cleveragents/cleveragents-core

Fork 3

[AUTO-ARCHITECT] Architecture Supervisor Status (Cycle 1) #4994

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-04-09 00:21:14 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 3 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 00:21:14 +00:00

Owner

Architecture Supervisor Session Started

Session Info:

Started: 2026-04-09
Instance ID: architect-1
Agent: architect (continuous supervisor)
Product Vision: Complete milestones v3.2.0 through v3.7.0 to production-ready state

Current Status: 🔄 In Progress

Initial Assessment

Specification Status

The existing docs/specification.md is 47,039 lines / 3.1 MB — comprehensive and covers all target milestones.

Milestone	State	Open Issues	Closed Issues	Spec Coverage
v3.0.0	✅ closed	0	163	✅ Complete
v3.1.0	✅ closed	0	108	✅ Complete
v3.2.0	🔄 open	86	235	✅ Complete
v3.3.0	🔄 open	71	108	✅ Complete
v3.4.0	🔄 open	56	130	✅ Complete
v3.5.0	🔄 open	505	188	✅ Complete
v3.6.0	🔄 open	162	150	✅ Complete
v3.7.0	🔄 open	461	403	✅ Complete

Issues Identified

Implementation Bugs (spec is correct, code needs fixing):

#4589 — Invariant precedence 3-tier vs spec-required 4-tier (plan > action > project > global)
#4560 — ContextStrategy protocol mismatch in acms_service.py

Spec Corrections Needed (minor clarifications):

#4600 — TUI shell safety: add CRITICAL danger level, update pattern table
#4523 — SandboxStrategy → SandboxStrategyProtocol, write() return type, registration config keys
#4382 — validation attach args format, SemanticEmbeddingStrategy v1 note, SpecStrategyAdapter doc
#4554 — Skill YAML format: remove skill: wrapper, fix agent_skills_dirs → agent_skill_folders

Major Structural Change (requires human approval):

#4807 — Restructure monolithic spec into docs/specification/ directory

Reference Doc Update (not specification.md):

#3675 — ACMS reference doc v1 Known Limitations table outdated

Actions Planned

Assess existing specification completeness
Comment on implementation bug issues (#4589, #4560) — spec is authoritative
Create spec corrections PR (minor corrections from #4600, #4523, #4382, #4554)
Comment on #4807 (structural split proposal)
Comment on #3675 (reference doc update)
Enter continuous polling loop (30-minute cycles)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architect (Instance: architect-1)

## Architecture Supervisor Session Started **Session Info:** - Started: 2026-04-09 - Instance ID: architect-1 - Agent: architect (continuous supervisor) - Product Vision: Complete milestones v3.2.0 through v3.7.0 to production-ready state ## Current Status: 🔄 In Progress ## Initial Assessment ### Specification Status The existing `docs/specification.md` is **47,039 lines / 3.1 MB** — comprehensive and covers all target milestones. | Milestone | State | Open Issues | Closed Issues | Spec Coverage | |-----------|-------|-------------|---------------|---------------| | v3.0.0 | ✅ closed | 0 | 163 | ✅ Complete | | v3.1.0 | ✅ closed | 0 | 108 | ✅ Complete | | v3.2.0 | 🔄 open | 86 | 235 | ✅ Complete | | v3.3.0 | 🔄 open | 71 | 108 | ✅ Complete | | v3.4.0 | 🔄 open | 56 | 130 | ✅ Complete | | v3.5.0 | 🔄 open | 505 | 188 | ✅ Complete | | v3.6.0 | 🔄 open | 162 | 150 | ✅ Complete | | v3.7.0 | 🔄 open | 461 | 403 | ✅ Complete | ### Issues Identified **Implementation Bugs (spec is correct, code needs fixing):** - #4589 — Invariant precedence 3-tier vs spec-required 4-tier (plan > action > project > global) - #4560 — ContextStrategy protocol mismatch in acms_service.py **Spec Corrections Needed (minor clarifications):** - #4600 — TUI shell safety: add CRITICAL danger level, update pattern table - #4523 — SandboxStrategy → SandboxStrategyProtocol, write() return type, registration config keys - #4382 — validation attach args format, SemanticEmbeddingStrategy v1 note, SpecStrategyAdapter doc - #4554 — Skill YAML format: remove `skill:` wrapper, fix `agent_skills_dirs` → `agent_skill_folders` **Major Structural Change (requires human approval):** - #4807 — Restructure monolithic spec into docs/specification/ directory **Reference Doc Update (not specification.md):** - #3675 — ACMS reference doc v1 Known Limitations table outdated ## Actions Planned - [x] Assess existing specification completeness - [ ] Comment on implementation bug issues (#4589, #4560) — spec is authoritative - [ ] Create spec corrections PR (minor corrections from #4600, #4523, #4382, #4554) - [ ] Comment on #4807 (structural split proposal) - [ ] Comment on #3675 (reference doc update) - [ ] Enter continuous polling loop (30-minute cycles) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architect (Instance: architect-1)

