UAT: Specification Workflow Examples 1, 9, 10, 11, 13, and 15 have no Robot Framework integration tests #4072

New issue

Open

opened 2026-04-06 09:56:31 +00:00 by freemo · 0 comments

freemo commented

2026-04-06 09:56:31 +00:00

Owner

Metadata

Branch: feat/integration-tests-missing-workflows
Commit Message: test(robot): add integration tests for workflow examples 1, 9, 10, 11, 13, 15
Milestone: (none — backlog)
Parent Epic: (Integration Testing Epic)

Background and Context

CONTRIBUTING.md (line 53–54) states:

Multi-Level Testing Mandate: Every coding task must include or update tests at multiple levels: unit tests, integration tests, and performance benchmarks. Testing is non-optional and is part of the definition of done for any task.

The specification (docs/specification.md) defines 18 workflow examples (Examples 1–18) that represent the primary user-facing workflows. Each workflow example should have a corresponding Robot Framework integration test to verify the end-to-end behavior.

What Was Tested

Cross-reference of all 18 workflow examples in docs/specification.md against the robot/ directory for corresponding integration test files.

Expected Behavior

All 18 workflow examples defined in the specification should have corresponding Robot Framework integration tests in the robot/ directory.

Actual Behavior

6 out of 18 workflow examples (33%) have NO integration tests at all:

Example	Title	Integration Test	Status
Example 1	Hello World — Fix a Single Bug	None	❌ MISSING
Example 2	Automated Test Generation	`robot/wf02_test_generation_integration.robot`	✅
Example 3	Multi-File Refactoring with Invariants	None	❌ MISSING
Example 4	Multi-Project Dependency Update	`robot/wf04_multi_project_dependency.robot`	✅
Example 5	Database Schema Migration	`robot/int_wf05_db_migration.robot`	✅
Example 6	Writing Technical Documentation	`robot/int_wf06_doc_generation.robot`	✅
Example 7	CI/CD Integration	`robot/wf07_cicd_integration.robot`	✅
Example 8	Cloud Infrastructure Management	`robot/wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.robot`	✅
Example 9	Session-Driven Interactive Exploration	None	❌ MISSING
Example 10	Full-Auto Batch Operations	None	❌ MISSING
Example 11	Complex Graph Actor for Multi-Stage Code Review	None	❌ MISSING
Example 12	Large-Scale Feature Implementation	`robot/large_project_decompose.robot`	✅
Example 13	Custom Automation Profile with Semantic Escalation	None	❌ MISSING
Example 14	Server Mode — Team Collaboration	`robot/wf14_server_mode_integration.robot`	✅
Example 15	Disaster Recovery — Rollback a Failed Apply	None	❌ MISSING
Example 16	Devcontainer-Driven Development	`robot/devcontainer_lifecycle.robot`	✅
Example 17	Explicit Container with Directory Mount	`robot/e2e/wf17_explicit_container.robot`	✅
Example 18	Container with Remote Repo Clone	`robot/e2e/wf18_container_clone.robot`	✅

Missing Workflow Details

Example 1: Hello World — Fix a Single Bug

The most fundamental workflow: agents init → resource add git-checkout → project create → validation add → action create → plan use → plan execute → plan diff → plan apply
This is the primary "getting started" workflow and has NO integration test
Critical because it exercises the complete plan lifecycle with a real git repository resource

Example 3: Multi-File Refactoring with Invariants

Exercises invariant registration, invariant checking during plan execution, and correction flows
No integration test exists for the invariant-gated workflow

Example 9: Session-Driven Interactive Exploration

Exercises agents session create, agents session list, agents session show, and session-based plan execution
No integration test exists for session management workflows

Example 10: Full-Auto Batch Operations

Exercises the trusted automation profile for fully automated plan execution without human approval
No integration test exists for the trusted/full-auto automation profile workflow

Example 11: Complex Graph Actor for Multi-Stage Code Review

Exercises custom actor configuration with graph-based execution
No integration test exists for complex actor workflows

Example 13: Custom Automation Profile with Semantic Escalation

Exercises custom automation profile creation and semantic escalation triggers
No integration test exists for custom automation profile workflows

