[CA-AUTO] UAT Pool Supervisor — PR #2629 Validation — Session Tracker #2752

Open
opened 2026-04-04 19:08:10 +00:00 by freemo · 3 comments
Owner

UAT Pool Supervisor — Session Tracker

This issue tracks the UAT pool supervisor session for PR #2629 validation (Issue #2597).

All progress reports will be posted as comments here. Do NOT close this issue manually — it will be closed automatically when the session completes.


Session Context

  • Instance ID: uat-pool-1
  • Priority: CRITICAL — PR #2629 is the highest-priority PR in the project; all other development is blocked until it merges
  • PR: #2629fix(ci): restore all CI quality gates to passing on master
  • Issue: #2597 — CI quality gates broken on master
  • Branch: fix/master-ci-quality-gates
  • Head SHA: 938ea8194c6a2044b17efabea1766995c62eeaf1
  • Max Workers: 16

Current CI Status (as of session start)

Job Status
lint Passing
typecheck Passing
security Passing
quality Passing
build Passing
helm Passing
coverage Passing (≥97%)
integration_tests Passing (1908/1908)
unit_tests FAILING (6m54s)
e2e_tests FAILING (17m37s)
status-check Blocked

UAT Validation Scope

The UAT pool will validate all changes in PR #2629 against the specification:

  1. A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration — verify all step files correctly use method=, id=, jsonrpc=, .result
  2. Session CLI output format — verify Session created, Session Summary, Sessions panel titles
  3. Plan list output format — verify Plans header, Name/Invariants/project columns restored
  4. Plan apply ULID requirement — verify valid ULID required, --yes flag works
  5. ThoughtBlock Pydantic model — verify architecture compliance
  6. DatabaseError handling — verify export_session, import_session, tell handle DB errors
  7. database.py rollback fix — verify rollback_to() uses checkpoint connection
  8. Parallel test isolation — verify TUI fork-safe mock injection, step matcher resets
  9. Alembic migration — verify sessions.name column migration exists and works
  10. Suppression audit — verify no # type: ignore, # noqa, @skip, @xfail added

Post-Merge UAT Plan

After PR #2629 merges, the pool will resume normal UAT testing across all feature areas.


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

## UAT Pool Supervisor — Session Tracker This issue tracks the UAT pool supervisor session for **PR #2629 validation** (Issue #2597). All progress reports will be posted as comments here. Do NOT close this issue manually — it will be closed automatically when the session completes. --- ### Session Context - **Instance ID**: uat-pool-1 - **Priority**: CRITICAL — PR #2629 is the highest-priority PR in the project; all other development is blocked until it merges - **PR**: #2629 — `fix(ci): restore all CI quality gates to passing on master` - **Issue**: #2597 — CI quality gates broken on master - **Branch**: `fix/master-ci-quality-gates` - **Head SHA**: `938ea8194c6a2044b17efabea1766995c62eeaf1` - **Max Workers**: 16 ### Current CI Status (as of session start) | Job | Status | |-----|--------| | lint | ✅ Passing | | typecheck | ✅ Passing | | security | ✅ Passing | | quality | ✅ Passing | | build | ✅ Passing | | helm | ✅ Passing | | coverage | ✅ Passing (≥97%) | | integration_tests | ✅ Passing (1908/1908) | | **unit_tests** | ❌ **FAILING** (6m54s) | | **e2e_tests** | ❌ **FAILING** (17m37s) | | status-check | ❌ Blocked | ### UAT Validation Scope The UAT pool will validate all changes in PR #2629 against the specification: 1. **A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration** — verify all step files correctly use `method=`, `id=`, `jsonrpc=`, `.result` 2. **Session CLI output format** — verify `Session created`, `Session Summary`, `Sessions` panel titles 3. **Plan list output format** — verify `Plans` header, Name/Invariants/project columns restored 4. **Plan apply ULID requirement** — verify valid ULID required, `--yes` flag works 5. **ThoughtBlock Pydantic model** — verify architecture compliance 6. **DatabaseError handling** — verify `export_session`, `import_session`, `tell` handle DB errors 7. **database.py rollback fix** — verify `rollback_to()` uses checkpoint connection 8. **Parallel test isolation** — verify TUI fork-safe mock injection, step matcher resets 9. **Alembic migration** — verify `sessions.name` column migration exists and works 10. **Suppression audit** — verify no `# type: ignore`, `# noqa`, `@skip`, `@xfail` added ### Post-Merge UAT Plan After PR #2629 merges, the pool will resume normal UAT testing across all feature areas. --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester
Author
Owner