HAL9000 added the

labels

2026-04-09 00:21:31 +00:00

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 00:50:12 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 1 Work Complete

Actions Taken

✅ Assessed existing specification — 47,039 lines, comprehensive coverage of all milestones v3.2.0–v3.7.0

✅ Commented on implementation bug #4589 — Confirmed spec is correct (4-tier invariant precedence). Implementation must be fixed.

✅ Commented on implementation bug #4560 — Confirmed spec is correct (ContextStrategy protocol). Implementation must consolidate protocols.

✅ Commented on #4807 (structural split proposal) — Assessed as valid but requires human approval. Awaiting @freemo decision.

✅ Commented on #3675 (ACMS reference doc) — Included in spec corrections PR.

✅ Created spec corrections PR #5035 — spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1 branch with needs feedback label:

Invariant precedence pseudocode fix (plan > action > project > global)
TUI shell safety: CRITICAL danger level added
SandboxStrategyProtocol name, write() return type, registration config keys
Validation attach --key value format
SemanticEmbeddingStrategy v1 implementation note
SpecStrategyAdapter documentation
Skill YAML: removed skill: wrapper, fixed agent_skills_dirs → agent_skill_folders
ACMS reference doc: resolved v1 limitations removed, strategy interface updated

Next Cycle

Entering 30-minute polling loop. Will check for:

New issues requesting architectural clarification
Comments on PR #5035 or issue #4807 requiring response
New milestones without spec coverage
Human approval of #4807 (structural split)

Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09

## Cycle 1 Work Complete ### Actions Taken ✅ **Assessed existing specification** — 47,039 lines, comprehensive coverage of all milestones v3.2.0–v3.7.0 ✅ **Commented on implementation bug #4589** — Confirmed spec is correct (4-tier invariant precedence). Implementation must be fixed. ✅ **Commented on implementation bug #4560** — Confirmed spec is correct (ContextStrategy protocol). Implementation must consolidate protocols. ✅ **Commented on #4807** (structural split proposal) — Assessed as valid but requires human approval. Awaiting @freemo decision. ✅ **Commented on #3675** (ACMS reference doc) — Included in spec corrections PR. ✅ **Created spec corrections PR #5035** — `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1` branch with `needs feedback` label: - Invariant precedence pseudocode fix (plan > action > project > global) - TUI shell safety: CRITICAL danger level added - SandboxStrategyProtocol name, write() return type, registration config keys - Validation attach --key value format - SemanticEmbeddingStrategy v1 implementation note - SpecStrategyAdapter documentation - Skill YAML: removed skill: wrapper, fixed agent_skills_dirs → agent_skill_folders - ACMS reference doc: resolved v1 limitations removed, strategy interface updated ### Next Cycle Entering 30-minute polling loop. Will check for: - New issues requesting architectural clarification - Comments on PR #5035 or issue #4807 requiring response - New milestones without spec coverage - Human approval of #4807 (structural split) --- *Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09*

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:24:36 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 2 Work Complete

Actions Taken (Cycle 2)

✅ Commented on #4596 (agents plan revert/resume) — Spec needs to document both commands; implementation is correct

✅ Commented on #4569 (ShellSafetyService blocking) — Spec is correct; implementation must not block commands (advisory only)

✅ Commented on #4911 (correction_attempts DDL) — Spec has internal inconsistency; original_subtree_snapshot field should be added to both DDLs and implementation

✅ Created spec corrections PR #5133 — spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2 branch with needs feedback label:

agents plan revert and agents plan resume documented in command reference
correction_attempts DDL aligned between early and late spec sections
original_subtree_snapshot field added to both DDL definitions

Open PRs Awaiting Human Review

PR	Branch	Status	Summary
#5035	`spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1`	Open (needs feedback)	8 corrections: invariant precedence, TUI shell safety, sandbox protocol, validation args, ACMS strategy
#5133	`spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2`	Open (needs feedback)	2 corrections: plan revert/resume commands, correction_attempts DDL

Open Structural Change Awaiting Human Approval

Issue	Summary	Status
#4807	Restructure spec into docs/specification/ directory	Awaiting @freemo approval

Next Cycle

Entering 30-minute polling loop. Will check for:

New issues requesting architectural clarification
Comments on PRs #5035, #5133 requiring response
Human approval of #4807 (structural split)
New milestones without spec coverage

Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09

## Cycle 2 Work Complete ### Actions Taken (Cycle 2) ✅ **Commented on #4596** (`agents plan revert`/`resume`) — Spec needs to document both commands; implementation is correct ✅ **Commented on #4569** (`ShellSafetyService` blocking) — Spec is correct; implementation must not block commands (advisory only) ✅ **Commented on #4911** (`correction_attempts` DDL) — Spec has internal inconsistency; `original_subtree_snapshot` field should be added to both DDLs and implementation ✅ **Created spec corrections PR #5133** — `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2` branch with `needs feedback` label: - `agents plan revert` and `agents plan resume` documented in command reference - `correction_attempts` DDL aligned between early and late spec sections - `original_subtree_snapshot` field added to both DDL definitions ### Open PRs Awaiting Human Review | PR | Branch | Status | Summary | |----|--------|--------|---------| | #5035 | `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1` | Open (needs feedback) | 8 corrections: invariant precedence, TUI shell safety, sandbox protocol, validation args, ACMS strategy | | #5133 | `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2` | Open (needs feedback) | 2 corrections: plan revert/resume commands, correction_attempts DDL | ### Open Structural Change Awaiting Human Approval | Issue | Summary | Status | |-------|---------|--------| | #4807 | Restructure spec into docs/specification/ directory | Awaiting @freemo approval | ### Next Cycle Entering 30-minute polling loop. Will check for: - New issues requesting architectural clarification - Comments on PRs #5035, #5133 requiring response - Human approval of #4807 (structural split) - New milestones without spec coverage --- *Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09*

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-09 01:56:01 +00:00

Author

Owner

Cycle 3 Work Complete

Actions Taken (Cycle 3)

✅ Commented on #5109 (A2A task lifecycle operations missing) — Spec is correct; implementation gap in v3.5.0. Provided implementation path for Task domain model and handler implementations.

✅ Commented on #5114 (LspToolAdapter server-specific tool names) — Spec is correct; fix is lsp/{suffix} not {config.name}/{suffix}. v3.6.0 deliverable.

✅ Commented on #5108 (LSP server config field name mismatch) — Spec formal JSON schema is authoritative. Implementation must use init_options, add root_path and health_check. Will add workspace_settings to spec in next PR.

✅ Commented on #5112 (A2aEvent generic data dict) — Spec is correct; typed TaskStatusUpdateEvent/TaskArtifactUpdateEvent models required. Related to #5109.

Open PRs Awaiting Human Review

PR	Branch	Status	Summary
#5035	`spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1`	Open (needs feedback)	8 corrections
#5133	`spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2`	Open (needs feedback)	2 corrections

Pending Spec Corrections (Cycle 4)

LSP server config: align informal YAML example with formal JSON schema; add workspace_settings to schema
Any new issues discovered in next poll

Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09

## Cycle 3 Work Complete ### Actions Taken (Cycle 3) ✅ **Commented on #5109** (A2A task lifecycle operations missing) — Spec is correct; implementation gap in v3.5.0. Provided implementation path for Task domain model and handler implementations. ✅ **Commented on #5114** (LspToolAdapter server-specific tool names) — Spec is correct; fix is `lsp/{suffix}` not `{config.name}/{suffix}`. v3.6.0 deliverable. ✅ **Commented on #5108** (LSP server config field name mismatch) — Spec formal JSON schema is authoritative. Implementation must use `init_options`, add `root_path` and `health_check`. Will add `workspace_settings` to spec in next PR. ✅ **Commented on #5112** (A2aEvent generic data dict) — Spec is correct; typed `TaskStatusUpdateEvent`/`TaskArtifactUpdateEvent` models required. Related to #5109. ### Open PRs Awaiting Human Review | PR | Branch | Status | Summary | |----|--------|--------|---------| | #5035 | `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle1` | Open (needs feedback) | 8 corrections | | #5133 | `spec/architecture-corrections-cycle2` | Open (needs feedback) | 2 corrections | ### Pending Spec Corrections (Cycle 4) - LSP server config: align informal YAML example with formal JSON schema; add `workspace_settings` to schema - Any new issues discovered in next poll --- *Architecture Supervisor (architect-1) — 2026-04-09*

HAL9000 added the

Automation Tracking

label

2026-04-09 02:57:00 +00:00

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-09 02:58:50 +00:00

[AUTO-GROOMER] Backlog Grooming Report (Cycle 16) #5173