Example 15: Disaster Recovery — Rollback a Failed Apply

Exercises agents plan rollback with a checkpoint ID to revert a failed apply
No integration test exists for the rollback/disaster recovery workflow
This is particularly critical given the existing bug #4068 about plan rollback accepting missing CHECKPOINT_ID

Impact

Without integration tests for these workflows:

Regressions in these critical user workflows go undetected until they reach production
The agents init command (Example 1) has no integration test — the most basic user action
Session management (Example 9) has no integration test
The rollback/disaster recovery workflow (Example 15) has no integration test, which is especially concerning given the existing rollback bug

Subtasks

Create robot/wf01_hello_world.robot + robot/helper_wf01_hello_world.py for Example 1 (init → resource → project → validation → action → plan lifecycle)
Create robot/wf03_refactoring_invariants.robot + helper for Example 3 (invariant-gated refactoring)
Create robot/wf09_session_exploration.robot + helper for Example 9 (session create/list/show/use)
Create robot/wf10_full_auto_batch.robot + helper for Example 10 (trusted automation profile)
Create robot/wf11_graph_actor_review.robot + helper for Example 11 (complex graph actor)
Create robot/wf13_custom_automation_profile.robot + helper for Example 13 (custom profile + semantic escalation)
Create robot/wf15_disaster_recovery.robot + helper for Example 15 (plan rollback)
All new integration tests must use real services (no mocks) per CONTRIBUTING.md
Run nox -s integration_tests to verify all new tests pass

Definition of Done

All 18 workflow examples have corresponding Robot Framework integration tests
All new tests use real CLI subprocess invocations with real SQLite database
nox -s integration_tests passes
Coverage >= 97%

Supporting Information

Spec reference: docs/specification.md lines 36260–46597 (Workflow Examples section)
Correct pattern: robot/helper_m1_e2e_verification.py — uses run_cli() with real subprocess and real database
Related bug: #4068 — agents plan rollback missing CHECKPOINT_ID validation (Example 15 would catch this)