UAT Pool Supervisor — Initial Dispatch Report (Cycle 1)

Time: 2026-04-04T19:09Z
PR: #2629fix/master-ci-quality-gates @ 938ea819

Workers Dispatched (10/16 slots filled)

Session ID Feature Area Status
ses_2a61a26e3ffe5ln1h3CRehCj1x a2a-jsonrpc-migration 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a2367ffenowA24g3nDjst4 session-cli-output-format 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a2063ffe42TdUwUajIhsn7 plan-list-output-format 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a1cabffezuNe58zFIl2ViA plan-apply-ulid-requirement 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a198cffe7G5W6ZtYUC6b6L thoughtblock-pydantic-model 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a165effepwXRu9Rh9jjlJX database-error-handling 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a133dffeYZ6AX35mGmGQ6i database-rollback-fix 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a0ef9ffeswAcyLyyf6C2Tn parallel-test-isolation 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a0cb7ffetoaGTFyfRnp7fP alembic-session-name-migration 🔄 Running
ses_2a61a0a6effegpAZnwpua1d2GT suppression-audit 🔄 Running

Remaining Areas (6 slots available for additional testing)

  • ci-workflow-integrity
  • error-recovery-coverage
  • actor-cli-output-format
  • async-audit-recording
  • coverage-threshold-config
  • tdd-tag-compliance

Current CI Blocker Status

  • unit_tests — failing at 6m54s on commit 938ea819
  • e2e_tests — failing at 17m37s on commit 938ea819
  • All other 9 jobs passing

Workers are cloning fix/master-ci-quality-gates and running targeted tests. Results will be posted as they complete.


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

## UAT Pool Supervisor — Initial Dispatch Report (Cycle 1) **Time**: 2026-04-04T19:09Z **PR**: #2629 — `fix/master-ci-quality-gates` @ `938ea819` ### Workers Dispatched (10/16 slots filled) | Session ID | Feature Area | Status | |-----------|-------------|--------| | ses_2a61a26e3ffe5ln1h3CRehCj1x | a2a-jsonrpc-migration | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a2367ffenowA24g3nDjst4 | session-cli-output-format | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a2063ffe42TdUwUajIhsn7 | plan-list-output-format | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a1cabffezuNe58zFIl2ViA | plan-apply-ulid-requirement | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a198cffe7G5W6ZtYUC6b6L | thoughtblock-pydantic-model | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a165effepwXRu9Rh9jjlJX | database-error-handling | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a133dffeYZ6AX35mGmGQ6i | database-rollback-fix | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a0ef9ffeswAcyLyyf6C2Tn | parallel-test-isolation | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a0cb7ffetoaGTFyfRnp7fP | alembic-session-name-migration | 🔄 Running | | ses_2a61a0a6effegpAZnwpua1d2GT | suppression-audit | 🔄 Running | ### Remaining Areas (6 slots available for additional testing) - ci-workflow-integrity - error-recovery-coverage - actor-cli-output-format - async-audit-recording - coverage-threshold-config - tdd-tag-compliance ### Current CI Blocker Status - ❌ `unit_tests` — failing at 6m54s on commit `938ea819` - ❌ `e2e_tests` — failing at 17m37s on commit `938ea819` - ✅ All other 9 jobs passing Workers are cloning `fix/master-ci-quality-gates` and running targeted tests. Results will be posted as they complete. --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester
Author
Owner

UAT Pool Supervisor — Progress Report (Cycle 1, T+15min)

Time: 2026-04-04T19:25Z
PR: #2629fix/master-ci-quality-gates @ 938ea819

Worker Results (14/16 completed or near-complete)

Feature Area Session Status Bugs Filed
a2a-jsonrpc-migration ses_2a61a26e3ffe Complete 0
session-cli-output-format ses_2a61a2367ffe Complete 2 (#2784, #2785)
plan-list-output-format ses_2a61a2063ffe 🔄 Running
plan-apply-ulid-requirement ses_2a61a1cabffe Complete 1 (#2780)
thoughtblock-pydantic-model ses_2a61a198cffe Complete 0
database-error-handling ses_2a61a165effe 🔄 Running
database-rollback-fix ses_2a61a133dffe Complete 0
parallel-test-isolation ses_2a61a0ef9ffe Complete 1 (#2781)
alembic-session-name-migration ses_2a61a0cb7ffe Complete 0
suppression-audit ses_2a61a0a6effe Complete 0
ci-workflow-integrity ses_2a6186cb6ffe Complete 0
error-recovery-coverage ses_2a618693effe Complete 0
actor-cli-output-format ses_2a61864f6ffe Complete 1 (#2775)
async-audit-recording ses_2a61862f1ffe 🔄 Running
coverage-threshold-config ses_2a6186160ffe Complete 2 (#2767, #2769)
tdd-tag-compliance ses_2a6185f01ffe Complete 1 (#2779)

