity: Labeled issues 4937, 4939, 4918; triaging UAT bugs

"Analyzing agent system performance" Session

Session: ses_290454980ffe — appears to be a product-builder analysis session
Status: Active, analyzing automation tracking issues and open PRs
Spawning: explore subagents to analyze PR status

Findings Summary

Severity	Count	Details
CRITICAL	1	Master CI failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) for 50+ min
HIGH	3	Implementation orchestrator non-functional; arch-guard dead (Gemini); PR pipeline blocked
MEDIUM	1	Required approvals=0 (should be 2)
LOW	1	Some PRs have merge conflicts

Actions Taken This Period

Created alert #4996 (master CI failure)
Created alert #5003 (Gemini API 403 — 3 supervisors dead)
Created alert #5070 (implementation orchestrator non-functional)
Posted CI failure warnings on PR #4979
Closed previous tracking issues #4968, #4993

System Recovery Progress

✅ hunter-pool: NEW session spawned (was dead due to Gemini API)
✅ test-infra-pool: NEW session spawned (was dead due to Gemini API)
⏳ arch-guard: Still dead (no replacement yet)
⏳ Master CI: Still failing (investigation in progress)
⏳ Implementation orchestrator: Needs tool access restoration

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog
Tracking Type: Health Report
Cycle: 6

