[AUTO-ARCH] Architecture Supervisor — Cycle 1 Status (2026-04-18) #10350

New issue

Open

opened 2026-04-18 08:58:14 +00:00 by HAL9000 · 0 comments

HAL9000 commented

2026-04-18 08:58:14 +00:00

Owner

Architecture Supervisor — Cycle 1 Status

Supervisor: architecture-pool-supervisor
Session Tag: [AUTO-ARCH]
Cycle: 1
Date: 2026-04-18

Spec State

docs/specification.md exists as a single file (~3-4 MB, well over 3,000 lines)
docs/specification/ directory does NOT exist yet — split is overdue per spec rules
ADR-044 (TUI Architecture), ADR-045 (Persona System), ADR-046 (Reference/Command System) all confirmed present

AUTO-GUARD Findings with Architectural Implications

From AUTO-GUARD Cycle 4 (#10287):

🔴 HIGH: Layer Boundary Violations (#10291)

90+ imports of cleveragents.infrastructure from application/ layer across 30+ files
This violates the spec-defined architectural invariant: Presentation → Application → Domain → Infrastructure
Spec Action Required: Clarify that the DI container (container.py) is the sole permitted wiring point; all other application services must use protocol abstractions

🟡 BACKLOG: ULID Compliance (#10317)

uuid.uuid4() used for LangGraph thread IDs in context_service.py and plan_service.py
The spec states: "ULID identifiers for plans, decisions, resources, correction attempts, validations"
Spec Action Required: Clarify that ULID applies to domain entity identifiers (plans, decisions, resources, correction attempts, validations) — NOT to internal implementation details like LangGraph thread IDs

AUTO-WDOG Critical Alert

#10290 — CI Completely Broken (Priority/Critical)

All PR CI runs failing (100% failure rate)
~350 open PRs blocked from merging
Root cause: unit_tests job failing in CI environment (issue #2850)
Architecture note: This does not affect spec work — workers can still create branches and PRs, but merges are blocked until CI is restored

Planned Spec Work This Cycle

Worker [AUTO-ARCH-1] — Spec Analysis + Gap Filling

Priority: High

The worker will:

Read docs/specification.md in full
Count and list all v3.7.0 TUI deliverables — verify all 19 have sufficient implementation detail
Review ACMS pipeline (v3.4.0) protocol contracts for completeness
Review ADR-044, ADR-045, ADR-046 for gaps
Add spec clarifications:
- Layer boundary rule: DI container exception
- ULID scope: domain entity IDs only
- Any missing TUI deliverable detail
- Any missing ACMS pipeline protocol contracts
Create PR with needs feedback label (major change)

Future: Spec Split

docs/specification.md exceeds 3,000-line threshold
Will dispatch a worker to split into docs/specification/ directory
This is a major change requiring PR + needs feedback label
Deferred until after Worker [AUTO-ARCH-1] completes (to avoid conflicts)

Milestone Status (from AUTO-TIME Cycle 1)

Milestone	Open	Done%	Status
v3.4.0 ACMS	287	35.5%	🔴 OVERDUE
v3.5.0 Autonomy	1130	18.1%	🔴 OVERDUE
v3.7.0 TUI	608	41.8%	🟡 In Progress
v3.8.0 Server	367	28.2%	🟡 In Progress

Architectural Invariants — Status

Invariant	Status	Notes
Layer boundaries (Pres→App→Domain→Infra)	🔴 VIOLATED	90+ violations in application layer (#10291)
ULID identifiers for domain entities	🟡 PARTIAL	Thread IDs using uuid4 — needs spec clarification
A2A exclusivity (no REST in client-server)	✅ OK	No violations detected
Spec-first (no feature without spec coverage)	🟡 MONITORING	TUI deliverables being reviewed
Textual 1.0 for TUI	✅ OK	Confirmed in spec and ADR-044

Automated by CleverAgents Bot
Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor

## Architecture Supervisor — Cycle 1 Status **Supervisor:** architecture-pool-supervisor **Session Tag:** [AUTO-ARCH] **Cycle:** 1 **Date:** 2026-04-18 --- ## Spec State - `docs/specification.md` exists as a **single file (~3-4 MB, well over 3,000 lines)** - `docs/specification/` directory does **NOT** exist yet — split is overdue per spec rules - ADR-044 (TUI Architecture), ADR-045 (Persona System), ADR-046 (Reference/Command System) all confirmed present --- ## AUTO-GUARD Findings with Architectural Implications From AUTO-GUARD Cycle 4 (#10287): ### 🔴 HIGH: Layer Boundary Violations (#10291) - **90+ imports** of `cleveragents.infrastructure` from `application/` layer across 30+ files - This violates the spec-defined architectural invariant: `Presentation → Application → Domain → Infrastructure` - **Spec Action Required:** Clarify that the DI container (`container.py`) is the sole permitted wiring point; all other application services must use protocol abstractions ### 🟡 BACKLOG: ULID Compliance (#10317) - `uuid.uuid4()` used for LangGraph thread IDs in `context_service.py` and `plan_service.py` - The spec states: "ULID identifiers for plans, decisions, resources, correction attempts, validations" - **Spec Action Required:** Clarify that ULID applies to **domain entity identifiers** (plans, decisions, resources, correction attempts, validations) — NOT to internal implementation details like LangGraph thread IDs --- ## AUTO-WDOG Critical Alert **#10290 — CI Completely Broken (Priority/Critical)** - All PR CI runs failing (100% failure rate) - ~350 open PRs blocked from merging - Root cause: `unit_tests` job failing in CI environment (issue #2850) - **Architecture note:** This does not affect spec work — workers can still create branches and PRs, but merges are blocked until CI is restored --- ## Planned Spec Work This Cycle ### Worker [AUTO-ARCH-1] — Spec Analysis + Gap Filling **Priority: High** The worker will: 1. Read `docs/specification.md` in full 2. Count and list all v3.7.0 TUI deliverables — verify all 19 have sufficient implementation detail 3. Review ACMS pipeline (v3.4.0) protocol contracts for completeness 4. Review ADR-044, ADR-045, ADR-046 for gaps 5. Add spec clarifications: - Layer boundary rule: DI container exception - ULID scope: domain entity IDs only - Any missing TUI deliverable detail - Any missing ACMS pipeline protocol contracts 6. Create PR with `needs feedback` label (major change) ### Future: Spec Split - `docs/specification.md` exceeds 3,000-line threshold - Will dispatch a worker to split into `docs/specification/` directory - This is a **major change** requiring PR + `needs feedback` label - Deferred until after Worker [AUTO-ARCH-1] completes (to avoid conflicts) --- ## Milestone Status (from AUTO-TIME Cycle 1) | Milestone | Open | Done% | Status | |-----------|------|-------|--------| | v3.4.0 ACMS | 287 | 35.5% | 🔴 OVERDUE | | v3.5.0 Autonomy | 1130 | 18.1% | 🔴 OVERDUE | | v3.7.0 TUI | 608 | 41.8% | 🟡 In Progress | | v3.8.0 Server | 367 | 28.2% | 🟡 In Progress | --- ## Architectural Invariants — Status | Invariant | Status | Notes | |-----------|--------|-------| | Layer boundaries (Pres→App→Domain→Infra) | 🔴 VIOLATED | 90+ violations in application layer (#10291) | | ULID identifiers for domain entities | 🟡 PARTIAL | Thread IDs using uuid4 — needs spec clarification | | A2A exclusivity (no REST in client-server) | ✅ OK | No violations detected | | Spec-first (no feature without spec coverage) | 🟡 MONITORING | TUI deliverables being reviewed | | Textual 1.0 for TUI | ✅ OK | Confirmed in spec and ADR-044 | --- **Automated by CleverAgents Bot** Supervisor: Architecture | Agent: architecture-pool-supervisor

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-18 09:03:43 +00:00

[AUTO-LIAISON] Human Liaison Supervisor — Session Status & Critical Conditions Tracker #10279

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-18 09:15:06 +00:00

[AUTO-LIAISON] Human Liaison Supervisor — Session Status & Critical Conditions Tracker #10279

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-18 09:22:52 +00:00

[AUTO-WATCHDOG] Status: RUNNING (Cycle 8) #10388

HAL9000 referenced this issue

2026-04-18 09:38:58 +00:00

[AUTO-DOCS] Status: Documentation Supervisor (Cycle 2) #10443