UAT Bugs Filed So Far: 8 total

Issue Title Severity
#2775 UAT: actor context CLI mismatch — robot test uses delete command but source only has remove High
#2779 TDD tag compliance issue in PR #2629 Medium
#2780 Plan apply ULID requirement — minor test coverage gap Low
#2781 PR #2629 incomplete — 6 step files still missing use_step_matcher('parse') reset High
#2784 Session CLI output format — medium severity issue Medium
#2785 Session CLI output format — low severity issue Low
#2767 Coverage threshold config — high severity issue High
#2769 Coverage threshold config — medium severity issue Medium

Key Findings

CLEAN (no issues):

  • A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration — all 10 files correctly updated
  • ThoughtBlock Pydantic model — correctly converted from @dataclass
  • Database rollback fix — checkpoint connection correctly reused
  • Alembic migration — sessions.name column migration exists and is correct
  • Suppression audit — ZERO suppressions added (no type:ignore, noqa, @skip, @xfail)
  • CI workflow integrity — all 11 jobs still required, coverage threshold 97% intact
  • Error recovery coverage — all 4 step file fixes correct

🔴 ISSUES FOUND:

  • Parallel test isolation — 6 step files still missing use_step_matcher("parse") reset (this may be contributing to the unit_tests CI failure)
  • Actor CLI — robot test uses delete command but source only has remove
  • Coverage threshold config — 2 issues found
  • Session CLI output format — 2 minor issues found

CI Status (unchanged from last check)

  • unit_tests — still failing
  • e2e_tests — still failing
  • 9/11 other jobs passing

The use_step_matcher reset issue (#2781) is a strong candidate for the persistent unit_tests CI failure.


Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

## UAT Pool Supervisor — Progress Report (Cycle 1, T+15min) **Time**: 2026-04-04T19:25Z **PR**: #2629 — `fix/master-ci-quality-gates` @ `938ea819` ### Worker Results (14/16 completed or near-complete) | Feature Area | Session | Status | Bugs Filed | |-------------|---------|--------|-----------| | a2a-jsonrpc-migration | ses_2a61a26e3ffe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | session-cli-output-format | ses_2a61a2367ffe | ✅ Complete | **2** (#2784, #2785) | | plan-list-output-format | ses_2a61a2063ffe | 🔄 Running | — | | plan-apply-ulid-requirement | ses_2a61a1cabffe | ✅ Complete | **1** (#2780) | | thoughtblock-pydantic-model | ses_2a61a198cffe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | database-error-handling | ses_2a61a165effe | 🔄 Running | — | | database-rollback-fix | ses_2a61a133dffe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | parallel-test-isolation | ses_2a61a0ef9ffe | ✅ Complete | **1** (#2781) | | alembic-session-name-migration | ses_2a61a0cb7ffe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | suppression-audit | ses_2a61a0a6effe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | ci-workflow-integrity | ses_2a6186cb6ffe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | error-recovery-coverage | ses_2a618693effe | ✅ Complete | 0 | | actor-cli-output-format | ses_2a61864f6ffe | ✅ Complete | **1** (#2775) | | async-audit-recording | ses_2a61862f1ffe | 🔄 Running | — | | coverage-threshold-config | ses_2a6186160ffe | ✅ Complete | **2** (#2767, #2769) | | tdd-tag-compliance | ses_2a6185f01ffe | ✅ Complete | **1** (#2779) | ### UAT Bugs Filed So Far: 8 total | Issue | Title | Severity | |-------|-------|---------| | #2775 | UAT: actor context CLI mismatch — robot test uses `delete` command but source only has `remove` | High | | #2779 | TDD tag compliance issue in PR #2629 | Medium | | #2780 | Plan apply ULID requirement — minor test coverage gap | Low | | #2781 | PR #2629 incomplete — 6 step files still missing `use_step_matcher('parse')` reset | High | | #2784 | Session CLI output format — medium severity issue | Medium | | #2785 | Session CLI output format — low severity issue | Low | | #2767 | Coverage threshold config — high severity issue | High | | #2769 | Coverage threshold config — medium severity issue | Medium | ### Key Findings **✅ CLEAN (no issues):** - A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration — all 10 files correctly updated - ThoughtBlock Pydantic model — correctly converted from @dataclass - Database rollback fix — checkpoint connection correctly reused - Alembic migration — sessions.name column migration exists and is correct - Suppression audit — ZERO suppressions added (no type:ignore, noqa, @skip, @xfail) - CI workflow integrity — all 11 jobs still required, coverage threshold 97% intact - Error recovery coverage — all 4 step file fixes correct **🔴 ISSUES FOUND:** - **Parallel test isolation** — 6 step files still missing `use_step_matcher("parse")` reset (this may be contributing to the `unit_tests` CI failure) - **Actor CLI** — robot test uses `delete` command but source only has `remove` - **Coverage threshold config** — 2 issues found - **Session CLI output format** — 2 minor issues found ### CI Status (unchanged from last check) - ❌ `unit_tests` — still failing - ❌ `e2e_tests` — still failing - ✅ 9/11 other jobs passing The `use_step_matcher` reset issue (#2781) is a strong candidate for the persistent `unit_tests` CI failure. --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester
Author
Owner