## System Health Report — Cycle 6 (Deep Introspection) **Supervisor**: System Watchdog **Status**: Active **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T01:03:00Z **Instance**: watchdog-1 **Reporting Period**: Cycles 1-6 (~30 minutes) --- ## 🟡 Overall System Status: DEGRADED — Multiple Issues Active --- ## Audit Results ### 🔴 Audit 0: Master CI Health — CRITICAL - Latest master commit `92f533dc` — **FAILING** for 50+ minutes - Failing checks: `lint`, `integration_tests`, `benchmark-publish`, `status-check` - Passing checks: `unit_tests`, `e2e_tests`, `typecheck`, `security`, `quality`, `build`, `helm` - **No new commits to master** — no fix has been pushed yet - Alert issue created: #4996 ### ✅ Audit 2: Branch Protection - Master branch protection: **ACTIVE** ✅ - Status checks required: **YES** ✅ - Push whitelist: freemo only ✅ ### 🟡 Audit 3: Ticket State Integrity - Automation tracking issues correctly labeled - New UAT issues being labeled by human-liaison ### ✅ Audit 4: Priority and Milestone Ordering - No evidence of lower-milestone critical bugs being ignored ### 🔴 Audit 5: PR Pipeline Health - PR #4979 — CI FAILING (lint + integration_tests) — 80+ min old - PR #4932 — CI FAILING (lint + integration_tests) — 2+ hours old - PR #4830 — `mergeable: false` (merge conflict) - PR #4805 — `mergeable: false` (merge conflict) - New PR #5085 — just created, being reviewed - **Reviewer pool very active**: PRs 3473, 3478, 3480, 3551, 3554, 4217, 4453, 4932, 4979, 5007, 5085 all being reviewed ### 🟡 Audit 6: Supervisor Health **Active Supervisors (13/16):** | Supervisor | Session | Status | |-----------|---------|--------| | implementor-pool | ses_2906630e4ffe | ⚠️ COMPLETED (no workers dispatched) | | reviewer-pool | ses_2906608daffe | ✅ Active (many workers) | | tester-pool | ses_29065efe1ffe | ✅ Active | | hunter-pool | ses_29044b480ffe | 🔄 NEW SESSION (replacing dead Gemini one) | | test-infra-pool | ses_29044df8dffe | 🔄 NEW SESSION (replacing dead Gemini one) | | architect | ses_29065a3e7ffe | ✅ Active | | epic-planner | ses_290658946ffe | ✅ Active | | human-liaison | ses_290657292ffe | ✅ Active (labeling issues) | | agent-evolver | ses_2906556beffe | ✅ Active | | arch-guard | ses_290653ee5ffe | ❌ DEAD (Gemini 403) | | spec-updater | ses_2906529c2ffe | ✅ Active | | backlog-groomer | ses_290651345ffe | ✅ Active | | docs-writer | ses_29064fca6ffe | ✅ Active | | timeline-updater | ses_29064e5aaffe | ✅ Active | | project-owner | ses_29064cf31ffe | ✅ Active | | system-watchdog | ses_29064b741ffe | ✅ Active (this session) | **Dead Supervisors (1/16):** - `[AUTO-GUARD]` arch-guard — Gemini API 403 (no replacement yet) **Recovered Supervisors (2/16):** - `[AUTO-BUG-SUP]` hunter-pool — NEW session spawned (ses_29044b480ffe) - `[AUTO-INF-SUP]` test-infra-pool — NEW session spawned (ses_29044df8dffe) ### 🔴 Audit 9: Test Infrastructure Health - **SYSTEMIC**: lint + integration_tests failing on master and all PRs - CI log fetchers actively investigating failures for PRs 4217, 3473, 4453, 4979 - No fix has been pushed yet ### ✅ Audit 10: Improvement Generation - Automation tracking issues being created by all supervisors ✅ - New tracking issues: #5010 (spec-updater), #4990 (implementor-pool) ### ✅ Audit 11: Automation Tracking Health - All active supervisors have recent tracking issues - No stalled automation tracking issues detected ### ✅ Audit 12: Session Spot-Check - No force_merge usage detected - No direct pushes to master detected - No type: ignore suppressions detected --- ## Deep Session Introspection (Cycle 6) ### Implementation Orchestrator Analysis - **Status**: COMPLETED without dispatching workers - **Root cause**: Tool access limitation (cannot use `task` tool to dispatch subagents) - **Impact**: No implementation work being done - **Alert**: Issue #5070 created ### Reviewer Pool Analysis - **Status**: VERY ACTIVE — 11+ reviewer workers running simultaneously - **PRs being reviewed**: 3473, 3478, 3480, 3551, 3554, 4217, 4453, 4932, 4979, 5007, 5085 - **CI log fetchers**: Multiple fetchers investigating failures - **No policy violations detected**: No force_merge, no direct pushes ### UAT Pool Analysis - **Status**: ACTIVE — 8+ UAT workers running - **Areas covered**: CLI Commands, TUI Interactions, ACMS, Actor System, Sandbox, Projects, Tools, A2A Protocol, Configuration, Validation, Provider Registry - **New UAT bugs being filed**: System is finding spec deviations ### Human Liaison Analysis - **Status**: ACTIVE — dispatching label managers for UAT issues - **Recent activity**: Labeled issues 4937, 4939, 4918; triaging UAT bugs ### "Analyzing agent system performance" Session - **Session**: ses_290454980ffe — appears to be a product-builder analysis session - **Status**: Active, analyzing automation tracking issues and open PRs - **Spawning**: explore subagents to analyze PR status --- ## Findings Summary | Severity | Count | Details | |----------|-------|---------| | CRITICAL | 1 | Master CI failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) for 50+ min | | HIGH | 3 | Implementation orchestrator non-functional; arch-guard dead (Gemini); PR pipeline blocked | | MEDIUM | 1 | Required approvals=0 (should be 2) | | LOW | 1 | Some PRs have merge conflicts | --- ## Actions Taken This Period - Created alert #4996 (master CI failure) - Created alert #5003 (Gemini API 403 — 3 supervisors dead) - Created alert #5070 (implementation orchestrator non-functional) - Posted CI failure warnings on PR #4979 - Closed previous tracking issues #4968, #4993 --- ## System Recovery Progress - ✅ hunter-pool: NEW session spawned (was dead due to Gemini API) - ✅ test-infra-pool: NEW session spawned (was dead due to Gemini API) - ⏳ arch-guard: Still dead (no replacement yet) - ⏳ Master CI: Still failing (investigation in progress) - ⏳ Implementation orchestrator: Needs tool access restoration --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog **Tracking Type**: Health Report **Cycle**: 6

HAL9000 added the

labels

2026-04-09 01:00:44 +00:00

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:06:27 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 7 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T01:08:00Z

Key Findings

Gemini API Failure Persists:

New hunter-pool session (ses_29044b480ffe) — ❌ DEAD (Gemini 403)
New test-infra-pool session (ses_29044df8dffe) — ❌ DEAD (Gemini 403)
Product-builder restarted these agents but they immediately fail again
This will keep happening until Gemini API access is restored or agents are reconfigured

Master CI:

Still at commit 92f533dc — no new commits
CI failures persist (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish)

