[AUTO-GUARD-1] Duplicate code: Model configuration logic across agents #10558

Open
opened 2026-04-18 17:14:25 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments
Owner

Metadata

  • Commit: AUTO-GUARD-1
  • Branch: architecture-guard/model-config-refactor

Background and Context

Analysis of recent commits reveals potential duplication of model configuration logic across different agent types. The pattern of similar changes to multiple agents (sonnet to haiku migration, model selection tweaks) suggests configuration logic is not properly abstracted.

Category

Duplicate Code - functions or blocks with >70% similarity

Findings

Recent commits show similar changes applied to multiple agents:

  • Commit 435e409: "moved all sonnet agents to haiku" - bulk migration suggests duplication
  • Commit 555509c: "tweaked reasoning level on pr-merge related agents" - multiple agents affected
  • Commit aaeecd1: "reduced cost of models for merging by picking cheaper models" - cost logic duplicated

This indicates:

  1. Model configuration is duplicated across agent definitions
  2. Changes require updates to multiple locations
  3. No centralized model configuration
  4. Risk of inconsistency when updating models

Expected Behavior

Model configuration should be:

  • Centralized in a single registry or configuration module
  • Inherited by agents through a common base or factory pattern
  • Updated in one place to affect all agents consistently
  • Validated to prevent configuration drift

Acceptance Criteria

  • All instances of model configuration across agents are identified and documented
  • Common configuration patterns are extracted and abstracted
  • A centralized model registry is created
  • Configuration inheritance mechanism is implemented for agents
  • Validation rules prevent configuration inconsistencies
  • All agents use the centralized configuration
  • No duplicate model configuration logic remains in agent definitions
  • Test coverage validates configuration consistency across agents

Subtasks

  • Audit all agent definitions to identify model configuration patterns
  • Document current model configuration duplication instances
  • Design centralized model registry architecture
  • Implement model registry module
  • Create configuration inheritance mechanism
  • Refactor agents to use centralized configuration
  • Add validation and consistency checks
  • Update tests to verify configuration consistency
  • Update documentation with new configuration approach

Definition of Done

This issue is complete when:

  1. A centralized model configuration system is implemented and documented
  2. All agents have been refactored to use the centralized configuration
  3. No duplicate model configuration logic exists in agent definitions
  4. Configuration changes can be made in a single location and propagate to all agents
  5. Automated validation prevents configuration drift
  6. Test coverage confirms consistency across all agents
  7. Code review approval from architecture team

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Agent: new-issue-creator

## Metadata - **Commit**: AUTO-GUARD-1 - **Branch**: architecture-guard/model-config-refactor ## Background and Context Analysis of recent commits reveals potential duplication of model configuration logic across different agent types. The pattern of similar changes to multiple agents (sonnet to haiku migration, model selection tweaks) suggests configuration logic is not properly abstracted. ### Category Duplicate Code - functions or blocks with >70% similarity ### Findings Recent commits show similar changes applied to multiple agents: - Commit 435e409: "moved all sonnet agents to haiku" - bulk migration suggests duplication - Commit 555509c: "tweaked reasoning level on pr-merge related agents" - multiple agents affected - Commit aaeecd1: "reduced cost of models for merging by picking cheaper models" - cost logic duplicated This indicates: 1. Model configuration is duplicated across agent definitions 2. Changes require updates to multiple locations 3. No centralized model configuration 4. Risk of inconsistency when updating models ## Expected Behavior Model configuration should be: - Centralized in a single registry or configuration module - Inherited by agents through a common base or factory pattern - Updated in one place to affect all agents consistently - Validated to prevent configuration drift ## Acceptance Criteria - [ ] All instances of model configuration across agents are identified and documented - [ ] Common configuration patterns are extracted and abstracted - [ ] A centralized model registry is created - [ ] Configuration inheritance mechanism is implemented for agents - [ ] Validation rules prevent configuration inconsistencies - [ ] All agents use the centralized configuration - [ ] No duplicate model configuration logic remains in agent definitions - [ ] Test coverage validates configuration consistency across agents ## Subtasks - [ ] Audit all agent definitions to identify model configuration patterns - [ ] Document current model configuration duplication instances - [ ] Design centralized model registry architecture - [ ] Implement model registry module - [ ] Create configuration inheritance mechanism - [ ] Refactor agents to use centralized configuration - [ ] Add validation and consistency checks - [ ] Update tests to verify configuration consistency - [ ] Update documentation with new configuration approach ## Definition of Done This issue is complete when: 1. A centralized model configuration system is implemented and documented 2. All agents have been refactored to use the centralized configuration 3. No duplicate model configuration logic exists in agent definitions 4. Configuration changes can be made in a single location and propagate to all agents 5. Automated validation prevents configuration drift 6. Test coverage confirms consistency across all agents 7. Code review approval from architecture team --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Agent: new-issue-creator
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
cleveragents/cleveragents-core#10558
No description provided.