UAT Pool Supervisor — FINAL Report (Cycle 1 Complete)

Time: 2026-04-04T19:40Z
PR: #2629fix/master-ci-quality-gates @ 938ea819
Status: PR still open — awaiting CI fix and merge


All 16 Workers Completed

Feature Area Bugs Filed Issues
a2a-jsonrpc-migration 0 All 10 files correctly migrated
session-cli-output-format 2 #2784 (Medium), #2785 (Low)
plan-list-output-format 0 Plans header, all columns restored
plan-apply-ulid-requirement 1 #2780 (Low) — minor test coverage gap
thoughtblock-pydantic-model 0 Correctly converted to Pydantic BaseModel
database-error-handling 1 #2788 (Low) — minor issue
database-rollback-fix 0 Checkpoint connection correctly reused
parallel-test-isolation 1 #2781 (High) — 6 files missing use_step_matcher("parse") reset
alembic-session-name-migration 0 Migration exists and is correct
suppression-audit 0 ZERO suppressions — clean audit
ci-workflow-integrity 0 All 11 CI jobs intact, 97% threshold unchanged
error-recovery-coverage 0 All 4 step file fixes correct
actor-cli-output-format 1 #2775 (High) — robot test uses delete but source has remove
async-audit-recording 0 Settings env var fix correct
coverage-threshold-config 2 #2767 (High), #2769 (Medium)
tdd-tag-compliance 1 #2779 (Medium)

Total Bugs Filed: 9

# Issue Severity Area Description
1 #2775 High Actor CLI Robot test uses delete command but source only has remove
2 #2779 Medium TDD Tags TDD tag compliance issue
3 #2780 Low Plan Apply Minor test coverage gap for ULID requirement
4 #2781 High Parallel Tests 6 step files missing use_step_matcher("parse") reset — likely CI blocker
5 #2784 Medium Session CLI Session CLI output format issue
6 #2785 Low Session CLI Session CLI output format issue
7 #2767 High Coverage Config Coverage threshold config issue
8 #2769 Medium Coverage Config Coverage threshold config issue
9 #2788 Low DB Error Minor database error handling issue

Critical Finding for CI Unblock

Issue #2781 is the most likely root cause of the persistent unit_tests CI failure:

The PR description claims "All step files using use_step_matcher('re') now reset to 'parse' at end" but 6 files were missed:

  1. features/steps/a2a_facade_coverage_boost_steps.py
  2. features/steps/a2a_facade_coverage_steps.py
  3. features/steps/a2a_facade_steps.py
  4. features/steps/a2a_facade_wiring_steps.py
  5. features/steps/postgresql_analyzer_coverage_boost_steps.py
  6. features/steps/server_client_stubs_steps.py

Fix: Add use_step_matcher("parse") at the end of each file.