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

## Metadata - **Branch**: `feat/integration-tests-missing-workflows` - **Commit Message**: `test(robot): add integration tests for workflow examples 1, 9, 10, 11, 13, 15` - **Milestone**: (none — backlog) - **Parent Epic**: (Integration Testing Epic) ## Background and Context `CONTRIBUTING.md` (line 53–54) states: > **Multi-Level Testing Mandate:** Every coding task must include or update tests at multiple levels: unit tests, integration tests, and performance benchmarks. Testing is non-optional and is part of the definition of done for any task. The specification (`docs/specification.md`) defines 18 workflow examples (Examples 1–18) that represent the primary user-facing workflows. Each workflow example should have a corresponding Robot Framework integration test to verify the end-to-end behavior. ## What Was Tested Cross-reference of all 18 workflow examples in `docs/specification.md` against the `robot/` directory for corresponding integration test files. ## Expected Behavior All 18 workflow examples defined in the specification should have corresponding Robot Framework integration tests in the `robot/` directory. ## Actual Behavior **6 out of 18 workflow examples (33%) have NO integration tests at all:** | Example | Title | Integration Test | Status | |---------|-------|-----------------|--------| | Example 1 | Hello World — Fix a Single Bug | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 2 | Automated Test Generation | `robot/wf02_test_generation_integration.robot` | ✅ | | Example 3 | Multi-File Refactoring with Invariants | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 4 | Multi-Project Dependency Update | `robot/wf04_multi_project_dependency.robot` | ✅ | | Example 5 | Database Schema Migration | `robot/int_wf05_db_migration.robot` | ✅ | | Example 6 | Writing Technical Documentation | `robot/int_wf06_doc_generation.robot` | ✅ | | Example 7 | CI/CD Integration | `robot/wf07_cicd_integration.robot` | ✅ | | Example 8 | Cloud Infrastructure Management | `robot/wf08_cloud_infra_supervised.robot` | ✅ | | Example 9 | Session-Driven Interactive Exploration | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 10 | Full-Auto Batch Operations | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 11 | Complex Graph Actor for Multi-Stage Code Review | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 12 | Large-Scale Feature Implementation | `robot/large_project_decompose.robot` | ✅ | | Example 13 | Custom Automation Profile with Semantic Escalation | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 14 | Server Mode — Team Collaboration | `robot/wf14_server_mode_integration.robot` | ✅ | | Example 15 | Disaster Recovery — Rollback a Failed Apply | None | ❌ MISSING | | Example 16 | Devcontainer-Driven Development | `robot/devcontainer_lifecycle.robot` | ✅ | | Example 17 | Explicit Container with Directory Mount | `robot/e2e/wf17_explicit_container.robot` | ✅ | | Example 18 | Container with Remote Repo Clone | `robot/e2e/wf18_container_clone.robot` | ✅ | ### Missing Workflow Details **Example 1: Hello World — Fix a Single Bug** - The most fundamental workflow: `agents init` → `resource add git-checkout` → `project create` → `validation add` → `action create` → `plan use` → `plan execute` → `plan diff` → `plan apply` - This is the primary "getting started" workflow and has NO integration test - Critical because it exercises the complete plan lifecycle with a real git repository resource **Example 3: Multi-File Refactoring with Invariants** - Exercises invariant registration, invariant checking during plan execution, and correction flows - No integration test exists for the invariant-gated workflow **Example 9: Session-Driven Interactive Exploration** - Exercises `agents session create`, `agents session list`, `agents session show`, and session-based plan execution - No integration test exists for session management workflows **Example 10: Full-Auto Batch Operations** - Exercises the `trusted` automation profile for fully automated plan execution without human approval - No integration test exists for the trusted/full-auto automation profile workflow **Example 11: Complex Graph Actor for Multi-Stage Code Review** - Exercises custom actor configuration with graph-based execution - No integration test exists for complex actor workflows **Example 13: Custom Automation Profile with Semantic Escalation** - Exercises custom automation profile creation and semantic escalation triggers - No integration test exists for custom automation profile workflows **Example 15: Disaster Recovery — Rollback a Failed Apply** - Exercises `agents plan rollback` with a checkpoint ID to revert a failed apply - No integration test exists for the rollback/disaster recovery workflow - This is particularly critical given the existing bug #4068 about `plan rollback` accepting missing CHECKPOINT_ID ## Impact Without integration tests for these workflows: - Regressions in these critical user workflows go undetected until they reach production - The `agents init` command (Example 1) has no integration test — the most basic user action - Session management (Example 9) has no integration test - The rollback/disaster recovery workflow (Example 15) has no integration test, which is especially concerning given the existing rollback bug ## Subtasks - [ ] Create `robot/wf01_hello_world.robot` + `robot/helper_wf01_hello_world.py` for Example 1 (init → resource → project → validation → action → plan lifecycle) - [ ] Create `robot/wf03_refactoring_invariants.robot` + helper for Example 3 (invariant-gated refactoring) - [ ] Create `robot/wf09_session_exploration.robot` + helper for Example 9 (session create/list/show/use) - [ ] Create `robot/wf10_full_auto_batch.robot` + helper for Example 10 (trusted automation profile) - [ ] Create `robot/wf11_graph_actor_review.robot` + helper for Example 11 (complex graph actor) - [ ] Create `robot/wf13_custom_automation_profile.robot` + helper for Example 13 (custom profile + semantic escalation) - [ ] Create `robot/wf15_disaster_recovery.robot` + helper for Example 15 (plan rollback) - [ ] All new integration tests must use real services (no mocks) per CONTRIBUTING.md - [ ] Run `nox -s integration_tests` to verify all new tests pass ## Definition of Done - [ ] All 18 workflow examples have corresponding Robot Framework integration tests - [ ] All new tests use real CLI subprocess invocations with real SQLite database - [ ] `nox -s integration_tests` passes - [ ] Coverage >= 97% ## Supporting Information - **Spec reference**: `docs/specification.md` lines 36260–46597 (Workflow Examples section) - **Correct pattern**: `robot/helper_m1_e2e_verification.py` — uses `run_cli()` with real subprocess and real database - **Related bug**: #4068 — `agents plan rollback` missing CHECKPOINT_ID validation (Example 15 would catch this) --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

freemo referenced this issue

2026-04-06 09:57:43 +00:00

[Automated] CleverAgents Build Session - 2026-04-06 #3775

freemo referenced this issue

2026-04-06 10:15:25 +00:00

[Automated] CleverAgents Build Session - 2026-04-06 #3775

freemo referenced this issue

2026-04-06 10:35:53 +00:00

[Automated] CleverAgents Build Session - 2026-04-06 #3775