Positive:

New reviewer worker spawned for PR-3390
System continues to be very active with CI log investigation
"Analyzing agent system performance" session still active

Persistent Issues

🔴 3 supervisors dead (arch-guard, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool) — Gemini API 403
🔴 Master CI failing for 60+ minutes
🔴 Implementation orchestrator completed without dispatching workers

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 7 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T01:08:00Z ### Key Findings **Gemini API Failure Persists:** - New hunter-pool session (ses_29044b480ffe) — ❌ DEAD (Gemini 403) - New test-infra-pool session (ses_29044df8dffe) — ❌ DEAD (Gemini 403) - Product-builder restarted these agents but they immediately fail again - This will keep happening until Gemini API access is restored or agents are reconfigured **Master CI:** - Still at commit `92f533dc` — no new commits - CI failures persist (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) **Positive:** - New reviewer worker spawned for PR-3390 - System continues to be very active with CI log investigation - "Analyzing agent system performance" session still active ### Persistent Issues - 🔴 3 supervisors dead (arch-guard, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool) — Gemini API 403 - 🔴 Master CI failing for 60+ minutes - 🔴 Implementation orchestrator completed without dispatching workers --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:11:59 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 8 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T01:13:00Z

Status

Master CI: Still failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 70+ minutes
No new commits to master
PR #5085: Timeline update (docs only) — being reviewed
System active: reviewer workers, CI log fetchers, UAT workers all running

No New Critical Findings This Cycle

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 8 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T01:13:00Z ### Status - Master CI: Still failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 70+ minutes - No new commits to master - PR #5085: Timeline update (docs only) — being reviewed - System active: reviewer workers, CI log fetchers, UAT workers all running ### No New Critical Findings This Cycle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:23:07 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 10 Update

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T01:28:00Z

Status

Master CI: Still failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 90+ minutes
No new commits to master
Backlog groomer very active: 80+ label fixes applied (issue #5130)
All active supervisors running normally

No New Critical Findings This Cycle

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 10 Update **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T01:28:00Z ### Status - Master CI: Still failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 90+ minutes - No new commits to master - Backlog groomer very active: 80+ label fixes applied (issue #5130) - All active supervisors running normally ### No New Critical Findings This Cycle --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:33:53 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 12 Update — Closing This Tracking Issue

Timestamp: 2026-04-09T01:38:00Z

This tracking issue (Cycle 6) is being closed as Cycle 12 begins. A new comprehensive health report will be created.

Summary of Cycles 6-12

🔴 Master CI failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 110+ minutes, no fix pushed
🔴 3 supervisors dead (arch-guard, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool) — Gemini API 403 (persistent)
🔴 Implementation orchestrator completed without dispatching workers (tool access limitation)
✅ All other 13 supervisors active and working
✅ Backlog groomer: 80+ label fixes applied
✅ Reviewer pool: 15+ PRs being reviewed simultaneously
✅ UAT pool: 10+ feature areas being tested
✅ No policy violations detected (no force_merge, no direct pushes)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

## Cycle 12 Update — Closing This Tracking Issue **Timestamp**: 2026-04-09T01:38:00Z This tracking issue (Cycle 6) is being closed as Cycle 12 begins. A new comprehensive health report will be created. ### Summary of Cycles 6-12 - 🔴 Master CI failing (lint + integration_tests + benchmark-publish) — 110+ minutes, no fix pushed - 🔴 3 supervisors dead (arch-guard, hunter-pool, test-infra-pool) — Gemini API 403 (persistent) - 🔴 Implementation orchestrator completed without dispatching workers (tool access limitation) - ✅ All other 13 supervisors active and working - ✅ Backlog groomer: 80+ label fixes applied - ✅ Reviewer pool: 15+ PRs being reviewed simultaneously - ✅ UAT pool: 10+ feature areas being tested - ✅ No policy violations detected (no force_merge, no direct pushes) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: System Watchdog | Agent: system-watchdog

HAL9000 closed this issue

2026-04-09 01:34:03 +00:00

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-09 01:34:27 +00:00

[AUTO-WATCHDOG] System Health Report (Cycle 12) #5137

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-09 02:08:40 +00:00

[AUTO-WATCHDOG] System Health Report (Cycle 18) #5150