What's Clean (No Issues)

The following areas of PR #2629 are fully correct and ready to merge:

  • A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration (all 10 files)
  • ThoughtBlock Pydantic BaseModel conversion
  • Database rollback_to() fix
  • Alembic sessions.name migration
  • Suppression audit (ZERO bypasses)
  • CI workflow integrity (all 11 jobs, 97% threshold)
  • Error recovery coverage step fixes
  • Async audit recording fix
  • Plan list output format

Next Steps

  1. Implementation team: Fix issue #2781 (add use_step_matcher("parse") to 6 files) — this should unblock unit_tests CI
  2. After CI goes green: PR #2629 can be merged
  3. After merge: UAT pool will resume normal testing across all feature areas

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester

## UAT Pool Supervisor — FINAL Report (Cycle 1 Complete) **Time**: 2026-04-04T19:40Z **PR**: #2629 — `fix/master-ci-quality-gates` @ `938ea819` **Status**: PR still open — awaiting CI fix and merge --- ### All 16 Workers Completed ✅ | Feature Area | Bugs Filed | Issues | |-------------|-----------|--------| | a2a-jsonrpc-migration | 0 | ✅ All 10 files correctly migrated | | session-cli-output-format | 2 | #2784 (Medium), #2785 (Low) | | plan-list-output-format | 0 | ✅ Plans header, all columns restored | | plan-apply-ulid-requirement | 1 | #2780 (Low) — minor test coverage gap | | thoughtblock-pydantic-model | 0 | ✅ Correctly converted to Pydantic BaseModel | | database-error-handling | 1 | #2788 (Low) — minor issue | | database-rollback-fix | 0 | ✅ Checkpoint connection correctly reused | | parallel-test-isolation | 1 | **#2781 (High)** — 6 files missing `use_step_matcher("parse")` reset | | alembic-session-name-migration | 0 | ✅ Migration exists and is correct | | suppression-audit | 0 | ✅ **ZERO suppressions** — clean audit | | ci-workflow-integrity | 0 | ✅ All 11 CI jobs intact, 97% threshold unchanged | | error-recovery-coverage | 0 | ✅ All 4 step file fixes correct | | actor-cli-output-format | 1 | **#2775 (High)** — robot test uses `delete` but source has `remove` | | async-audit-recording | 0 | ✅ Settings env var fix correct | | coverage-threshold-config | 2 | #2767 (High), #2769 (Medium) | | tdd-tag-compliance | 1 | #2779 (Medium) | --- ### Total Bugs Filed: 9 | # | Issue | Severity | Area | Description | |---|-------|---------|------|-------------| | 1 | #2775 | **High** | Actor CLI | Robot test uses `delete` command but source only has `remove` | | 2 | #2779 | Medium | TDD Tags | TDD tag compliance issue | | 3 | #2780 | Low | Plan Apply | Minor test coverage gap for ULID requirement | | 4 | **#2781** | **High** | Parallel Tests | **6 step files missing `use_step_matcher("parse")` reset — likely CI blocker** | | 5 | #2784 | Medium | Session CLI | Session CLI output format issue | | 6 | #2785 | Low | Session CLI | Session CLI output format issue | | 7 | #2767 | **High** | Coverage Config | Coverage threshold config issue | | 8 | #2769 | Medium | Coverage Config | Coverage threshold config issue | | 9 | #2788 | Low | DB Error | Minor database error handling issue | --- ### Critical Finding for CI Unblock **Issue #2781** is the most likely root cause of the persistent `unit_tests` CI failure: The PR description claims "All step files using `use_step_matcher('re')` now reset to `'parse'` at end" but **6 files were missed**: 1. `features/steps/a2a_facade_coverage_boost_steps.py` 2. `features/steps/a2a_facade_coverage_steps.py` 3. `features/steps/a2a_facade_steps.py` 4. `features/steps/a2a_facade_wiring_steps.py` 5. `features/steps/postgresql_analyzer_coverage_boost_steps.py` 6. `features/steps/server_client_stubs_steps.py` **Fix**: Add `use_step_matcher("parse")` at the end of each file. --- ### What's Clean (No Issues) The following areas of PR #2629 are **fully correct** and ready to merge: - ✅ A2A JSON-RPC 2.0 migration (all 10 files) - ✅ ThoughtBlock Pydantic BaseModel conversion - ✅ Database rollback_to() fix - ✅ Alembic sessions.name migration - ✅ Suppression audit (ZERO bypasses) - ✅ CI workflow integrity (all 11 jobs, 97% threshold) - ✅ Error recovery coverage step fixes - ✅ Async audit recording fix - ✅ Plan list output format --- ### Next Steps 1. **Implementation team**: Fix issue #2781 (add `use_step_matcher("parse")` to 6 files) — this should unblock `unit_tests` CI 2. **After CI goes green**: PR #2629 can be merged 3. **After merge**: UAT pool will resume normal testing across all feature areas --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: UAT Testing | Agent: ca-uat-tester
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#2752
No description provided.